Moral and Legal Questions of Stem Cell Research
This paper examines the moral, ethical, and legal dimensions of stem cell research by analyzing the debate through four major frameworks of jurisprudence: natural law, legal positivism, legal realism, and critical legal studies. Beginning with an overview of what stem cells are and why embryonic stem cell harvesting is controversial, the paper then applies each jurisprudential perspective to the policy debate, evaluating how different views of law and morality lead to different conclusions about the legitimacy of such research. The paper draws historical parallels to slavery and Nazi experimentation, considers President Bush's policy decisions, and ultimately argues that a natural law framework best protects the rights of all parties — including the human embryo.
- Introduction to Stem Cell Research and Its Controversy: Overview of stem cells and the ethical controversy
- Four Frameworks of Jurisprudence: Natural law, positivism, realism, and critical legal studies
- Applying Jurisprudence to the Stem Cell Debate: Each legal framework applied to stem cell policy
- Historical Parallels and Policy Decisions: Slavery, Nazi experimentation, and Bush's policy
- Natural Law and the Rights of the Embryo: Embryo rights and ethical alternatives to harvesting
- Conclusion: Natural law as the guide to moral governance
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper organizes a complex policy debate around a clear analytical framework — the four schools of jurisprudence — giving the argument consistent structure throughout.
- It grounds abstract legal theory in concrete contemporary examples, such as President Bush's stem cell policy, the 2000 presidential election dispute, and federal funding battles.
- Historical analogies (slavery, Nazi experimentation) are used to illustrate the stakes of treating human life as a subordinate interest, adding rhetorical weight to the natural law argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative jurisprudential analysis — taking a single policy question and systematically evaluating it through multiple legal-philosophical lenses before arguing for the superiority of one framework. This technique is common in legal studies and applied ethics courses and shows how theoretical frameworks shape real policy outcomes.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a scientific overview of stem cells and the source of the ethical controversy. It then introduces the four jurisprudential frameworks (natural law, legal positivism, legal realism, critical legal studies) in sequence. The middle sections apply each framework to the stem cell debate and examine real policy decisions. A historical section draws analogies to slavery and Nazi Germany. The paper closes with a natural law argument that the embryo has rights, and that umbilical cord stem cells offer an ethical alternative to embryo harvesting.
Introduction to Stem Cell Research and Its Controversy
Stem cell research is an experimental, research-based study into methods of repairing the human body. By introducing stem cells into a damaged or degenerating area of the body, the medical profession hopes to prompt the body to regrow healthy tissue and repair the damage. Degenerative diseases such as Parkinson's disease or macular degeneration of the eye's retina are conditions in which healthy tissues cease to function properly. There is no overt damage — no disease has physically destroyed the affected body part — but for varying reasons, such as old age, wear and tear, or causes medical science does not yet understand, the affected body part simply ceases to function properly.
Stem cells are the type of cells that are most numerous in, though not limited to, human embryos. They are the building blocks of the blood and immune systems, and potentially of the nervous system, skin, bones, heart, endocrine organs, and other body tissues. During the human growth process, stem cells divide to create the following elements of the blood and immune systems:
- New red blood cells, which carry oxygen.
- New white blood cells, used in the body's immune system for fighting infections.
- New platelets, which help proper clotting of blood and healing.
Because of stem cells' involvement in the process of growing healthy tissue, scientific and medical research is investigating what role, if any, stem cells can play in rebuilding damaged and degenerative tissue.
The controversy revolves around the fact that these cells are most numerous in human embryos. In order to maintain a ready supply of stem cells, processes are being established to grow and harvest these cells from human embryos. Herein lies the controversy: Is it morally, ethically, and legally proper to create life in one innocent being and then destroy it in order to benefit another? Is the embryo a being? If so, the argument leaves the exclusively legal realm and must also be considered on the basis of moral and ethical principles. If the human embryo is not a being but an unviable tissue mass, then growing and harvesting specific cells is neither a moral nor a legal issue. In that latter case, the only laws needed to guide such research are those already in place governing the research and development of disease-resistant cash crops such as corn and wheat.
President Bush entered this debate and signed into law a tightly limited endorsement of federal funding for research on stem cells taken from human embryos. As a result of private research, more than 60 genetically diverse stem cell lines already existed at that time. They were created from embryos that had already been destroyed, and they have the ability to regenerate themselves indefinitely, creating ongoing opportunities for research. The President stated: "I have concluded that we should allow federal funds to be used for research on these existing stem cell lines, where the life-and-death decision has already been made."
The stage on which this battle is waged provides a clear opportunity to investigate the differing perspectives regarding law and how laws govern our society. Understanding these points of view aids comprehension of the arguments and the motives behind those who approach this quandary from opposing corners of the political spectrum. Understanding these viewpoints also allows a deeper comprehension of jurisprudence and how the motives of involved parties affect change in the legal system that guides the nation.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.