The Secret: The Power by Rhonda Byrne — A Critical Review
This paper offers a critical review of Rhonda Byrne's 2010 self-help book The Secret: The Power, which argues that positive thinking and the "law of attraction" can bring anyone wealth, health, and happiness. The review challenges Byrne's central thesis by contrasting it with more sophisticated philosophical treatments of happiness — including Aristotle's concept of eudaimonia — and by examining her misuse of figures such as Gandhi. The paper also critiques her ignorance of structural economic inequality, the 2008 financial crisis, racial injustice in America, the problem of evil, and the Nazi era, ultimately situating the book within the long tradition of individualistic, middle-class American self-help literature.
- Introduction: The Secret: The Power and Its Appeal: Overview of Byrne's bestseller and central thesis
- Byrne's Law of Attraction and the Power of Love: Detailing Byrne's claims about love and attraction
- Philosophical Failures: Happiness, Virtue, and Misquoted Heroes: Aristotle, Gandhi, and Byrne's shallow worldview
- Ignoring Economic Reality: The Financial Crisis and Inequality: Byrne ignores the 2008 crash and structural poverty
- Race, Civil Rights, and Structural Injustice: Civil rights history exposes Byrne's blind spots
- The Problem of Evil and the Limits of Positive Thinking: Nazi history reveals positive thinking's bankruptcy
- The Self-Help Tradition and Byrne's Place Within It: Byrne as product of American self-help tradition
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review maintains a consistent critical voice throughout, using specific textual evidence — including a direct quotation from Byrne misappropriating Gandhi — to substantiate its arguments rather than relying on vague dismissal.
- It grounds its critique in concrete intellectual traditions (Aristotelian ethics, Keynesian economics, civil rights history) that expose the shallowness of Byrne's claims by contrast, making the critique analytically rich rather than merely polemical.
- The scope deliberately widens from individual philosophy to macroeconomics to historical atrocity, demonstrating that Byrne's solipsistic worldview fails at every level of social reality.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of comparative critique: rather than simply asserting that Byrne is wrong, the author juxtaposes her claims against well-established intellectual frameworks — Aristotle on happiness, Gandhi on social justice, the history of the 2008 financial crisis, and the civil rights movement — so that each comparison does its own argumentative work. This technique allows the critique to build cumulatively without requiring the author to construct an independent positive thesis.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a summary of Byrne's commercial success and central thesis, then systematically dismantles it across six areas: the philosophical inadequacy of her conception of happiness, her misuse of historical figures, her obliviousness to economic crisis and structural inequality, her blindness to racial injustice, her failure to account for evil, and finally her place in the long American self-help tradition. The conclusion ties these threads together by framing Byrne as a product of that tradition rather than a deviation from it.
Introduction: The Secret: The Power and Its Appeal
Rhonda Byrne's The Secret: The Power (2010) is, by any serious intellectual measure, a remarkably bad book — simplistic, repetitive, and entirely divorced from real history, politics, or economics — yet it has sold 19 million copies. A cynic might say that the real secret to wealth is writing a bestselling book that millions will buy. Her 2006 book The Secret also sold over 19 million copies and was translated into 46 languages; she was subsequently a guest on the Oprah Winfrey Show and many other daytime television programs. Like all self-help writers, she has a talent for publishing essentially the same advice repeatedly in new books that claim to offer even greater insights than past philosophers and religious teachers. In 2007, Byrne wrote The Secret Gratitude Book, followed a year later by The Secret: Daily Teachings.
Her latest offering is approximately 250 pages long and quickly appeared on the bestseller lists, which indicates the kind of strong cult following that all publishers desire. Byrne's central thesis is that human beings can change their entire lives and obtain everything they want simply by wishing for it — including money, wealth, happiness, fulfilling careers, and romantic relationships. This magical Power is grounded in love, or the so-called law of attraction, by which every individual can engage in wishful thinking that will supposedly guarantee a life full of love, happiness, and unlimited wealth.
Byrne's Law of Attraction and the Power of Love
Byrne believed that everyone possesses this unlimited Power over their life circumstances, and that all wealthy and successful people throughout history have used it — whether they knew it or not — to obtain everything they desired. No special religious or ideological belief is necessary to activate the Power, which can manifest in the form of lucky charms, miraculous cures from illness, and good fortune. This secret Power of love, she argues, already exists within everyone, even though most people remain unaware of it. Love, in her framework, is the greatest force in the universe.
Love is presented as a great force or law of nature comparable to gravity, nuclear power, and electricity — and in fact stronger than any of these. It is more than an emotion; it is governed by laws of attraction that can be harnessed to give every person total control over their life, and it can be activated through the power of positive thinking. As Byrne repeats throughout, the Power is a scientific law rather than magic or religion: anyone who generates good or bad thoughts and feelings will receive the same in return. Emotions are described as literally magnetic frequencies that attract similar emotions, and good feelings operate on a positive frequency that draws love and abundance.
People, she insists, have the Power to create their own reality, and everything they hate or fear — including poverty, hunger, illness, and failed relationships — will be drawn to them by their own negativity. Using the Power requires eliminating hate, greed, envy, malice, irritability, despair, and insecurity, replacing these with love. Once all negative feelings are gone, money will naturally flow toward those who radiate positive energy, while worrying about finances only drives wealth away. Byrne insists that "you are what you feel," and that reacting to the negative with bad feelings only attracts more negativity. She extends this further: one can have anything simply by visualizing it.
Her advice for improving the careers, love lives, and health of her predominantly white, female, middle-class audience is to let love become the governing principle of life above all other ideas or emotions. She claimed to be the first to discover this central truth — rather than Jesus Christ or any of the great scholars, prophets, scientists, and philosophers of history — and asserted that once people embrace her teachings, they will be kind to one another, cease worrying and complaining, and attract the houses, cars, jobs, money, and security they desire. They will no longer grow old or sick, will be free from pain and disease, and will spend their time performing only acts of kindness and generosity. In short, the Power to create everything, change everything, and obtain anything the heart desires already lies within — if only humanity could learn to use it.
People can supposedly get anything they want, from parking spots to cures for disease, simply by wishing for them and pretending they already possess these things. Even water, Byrne claims, responds to love and positive feelings by becoming energized and harmonized, while it becomes chaotic and de-energized when exposed to negative vibrations. This matters, she argues, because the body and the brain are approximately 80% water, meaning that negative thoughts and emotions produce damaging physical and psychological effects. Byrne professes to feel love, gratitude, and bliss for every moment in life and for the entire universe — not least, one might observe, because she has become a millionaire from book sales and television appearances. She appears to regard the universe as a giant slot machine that pays out fulfilled wishes in exchange for every positive thought and emotion.
References
Byrne, R. (2010). The Secret: The Power. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.