Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Patricia Benner's Theory of Novice to Expert: Does It Remain Valid?
What makes a nurse a good nurse? Patricia Benner's Theory of Novice to Expert examines the growth of a nurse's expertise and emotional development from her first years of practice to what Benner calls expertise, or higher-level competency. In Benner's view, expertise depends upon the development of the nurse's intuitive capacity. As noted by Lyneham, Parkinson, & Denholm (2008), this competency that Benner defined as "intuitive" is a little-understood term, given the basis of modern nursing in evidence-based practice (p.380). By intuition, Benner meant the internalization of experience as well as technical capabilities. To better understand Benner's ideas, the authors adopted a qualitative, phenomenological approach, interviewing 14 emergency room nurses who met Benner's standards of expert practice, to determine if Benner's framework was relevant. Specifically, the study attempted to respond to criticisms of Benner's model of expert practice.
Critics of the Benner model view intuition as inappropriate to use in nursing practice, which they view as a scientific, evidence-based exercise of knowledge (Lyneham, Parkinson, & Denholm, 2008, p.381). Not only does Benner allow for intuition to be used; she regards it as the highest manifestation of nursing practice. It should be underlined that Benner does not disregard or discount the need for the nurse to have...
Defenders of the Benner model thus counter that Benner is hardly anti-science, but rather that Benner strives to underline nursing's basis in an individual, patient-focused approach and a craft that is honed by years of experience. Nursing, in short, requires book knowledge but expertise cannot be honed from reading alone. Nursing is an art as well as a science.
One of the challenges of studying the Benner model is the difficulty of defining what is meant by intuition at all as an object of study. In contrast to years of schooling or the number of degrees possessed by a nurse, intuition is not something which can be quantified. This is one of the reasons the researchers selected a qualitative approach. Intuition, according to the researchers' criteria, is defined as knowledge which is "non-inferential" in nature, is not strictly rational, and takes place "below the threshold of consciousness" (Lyneham, Parkinson, & Denholm, 2008, p.382). The study involved a voluntary sample of one male nurse and 13 female nurses with 5 or more years of experience in Australian emergency rooms. The authors used a series of semi-structured interviews to gather data. What emerged is that the expert nurses all had different practices and used their intuition in different ways, but all seemed to operate on some level…
Reference
Lyneham, J. Parkinson, C. & Denholm, C. (2008) Explicating Benner's concept of expert
practice: intuition in emergency nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 64(4), 380 -- 387.
doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2008.04799.x
Patricia Benner: Nursing Philosophy Patricia Benner Nursing Philosophy Theoretical Aspects of Benner in Nursing Importance of Benner's Theory Patricia Banner born in Hampton, Virginia received her early and professional education in California. She majored in nursing and obtained a Bachelors of Arts in 1964 from Pasadena College. After which, she earned a masters degree in nursing with her emphasis in medical surgical nursing from the University of California. She has worked as a research
Application of TheoryIntroductionAdvanced practice nursing is a specialized field that requires a comprehensive understanding of nursing theories and models to ensure that nursing care is delivered effectively and efficiently. Two relevant nursing theories that can be used in the area of advanced practice nursing are Jean Watson's Theory of caring and Benner's Novice to Expert theory. The Theory of caring by Watson emphasizes the importance of the nurse-patient relationship and
Application of Theory to the Practice Problem of Nurse Staffing Nursing theories are important in shaping how practitioners discharge their duties or make decisions related to the service delivery in healthcare. The following study explores and applies a middle range theory to an identified problem in nursing. Theory can be applied to solve nursing challenges especially in the management of nursing care services. The study will demonstrate the benefits of applying
Management Performance Within Elderly Care Homes in Gibraltar The elderly nursing community in Gibraltar is dispersed and characterized by different institution specific challenges and particularities. The current project assesses the general level of leadership competencies within three pre-selected institutions, the management performance assessments of employees, the basic leadership skills required and formulates a series of recommendations as to how these competencies could be obtained. The approach is predominantly a quantitative
Caring Nursing Concept Analysis: Caring Caring is a concept central to nursing theory. Indeed, an esteemed constellation of nurses throughout history, including Nightingale, Watson, Henderson, and Benner, have integrated the concept of care into their theory and praxis. Caring has been considered a foundational element of nursing such that "compassion and therapeutic relationships" are viewed as essential "underpinnings" of nursing (Skillings, 2008). As with most disciplines, the complexities that accompany professional
27). The proficient nurses perceive situations as wholes rather than in terms of distinct aspects, and performance is determined by maxims. Perceive or perception is the main word: The perspective is not thought out but presents itself based on experience and earlier events. Proficient nurses understand a situation because they perceive its meaning in regard to long-term goals. Because of their experience, proficient nurses can recognize when the expected normal