Merit Pay and Pay for Performance in Public Schools
This paper examines pay-for-performance (merit pay) systems in public school education, tracing their origins in 18th-century England through modern American reform efforts. It outlines the potential advantages of merit pay—including accountability, teacher motivation, and reduced demand for school vouchers—alongside key disadvantages such as teaching to the test and resource diversion. The paper reviews findings from the Denver Public Schools pilot program, which showed that improved student achievement stemmed from broader instructional support rather than financial incentives alone. It also covers relevant considerations for implementation, a brief employee communication plan, and the anticipated organizational impact of adopting a pay-for-performance system in a school district.
- Overview of Pay for Performance: History and definition of merit pay systems
- Potential Advantages of Pay for Performance: Accountability, motivation, and voucher reduction
- Potential Disadvantages of Pay for Performance: Subjectivity, resource diversion, teaching to the test
- Effectiveness of Pay for Performance in the Denver School District: Denver pilot outcomes and unexpected findings
- Relevant Considerations in Implementation: Strategic alignment and goal-setting requirements
- Employee Communication and Organizational Impact: Communication plan and district-wide HR implications
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds the discussion in historical context, tracing merit pay from 18th-century England through the No Child Left Behind era, giving readers a clear sense of the policy's cyclical nature.
- Balances competing perspectives by dedicating discrete sections to both advantages and disadvantages before turning to empirical evidence from the Denver pilot program.
- Moves logically from analysis to application, ending with a practical implementation framework and communication plan that ties theory to real-world HR practice.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses the Denver pilot program as a case study to test theoretical claims made in the advantages and disadvantages sections. This evidence-then-analysis structure allows the writer to show that real outcomes (improved achievement driven by instructional support, not financial incentives alone) complicate a simple pro/con framing, adding nuance to the argument.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a definition and historical overview of merit pay, then moves through a balanced advantages-and-disadvantages analysis. The Denver pilot program section provides empirical grounding. The final two sections shift from evaluation to prescription, covering implementation considerations, an employee communication plan, and the anticipated organizational impact on the district. Each section builds on the last, moving from "what is it and where did it come from?" to "does it work?" to "how should we do it?"
Overview of Pay for Performance
Pay for performance, alternatively referred to as "merit pay," is a system in which financial incentives are used to elicit certain levels of performance. This system of pay has been used in education for nearly 300 years and saw a strong revival in the 1980s (Gratz, 2005). The definition of pay for performance changes with the definer and their needs.
No uniform definition of pay for performance exists, even within the educational arena. Despite this fluid nature, the general meaning is a system where merit is determined by a supervisor and performance is arranged to be a more objective measurement. In many pay-for-performance systems within education, both merit and performance are determined by the administration of a test. These tests can either assess the teacher being evaluated — to demonstrate their personal skill and knowledge — or assess the student, to measure achievement (Gratz, 2005). Recently, testing students to determine the effectiveness of their teachers has become the most predominant method of performance assessment, a trend supported by the No Child Left Behind Act.
In the early 1700s, teachers' salaries in certain areas of England were linked directly to their students' scores on examinations in reading, writing, and arithmetic. By the mid-19th century, this practice had been incorporated into the English education system as part of the Revised Education Code, enacted in 1862 (Gratz, 2005). From this point, the pay-for-performance system would see the first of several surges in popularity.
During the following three decades, the pay-for-performance system grew increasingly complex. "Merit grants" were issued for greater efficiency and for expansion of the subjects being taught and tested. Bureaucracy grew significantly as a result. Inspectors became part of the educational system, and examiners who reviewed inspection reports added yet another layer to the educational bureaucracy. Because of this growing bureaucracy, teachers came under intense pressure, as journals from that era indicate. This pressure led to the over-drilling of students to ensure they would meet or surpass the standards required for teachers to receive a favorable assessment (Gratz, 2005).
During this era, upper-class politicians favored this system of compensation, seeing it as a method for restricting the education of the common class. Robert Lowe, Education Minister and a supporter of pay for performance, noted that it would at the very least reduce costs. He stated, "If it is not cheap, it shall be efficient; if it is not efficient, it will be cheap" (as cited in Gratz, 2005). However, Lowe's opinion would not remain mainstream for long.
By 1904, the Board of Education changed its pay policy for teachers. It indicated that teachers were charged with helping children learn and encouraged each teacher to use the best methods suited to the needs and conditions of their students. The Board felt that teachers should continue to test students, but that it was unreasonable to assume a child could keep everything entirely at the call of memory (Gratz, 2005). As such, the single-salary system came into favor and remained so for many more decades.
A Nation at Risk, published in the mid-1980s, refocused the United States on its struggling school systems. It recommended that teachers' compensation be switched to a performance-based system, with backing from President Reagan. This new system rewarded teachers based on supervisor reviews (Gratz, 2005). While the idea of linking effectiveness and efficiency through pay for performance had merit, the system was too subjective to ensure fairness. Today, pay for performance has been revitalized into something close to a human resources mantra, most commonly found as a system of extra compensation for achieving certain predetermined criteria. In education, this is currently most often seen in conjunction with higher student test scores — much like the systems of the 18th and 19th centuries.
References
Brotherton, P. Meyners pays for performance. Journal of Accountancy, 196(1). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.
Gratz, D. B. (2005, April). Lessons from Denver: The pay for performance pilot. Phi Delta Kappan, 86(8). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from ProQuest database.
Pay for performance say Kiwi workers. (2004, June). New Zealand Management, 51(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.
Rishell, M., & Becker, W. (2004, November). Pay for performance: The CFO's stake. Strategic Finance, 86(5). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.
Sturman, M., Trevor, C., Boudreau, J., & Gerhart, B. (2003, Winter). Is it worth it to win the talent war? Evaluating the utility of performance-based pay. Personnel Psychology, 56(4). Retrieved June 13, 2005, from Business Source Premier database.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.