Predator Drones in Afghanistan: Deterrence and Just War Ethics
This paper presents a preliminary research engagement examining the use of U.S. Predator unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) in Afghanistan, focusing on whether their deployment effectively deters enemy combatants from planting improvised explosive devices (IEDs). The paper formulates a central research question and hypothesis, then applies two contrasting theoretical models — Rational Deterrence Theory and Just War Theory — to evaluate the ethical and strategic dimensions of drone warfare. It also outlines both quantitative and qualitative research approaches for testing the hypothesis, and briefly reviews a relevant article addressing civilian casualty counting practices. The discussion highlights tensions between operational deterrence goals and ethical obligations under just war principles.
- Introduction: Ethical stakes of U.S. drone warfare introduced
- Research Question and Hypothesis: Drone deterrence of IEDs in Afghanistan examined
- Theoretical Models: Deterrence and Just War theories applied to drones
- Research Approach: Quantitative and qualitative research methods outlined
- Article Review: Hahn's critique of civilian casualty counting reviewed
- Conclusion: Tensions between deterrence goals and ethical standards
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly articulates a focused research question and testable hypothesis before introducing theoretical models, giving the discussion a logical, scaffolded structure.
- It productively juxtaposes two contrasting theoretical lenses — Rational Deterrence Theory and Just War Theory — to show the inherent tension in drone policy rather than oversimplifying the issue.
- The paper acknowledges both quantitative and qualitative methodological pathways, demonstrating methodological awareness appropriate for a research proposal format.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models the structure of a preliminary research proposal by moving systematically from problem statement to research question, hypothesis, theoretical framework, methodology, and source review. This scaffolding technique is especially effective in political science and military ethics writing, where grounding an argument in competing theoretical models adds analytical depth without overreaching the available evidence.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad contextual introduction establishing the ethical stakes of drone warfare. It then narrows to a specific research question and hypothesis about IED deterrence in Afghanistan. Two theoretical models are introduced and compared. The research approach section outlines both quantitative and qualitative methods for testing the hypothesis. The paper closes with an article review that complicates the hypothesis by raising concerns about civilian casualty classification. This progression — from claim to theory to method to evidence — mirrors a standard research proposal format.
Introduction
Making war is a political and military process that challenges our assumptions about ethical orientation and the performance of justice. The United States' use of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) such as the Predator drone is intended to minimize loss of life among military personnel. However, even as this tactic takes American soldiers out of harm's way, it blurs the lines between military and civilian targets on the ground. The result is pressure to scrutinize this approach to warfare within the context of a comprehensive research discussion, with a primary intent of examining this method of warfare through appropriate theoretical models.
Works Cited
Bird, S.J. (2006). Research Ethics, Research Integrity and the Responsible Conduct of Research. Science and Engineering Ethics (12), 411–412.
Hahn, N.G. (2012). Time for a Just Drone Theory. Real Clear Politics.
Moore, W.H. (2001). Evaluating Theory in Political Science. [University].
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.