Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 719 words

Parens Patriae vs. the Get Tough Movement in Juvenile Justice

~4 min read 5 sections Law · Juvenile Justice System
Abstract

This paper examines two contrasting approaches to juvenile justice: the historical doctrine of parens patriae and the modern "get tough" movement. Tracing parens patriae from its fourteenth-century English origins through its adoption in American courts, the paper explains how the doctrine obligated the state to act as a guardian for children whose parents failed them. It then analyzes how political pressures in the late 1970s drove a punitive shift toward mandatory sentencing, secure confinement, and juvenile curfews — policies critics argue were shaped more by media sensationalism and electoral politics than by evidence about juvenile crime.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Framing question contrasting parens patriae and get tough
  • The History of Parens Patriae: Origins and meaning of parens patriae doctrine
  • The Get Tough Movement: Political drivers of punitive juvenile justice policies
  • Policy Examples: New York and Juvenile Curfews: New York law and curfews as get tough measures
  • Conclusion: Assessment of both approaches and future outlook
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper anchors its argument in a clear historical framework, tracing parens patriae from its medieval English origins before explaining how U.S. policy diverged from that tradition.
  • It draws on multiple criminology textbooks and policy studies to support claims, giving the analysis academic grounding even at a short length.
  • The contrast between the two philosophies — rehabilitative guardianship versus punitive politics — is stated directly and reinforced with a concrete state-level policy example (New York's Juvenile Offender Law).

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper uses comparative analysis, placing two policy philosophies side by side and showing how one replaced the other over time. By quoting authors who explicitly label the New York law "the antithesis of the parens patriae philosophy," the student allows authoritative sources to carry the evaluative weight of the argument rather than relying solely on personal assertion.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a framing question, then dedicates one section to the origins and meaning of parens patriae and a second section to the political and social forces behind the get tough movement. A third section applies both frameworks to concrete policy examples — mandatory sentencing in New York and juvenile curfews — before closing with a brief normative conclusion. The structure is straightforward and mirrors a classic compare-and-contrast essay format.

Essay 719 words

Introduction

How was the "get tough" movement different from the original parens patriae concept? This paper reviews both approaches to handling juvenile offenders — the rehabilitative tradition rooted in parens patriae and the punitive philosophy that came to dominate juvenile justice policy in the late twentieth century.

The History of Parens Patriae

The system known as parens patriae was developed many centuries ago, beginning in the late fourteenth century, according to the textbook Juvenile Delinquency: An Integrated Approach. Early in the fifteenth century, parens patriae cases — governed by what became known as "equity law" — were brought before courts in England. In time, parens patriae was imported to the United States, because many of the legal traditions adopted by American settlers derived from English law (Burfeind, 2011, p. 13).

Originally, the Latin phrase parens patriae meant "parent of the country." In England it granted "far-reaching power" to the King as the ultimate ruler and guardian of the nation and its people, serving primarily as a means to settle disputes involving property rights (Burfeind, p. 13). Alongside that authority, however, the King was obliged under parens patriae to give back — to assist vulnerable and dependent groups, including children.

As the doctrine relates to juvenile justice in the United States, parens patriae ultimately transitioned into the principle that courts had both the right and the duty to "exercise parental duties" when parents were absent or failing to provide adequate care for their children (Burfeind, p. 14). In practice, American policy became one of supervising, educating, and providing discipline for children and adolescents rather than simply punishing them.

3 Sections Hidden · 365 words
The Get Tough Movement185 words
A significant body of literature characterizes the "get tough" movement as a politically driven response to public anxiety over juvenile crime. In the late 1970s, according to authors Preston Elrod and Scott…
Policy Examples: New York and Juvenile Curfews110 words
A notable example of the "get tough" approach was New York State's Juvenile Offender Law, which provided for "automatic placement in criminal court, long sentences, mandated secure confinement, low age jurisdiction," and an emphasis on protecting the community, its people, and its property (McGarrell, 1988, p. 178). McGarrell observed that the punishment imposed under this law was…
Conclusion70 words
The juvenile justice system is unlikely to return fully to the parens patriae philosophy that once guided it. The "get tough" era shifted the focus from rehabilitation and guardianship…

Works Cited

Burfeind, J. W., and Bartusch, D. (2011). Juvenile Delinquency: An Integrated Approach. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.

Elrod, P., and Ryder, S. (2011). Juvenile Justice: A Social, Historical and Legal Perspective. Burlington, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.

McGarrell, E. F. (1988). Juvenile Correctional Reform: Two Decades of Policy and Procedural Change. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.

Siegel, L., and Welsh, B. (2010). Juvenile Delinquency: The Core. Independence, KY: Cengage Learning.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Parens Patriae Get Tough Movement Juvenile Justice Punitive Policy Mandatory Sentencing Juvenile Curfews Media Influence Equity Law Juvenile Offenders Criminal Court Transfer
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Parens Patriae vs. the Get Tough Movement in Juvenile Justice. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/parens-patriae-vs-get-tough-juvenile-justice-190513

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.