Torture, Utilitarianism, and Deontology in the War on Terror
This paper analyzes the ethics of torture as an interrogation technique in the context of post-9/11 counterterrorism policy. Drawing on utilitarian philosophy, the paper argues that torture fails to produce reliable information, undermines social cohesion, and contradicts the goal of achieving the greatest good for the greatest number. A deontological counter-position—asserting that states have a duty to protect citizens by any means necessary—is then presented and critiqued. The paper concludes by defending utilitarianism, contending that justice is the foundation of a functioning society and that engaging in torture ultimately compounds harm, provokes retaliation, and erodes the very moral principles that distinguish democratic states from their adversaries.
- Introduction: Torture as flawed counterterrorism tool introduced
- The Utilitarian Position on Torture: Torture fails utilitarian test of common good
- Weaknesses of Utilitarianism: The Deontological Counter-Position: Deontology argues states have duty to use torture
- Defense of Utilitarianism Against Deontology: Justice and rights rebut deontological pro-torture case
- Conclusion: Utilitarianism upheld; torture harms everyone
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses a clear dialectical structure — stating a position, presenting a counter-argument, and then defending the original view — which gives the argument a logical and persuasive arc.
- Historical illustration (the Soviet use of forced confessions) is deployed effectively to ground abstract ethical claims in concrete, real-world consequences.
- The paper balances philosophical terminology with accessible language and vivid analogies (e.g., "opening Pandora's Box," "dynamite in a crowded room"), making complex ethical frameworks readable.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the technique of dialectical argumentation: it does not merely assert a thesis but anticipates the strongest objection (the deontological duty-based case for torture) and refutes it. This approach strengthens the original utilitarian claim by showing it can withstand serious challenge, a hallmark of rigorous philosophical writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an introduction that frames the problem and previews the argument. The second section develops the utilitarian case against torture using both theoretical grounding (Mill, Fox) and practical examples. The third section steelmans the deontological counter-position before the fourth section rebuts it by invoking justice as a foundational social value. A brief conclusion ties the argument back to Mill's own words on protecting individuals from coercive social practices.
Introduction
Since the rise of terrorism in the wake of 9/11, numerous tactics have been tried in order to obtain information about where terrorists are hiding and where they might strike next. One of these methods is torture. From a utilitarian perspective, torture should be viewed as an unethical approach to problem-solving. The central problem with this approach is that it simply does not work. A person who is being tortured cannot be trusted to tell the truth. Confessions made under duress are not admissible in a court of law for the straightforward reason that when someone is promised the pain will stop if they simply "confess," that confession cannot be considered unbiased or objective. There is a clear incentive to confess — that is, to end the torture.
Torture as a tool for procuring the truth is therefore a flawed approach to tackling the issue of terrorism, for which it has been re-introduced into the American counterterrorism playbook. If torture is not a useful device for obtaining information, then what is it useful for? This paper answers that question by examining the issue through the ethical framework of utilitarianism. It then identifies weaknesses in the utilitarian viewpoint and challenges this perspective from the standpoint of deontology. It concludes with a defense of utilitarianism against the deontological counter-position with respect to torture.
Works Cited
Fox, James. "Utilitarianism." The Catholic Encyclopedia. NY: Robert Appleton Company, 1912.
Mill, J. S. On Liberty. London: John W. Parker and Son, West Strand, 1859.
Sandel, Michael. Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? NY: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.