Research Paper Graduate 5,388 words

NFL Leadership Crisis: Organizational Change Strategies

~27 min read 7 sections Business · Corporate Strategy

Abstract

This paper examines the organizational challenges facing the National Football League (NFL), including player misconduct, player safety concerns, declining popularity, and ethical lapses in management. Using a structured literature review, the paper applies three key theoretical frameworks — risk management (COSO framework), organizational change models (Lewin, McKinsey 7-S, and Kotter's 8 Step Model), and transformational leadership — to diagnose the NFL's problems and propose a path forward. The paper also explores Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) as a complementary strategy to restore the league's public image. Recommendations include forming a steering committee to conduct a comprehensive risk assessment, appointing transformational leaders as change agents, and adopting a robust CSR reporting framework to strengthen stakeholder trust and long-term sustainability.

Key Takeaways

Executive Summary and Overview: NFL popularity decline and leadership crisis overview
Organizational Background and Problem Statement: NFL history, revenue, and multifaceted organizational problems
Theoretical Framework: Risk Management and Organizational Change: COSO, Lewin, McKinsey, and Kotter change models applied to NFL
Leadership Models and Transformational Leadership: Transformational leadership as optimal NFL change agent model
Corporate Social Responsibility in the NFL: CSR programs, reporting frameworks, and NFL community initiatives
Findings and Synthesis: Risk management and leadership models as reform foundation
Recommendations and Future Research: Steering committee, change strategy, and future research directions

✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

The paper anchors its argument in concrete, publicly available data — the drop in NFL popularity from 36% to 32% between 2011 and 2015 — giving the organizational diagnosis a measurable foundation rather than relying purely on anecdote.
It applies multiple established theoretical frameworks (Lewin, McKinsey 7-S, Kotter, COSO, transformational leadership) in a comparative fashion, weighing the strengths and limitations of each in the specific context of the NFL's decentralized structure.
The CSR section effectively bridges normative ethics and business strategy by citing KPMG survey data and the IIRC framework, showing how social responsibility also serves financial objectives.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates applied theory mapping — selecting models from the management literature and systematically evaluating their fit against the unique structural features of a target organization. For example, it notes that the McKinsey 7-S model's assumption of equal factor influence may be unsuitable given the NFL's thirty-two culturally distinct franchises, while Kotter's campaign-oriented model may be better aligned with the league's independent stakeholder structure.

Structure breakdown

The paper follows a five-section consulting-report structure: (1) problem identification and scope, (2) background and definitional grounding, (3) theoretical literature review covering risk, change, leadership, and CSR, (4) investigative methodology and findings, and (5) recommendations and implications. This scaffolding mirrors a professional management report format and is well-suited for graduate-level business analysis assignments.

📘 Read the full research paper guide → Generate citations → Build an outline → Draft a literature review → 📚 More Corporate Strategy examples →

Essay 5,388 words

Executive Summary and Overview

The National Football League (NFL) is currently the most popular sport with American adults; however, this position is not guaranteed to remain indefinitely. The NFL is plagued by a range of problems spanning player misconduct and serious indiscretions both on and off the field, issues related to injuries, player safety, and brain damage from multiple concussions, conflicts with the players' union and team salary caps, diminishing ticket sales for some teams, a lack of diversity among head coaches, ethics issues in management, and many more. Because of these major problems, many loyal fans are becoming increasingly disenfranchised with the league, and the overall popularity of professional football in the U.S. is slowly declining. In 2011, 36% of Americans surveyed stated that pro-football was their favorite sport; by 2015, that figure had dropped to 32%. Major League Baseball (MLB) has gained significant traction against the NFL in terms of popularity in recent years.

This analysis focuses on leadership — or the lack thereof — in the NFL, from the highest executive levels down to individual players, from a critical perspective. It is argued that an intervention is needed to mitigate the damage the NFL has incurred in recent years, and that this intervention must take the form of an organizational change led by transformational leadership. This report surveys best practices found in the academic literature regarding organizational change and leadership and relates these models to the NFL's current position.

Organizational Background and Problem Statement

The NFL has a rich tradition and heritage as the preeminent sports organization since its inception. The league was organized in the 1920s when ten teams came together under the American Professional Football Association, which later became the National Football League when it established a nationwide presence. Although other football leagues attempted to build a national competition, the NFL was the first to do so successfully. After its founding, the league slowly became more formalized in terms of membership, rules, and a governing body.

The NFL merged with another successful league, the American Football League (AFL), in the 1960s, creating an even larger organization and producing the Super Bowl. At that time, the league settled on thirty-two teams that still represent today's NFL. The Super Bowl has since become the most watched sporting event in the U.S., and the NFL has become the most popular spectator sport according to a variety of polls. The NFL was projected to have total revenue of more than twelve billion dollars in 2015, up over a billion dollars from the previous year (Kaplan, 2015). The NFL remains the top revenue-generating league in U.S. sports; MLB registers about $9 billion annually, the NBA $5 billion, and the NHL $3.6 billion (Kaplan, 2015).

There are several problems the NFL currently faces that are arguably rooted in a lack of leadership. From the bottom up, there are issues with player discipline. At the team level, there are challenges related to head coaching functions. And at the league level, the organization faces several broader structural and cultural problems.

The opportunity within this situation is to implement an organizational change initiative from the top down. Since the problems associated with the NFL are multifaceted and occur across multiple levels, an organizational — or cultural — change is needed. This analysis attempts to identify the change mechanisms that can help the NFL institute such an initiative.

Definition of Key Terms

Change Management: Minimizing resistance to organizational change through involvement of key players and stakeholders (Business Dictionary, n.d.).

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): Programs that an organization implements to address social or environmental issues either internally or externally.

Organizational Change: A company or organization going through a transformation. Organizational change occurs when business strategies or major sections of an organization are altered; also known as reorganization, restructuring, or turnaround (Business Dictionary, n.d.).

Transformational Leadership: A style of leadership in which the leader identifies the needed change, creates a vision to guide the change through inspiration, and executes the change with the commitment of the group's members (Business Dictionary, n.d.).

Risk Management: The identification, analysis, assessment, control, and avoidance, minimization, or elimination of unacceptable risks. An organization may use risk assumption, risk avoidance, risk retention, risk transfer, or any other strategy (or combination of strategies) in the proper management of future events (Business Dictionary, n.d.).

Relevant Organizational Processes and Systems

The processes, systems, and functions of the NFL can be understood on two broad levels. The first and broadest level is the league's executive management team and its administrative professionals. This group sets high-level strategy for the organization and is responsible for the league's overall success. The second level is the team level. Although each team pursues its own self-interest — primarily winning the Super Bowl — there is also an alignment with the league's broader goals. Each team benefits individually when the entire league does better: increased league popularity translates to higher ticket sales, individual revenue streams, viewership, and merchandise sales for every franchise.

The relevant theories applicable to the NFL broadly mirror those found in other types of organizations across industries. Organizations have an executive team responsible for setting strategy, which is then implemented on a tactical level by middle managers and employees. In the NFL, teams implement the strategic objectives set by the league, and although the tactical goals are different (such as winning football games), much of a head coach's job mirrors the responsibilities found in positions such as a regional manager in other industries. Therefore, for the scope of this research project, the literature review focuses on broad-level concepts applicable across different levels of any organization, including the NFL.

5 Sections Hidden · 2,690 words

Theoretical Framework: Risk Management and Organizational Change780 words

Risk management can serve as the cornerstone of a strategy platform in many organizations. Since the league is currently facing a decrease in popularity relative…

Leadership Models and Transformational Leadership680 words

Leadership is one of the most fundamental aspects of running a successful organization and can be considered arguably the single largest critical success factor. Leadership can be broadly defined as a leader's ability to shift…

Corporate Social Responsibility in the NFL590 words

Many would argue that the NFL is in a position in which it must maintain an ethical stance relative to its fans, given that many individuals and children see the various players and stakeholders as role models and often emulate their behaviors. Although many CSR initiatives are commonly thought of as corporate philanthropy,…

Findings and Synthesis280 words

An initial investigation identified a wide range of problems in the NFL, including player misconduct and serious indiscretions both on and off the field, issues related to injuries, player safety, and brain damage from multiple concussions, conflicts with the players' union and team salary caps, diminishing ticket sales for some teams, a lack of diversity among head coaches, ethics issues in management, and many more. A literature review was conducted to determine which models can assist…

Recommendations and Future Research360 words

The preliminary analysis identified evidence that the NFL has lost some popularity relative to baseball and other professional sports in recent years. It is reasonable to suspect that much of this trend is…

View Full Document

References

Bass, B. (1985). Leadership and performance beyond expectations. New York: Free Press.

Bass, B. (1999). Two decades of research and development in transformational leadership. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 9–32.

Benta, D. (2011). On best practices for risk management in complex projects. Informatica Economica, 142–152.

Business Dictionary. (n.d.). Change management. Retrieved from Business Dictionary:

Business Dictionary. (n.d.). Organizational change. Retrieved from Business Dictionary:

Business Dictionary. (n.d.). Risk management. Retrieved from Business Dictionary:

Business Dictionary. (n.d.). Transformational leadership. Retrieved from Business Dictionary:

Cho, C., Michelon, G., & Patten, D. (2012). Impression management in sustainability reports: An empirical investigation of the use of graphs. Accounting and the Public Interest, 12(1), 16–37.

COSO. (2004). Enterprise risk management. Treadway Commission, 1–7.

Floyd, P. (2002). Organizational change. London: Capstone Publishing.

Goodell, R. (2011, June 15). A letter from the commissioner. Retrieved from NFL: http://www.nfl.com/news/story/09000d5d82054f96/article/a-letter-from-the-commissioner

Green, M. (2007). Change management masterclass. London: Kogan Page.

Gunther, M. (2007, February 3). The NFL and CSR. Retrieved from Business Sustainability:

Hollmann, J. (2009). Recommended practices for risk analysis and cost contingency estimating. AACE International Transactions, 1–14.

Hughen, L., Lulseged, A., & Upton, D. (2014). Improving stakeholder value through sustainability and integrated reporting. The CPA Journal, 57–61.

Judge, J., & Bono, J. (2000). Five factor model of personality and transformational leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology, 751–765.

Kaplan, D. (2015, March 9). NFL projecting revenue increase of $1B over 2014. Retrieved from Street & Smith's Sports Business: http://www.sportsbusinessdaily.com/Journal/Issues/2015/03/09/Leagues-and-Governing-Bodies/NFL-revenue.aspx

Klein, T. (2011, January 16). John Kotter's 8 steps change model. Retrieved from A Doctoral Journey:

Lim, B., & Ployhart, R. (2004). Transformational leadership: Relations to the five factor model and team performance in typical and maximum contexts. Journal of Applied Psychology, 610–621.

NFL. (n.d.). Community programs. Retrieved from NFL: http://www.nfl.com/community

Ross, S., & Offerman, L. (1997). Transformational leadership: Measurement of personality attributes and work group performance. Personality and Social Psychology, 1078–1094.

Searcy, C., & Buslovich, R. (2014). Corporate perspectives on the development and use of sustainability reports. Journal of Business Ethics, 121(2), 149–169.

Turner, R., & Muller, R. (2005). The project manager's leadership style as a success factor on projects: A literature review. Project Management Journal, 49–61.

U.S. News. (n.d.). Should football be fundamentally changed to make it safer? Retrieved from U.S. News and World Report: http://www.usnews.com/debate-club/should-football-be-fundamentally-changed-to-make-it-safer

USBR. (n.d.). Emergency plans. Retrieved August 22, 2012, from

Zita, I. (2011, May 13). How to develop a risk management plan. Retrieved from Risk Management:

Key Concepts in This Paper

Transformational Leadership Organizational Change Risk Management Kotter's 8 Steps McKinsey 7-S Lewin Model COSO Framework Corporate Social Responsibility Player Safety NFL Popularity Change Management