Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 4,386 words

Torture, Ticking Time-Bombs, and Dershowitz's Judicial Warrant Proposal

~22 min read 6 sections Ethics · Utilitarian Ethics
Abstract

This paper examines the moral, legal, and philosophical dimensions of torture in the context of the "ticking time-bomb" scenario. Drawing primarily on Alan Dershowitz's arguments, it surveys the United Nations' definition of torture, the historical origins of the ticking bomb hypothetical, and utilitarian perspectives from Bentham and Voltaire. The paper critically evaluates Dershowitz's controversial proposal for judicially sanctioned torture warrants as a means of ensuring accountability in democratic societies, while also considering the Israeli Landau Commission's approach to terrorism and necessity. Ultimately, the paper weighs whether legalizing torture in extreme cases serves national security or undermines civil liberties and human dignity.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Defining Torture Under International Law: UN Convention Against Torture definition and scope
  • Dershowitz on Torture and Judicial Accountability: Dershowitz's case for judicially sanctioned torture warrants
  • The Ticking Time-Bomb Hypothesis: Origins and moral stakes of the ticking bomb scenario
  • Dershowitz on Bentham, Voltaire, and the Ethics of Torture: Utilitarian and philosophical frameworks applied to torture
  • The Israeli Government Approach and the Fourth Road: Landau Commission, necessity doctrine, and Israel's counter-terrorism law
  • Conclusion: Torture, Liberty, and Democratic Values: Weighing human dignity against national security trade-offs
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It anchors the discussion in a concrete legal framework — the UN Convention Against Torture — before moving into philosophical and policy debate, giving the argument a credible empirical foundation.
  • It faithfully traces Dershowitz's evolving reasoning rather than caricaturing it, presenting his judicial warrant proposal as a response to hypocrisy rather than an endorsement of torture.
  • It balances multiple voices — Bentham's utilitarianism, the Israeli Landau Commission, Sung's critique — so the paper reads as a genuine survey rather than a one-sided polemic.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates sustained use of secondary source synthesis: it draws on a single primary thinker (Dershowitz) and triangulates his claims against legal scholarship (Strauss, Sung), philosophical tradition (Bentham, Voltaire), and comparative government practice (Israel's Landau Commission). This multi-source triangulation allows the writer to evaluate rather than merely report Dershowitz's position.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a definitional section establishing what torture means under international law, then moves through four numbered analytical sections — Dershowitz's framework, the ticking bomb hypothesis, utilitarian philosophical context, and the Israeli case study — before a conclusion that synthesizes the civil-liberties trade-off. The numbered section structure mirrors an argumentative progression from definition to case analysis to normative judgment, which is appropriate for an ethics or legal-studies paper at the undergraduate level.

Essay 4,386 words

Introduction: Defining Torture Under International Law

In 1984, the United Nations General Assembly produced an advisory measure known as the United Nations Convention Against Torture. This document specifically addressed torture from the perspective of governments and states, while also focusing on the use of torture by any individual acting in an official capacity for said state or government. The document additionally addressed other forms of "cruel and inhumane treatment." Two other aspects of this convention are important: any government or state is forbidden to extradite individuals to a nation where it is reasonably possible that they might be tortured, and governments or states are required to act effectively to halt and/or block the use of torture within their borders. Evidence obtained through torture is likewise forbidden from use in any legal proceedings or courts.

The definition of torture specifically excludes actions involved in lawful sanctions — presumably such as the death penalty, but also perhaps the "accidental injury" of a suspect during the events leading up to his arrest. With this sole exclusion, torture was defined as those acts by which physical and/or mental suffering and/or pain are intentionally imposed upon an individual as part of an effort to obtain information (Ticking Time Bomb and Torture, n.d.). Factors involved in this definition include prohibition of any such acts by any public official, the deliberate intentionality of the act regardless of the reasons and/or justifications put forth for its necessity, and the use of the word "severe" in terms of mental and/or physical pain being inflicted. Both subjective and objective elements are thus included, as well as factors such as coercion and punishment (Wattad, 2008–2009). While there are those who suggest that the United Nations' definition of torture may be limited in scope and insufficiently precise, it can serve adequately for the purposes of the discussion herein.

5 Sections Hidden · 2,360 words
Dershowitz on Torture and Judicial Accountability1,050 words
Alan Dershowitz eloquently presents his views on torture in an essay entitled "Should the Ticking Bomb Terrorist Be Tortured?" He begins by describing how his teaching method at Harvard involves presenting students with a choice between evils — illustrated by a story about a railroad engineer — and from there takes the reader through his personal, step-by-step process of thinking about torture. Dershowitz states that his teaching experience in Israel had a significant…
The Ticking Time-Bomb Hypothesis310 words
As described by Strauss (2003–2004), the 9-11 tragedy had immense consequences for our nation and for each of us personally. Among these changes, and beyond the emotional toll, was the new…
Dershowitz on Bentham, Voltaire, and the Ethics of Torture240 words
From the perspective of normative ethics, torture should be considered through a utilitarian approach, measuring what is "right" by the greatest happiness of the larger population. The debate about torture is thus viewed as a choice between…
The Israeli Government Approach and the Fourth Road370 words
In 1987, the Israeli government authorized the Landau Commission to address terrorism and torture. This commission identified three approaches by which Israel might simultaneously maintain…
Conclusion: Torture, Liberty, and Democratic Values390 words
Remembering that the ticking-bomb argument is widely used — the same scenario approached from many different perspectives — it appears that the argument often results in a choice for torture given a hypothetical likelihood of saving many lives. In contrast, Dershowitz appears to defend torture, yet the crux of…

Bibliography

Allhoff, F. (2005). A defense of torture. International Journal of Applied Philosophy, 2005, 246.

Dershowitz, A. (2002). Fourth road. Chapter 15 (pp. 189–214) in Darmer, ed.

Dershowitz, A. (n.d.). Tortured reasoning.

Dershowitz, A. M. (2002). Why terrorism works: Understanding the threat, responding to the challenge. Yale University Press.

Filartiga v. Pena-Irala, Court of Appeals (2nd Circuit), 30 June 1980.

Kleining, J. (2005). Ticking bombs and torture warrants. Deakin Law Review, 10, 614.

Mayer, J. (2007). Whatever it takes. The New Yorker, February 19, 2007.

Mclaughlan, K. (n.d.). Torture: Prohibited in theory but terrifyingly useful in practice?

Pincus, W. (2001, October 21). Silence of 4 terror probe suspects poses dilemma for FBI. Washington Post, A6.

Safire, W. (2001, November 15). Seizing dictatorial power. New York Times, 31.

Strauss, M. (2003–2004). Torture. New York Law School Law Review, 48, 201.

Sung, C. (2003). Torturing the ticking bomb terrorist: An analysis of judicially sanctioned torture in the context of terrorism. Boston College Third World Law Journal, 23, 193.

Ticking time bomb and torture. (n.d.).

Twining, W. L. (1973). Bentham on torture. Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly, 24, 346–347.

Wattad, M. S-A. (2008–2009). The torturing debate on torture. Northern Illinois University Law Review, 29, 11–12.

Wisnewski, J. J. (2008). Unwarranted torture warrants: A critique of the Dershowitz proposal. Journal of Social Philosophy, 39(2), 308–321.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Torture Warrant Ticking Time-Bomb Judicial Oversight UN Convention Utilitarian Ethics Civil Liberties Necessity Doctrine Landau Commission Terrorism Policy Human Dignity
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Torture, Ticking Time-Bombs, and Dershowitz's Judicial Warrant Proposal. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/torture-ticking-time-bomb-dershowitz-judicial-warrant-2153910

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.