Argument Agree Or Disagree Essay

¶ … Pechter's "Too Much Violence: Murdering Wives in Othello"

The Author's Argument

Othello according to the author is the renaissance play where the most heinous act of violence against women occurs. He says "of all the acts of violence against women represented on the English Renaissance stage…Othello's murder of Desdemona, followed quickly by Iago's murder of Emilia, is the most appalling" (366). Throughout the piece the author gives accounts of writers, critics and reviewers who do not seem to believe this, instead stating in one case that it is a shame that "the...

...

Pechter sees the violence as a product of the times, but cannot excuse the fact that people not only want to see the scene, and believe that the scene is essential to the workings of the play. He is making the argument for the reader, but he may have some problems convincing people who want to see the Shakespearean works as they were written. The main argument is that the original scene is too violent mainly because it seems to relegate women to a secondary status, but also that it is wrong for reviewers to lament the fact that such an appalling scene is tampered with.
Main Points of Support

The author uses several excerpts from reviews to make his argument about the play and he also quotes noted critics. Pechter uses an argument from a 1610 review of the play to make his main argument. The reviewer said that the scene was beautiful and that it should remain because it was tradition, and "tradition was right" (367). Pechter responds to this by saying "Tradition, the nightmare of history registered in the weight of previous theatrical and critical response to Othello, does not solve…

Cite this Document:

"Argument Agree Or Disagree" (2012, December 05) Retrieved April 20, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-agree-or-disagree-106130

"Argument Agree Or Disagree" 05 December 2012. Web.20 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-agree-or-disagree-106130>

"Argument Agree Or Disagree", 05 December 2012, Accessed.20 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/argument-agree-or-disagree-106130

Related Documents

Chris Hedges made agreed disagreed agree/disagree. (150-word response). open link watch video: http://billmoyers./segment/chris-hedges -- capitalism's-'sacrifice-zones' / For questions's words response. "It comes down to the necessity to speak a truth, or, at least a truth as far as you can discern it. […] I understood all the ways that this was going to be a disaster, including upsetting the power balance in the Middle East." Chris Hedges' claim that the U.S.

Disagree: trying to get tough on gun crimes, especially through mandatory prison sentences, will not reduce gun-related crimes Getting "tough on crime" has become a political code in the United States. The phrase has become a Republican Party platform issue and one used to galvanize citizens, one that signals the righteous intolerance of criminals but is a thinly cloaked measure for social control. Of course, Americans should hope for a society

Agree or Expand on a
PAGES 5 WORDS 1552

Europe and Germany had a long anti-Semitic history and Nazism appeared to be the best solution during the 1930s. The masses were vulnerable to being influenced and Hitler was well-acquainted with this concept. Even with the fact that it is difficult to determine his exact interests in wanting to remove Jewish people from Germany and from territories that came to be occupied by Nazis, it is very likely that

Death and Justice by Edward I. Koch. Former New York City Mayor Ed Koch defends his beliefs and convictions regarding capital punishment, and discuss why it is such a volatile issue facing our country. The article includes Koch's opinions refuting some of the most popular arguments against capital punishment. Koch ends paragraph two with a question because he wants the reader to think about his statement. If he simply made

Assisted Suicide and Suicide
PAGES 60 WORDS 13401

Physician Assisted Suicide in Patients With Unbearable Suffering or the Terminally Ill One of the most hotly debated issues today is physician-assisted suicide. Recently, California became the fifth state to legalize physician-assisted suicide, and there is an increasing likelihood that other states will follow suit in the foreseeable future. The purpose of this study is to determine if the factors chosen have any bearing on those who choose to end their

Tennessee v. Garner. The case involved the excessive use of force with regards to felony cases. The decision of the court and the reasons given will also be looked into. The agreements and disagreements that followed will also be discussed. Court Decision At the end of the trial the court granted a motion in favor of the police department and the city. The court also found for the other defendants on