Proportional Represntation In A Plurality Term Paper

As far as congressional elections, proportional representation (PR) is based on the principle that any group of like-minded voters should win legislative seats in proportion to its share of the popular vote. Proportional representation would allow minor party candidates to overcome the formidable barrier imposed by the plurality system. Consequently, this new type of electoral system would ensure free and fair competition between all political parties irrespective of their size (Amy: More Choices for Voters). Nonetheless, there are numerous voices opposing such a shift in the electoral system that claim it would not be beneficial to the state of Colorado, as proportional representation makes it "less likely that Colorado will play a pivotal role in a presidential election." (Denver Post: 2004). Also, proportional representation would limit the number of the "safe seats" and would increase competition. In the American system, each legislator is the elected representative of a distinct geographical region. Should he not perform according to the voters' expectations, he is voted out in the next elections. His seat is then occupied by a new candidate. In the case of proportional representation, those who represent large states would end up representing everybody technically speaking and no one in reality. This would make it more difficult for voters to hold their representatives accountable...

...

Moreover, those who are not in favor of the amendment argue that in order for the transition to proportional representation to be possible, it is important to consider the elimination of the Electoral College as this prevents true popular elections. The existence of the Electoral College combined with the system of proportional representation undermines the two-party system and "strengthens the power of splinter groups." (Ibid.)
Amy, Douglas J. "What is Proportional Representation and why do we need this reform?" Mount Holyoke College. http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/polit/damy/BeginnningReading/whatispr.htm

Balinski, M.L.; Young, H.P. "Criteria for Proportional Representation." Operations Research 2.1 (Jan. - Feb., 1979): 80-95.

Colorado proposes Proportional Representation." Denver Post 15 June 2004. Center for Voting and Democracy. http://www.fairvote.org/articles/denverpost.htm

Sources Used in Documents:

Amy, Douglas J. "What is Proportional Representation and why do we need this reform?" Mount Holyoke College. http://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/polit/damy/BeginnningReading/whatispr.htm

Balinski, M.L.; Young, H.P. "Criteria for Proportional Representation." Operations Research 2.1 (Jan. - Feb., 1979): 80-95.

Colorado proposes Proportional Representation." Denver Post 15 June 2004. Center for Voting and Democracy. http://www.fairvote.org/articles/denverpost.htm


Cite this Document:

"Proportional Represntation In A Plurality" (2007, November 01) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/proportional-represntation-in-a-plurality-34703

"Proportional Represntation In A Plurality" 01 November 2007. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/proportional-represntation-in-a-plurality-34703>

"Proportional Represntation In A Plurality", 01 November 2007, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/proportional-represntation-in-a-plurality-34703

Related Documents

A primary is another system of electing delegates with a mandate to vote for a given candidate. Unlike caucuses, primaries are votes conducted by the government on behalf of the political party. This vote can be open, closed, semi-closed or semi-open. Open primaries allow citizens to vote in both parties' primaries; semi-closed only the primary for the party you belong to (independents may vote in these as well) and in

Presidential Campaign revolves under the presidential leadership from its formation. The presidential candidate has to undergo an electoral process so that they are declared winners. The nation has faced challenges like the world wars and even the civil wars due to differences in ideologies. The paper is going to cover U.S. political campaign of President Woodrow Wilson in 1916 as well as how this campaign differs from that of 1912? U.S.

Another Wall Street Journal article (April 2, 2007) explains that Senator Hillary Clinton is the current top fundraiser among Democratic candidates for president. In the Washington Post (March 29, 2007), former presidential candidate Steve Forbes has decided not to run again, but he threw his endorsement over to Republican Rudy Giuliani. Senator Hillary Clinton, meanwhile, picked up the endorsement of Iowa Governor Tom Vilsack, according to the New York Times

Also, viewers may perceive the negative advertising as an infringement upon their right to decide for themselves. Such a perception may result in reactance, a boomerang effect in which the individual reacts in a manner opposite to the persuader's intention. What these studies show, then, is that a candidate is never going to know how for sure how a negative ad may impact the voters. In the long run,

Election: The coming presidential elections in the United States will be conducted on Tuesday, November 6, 2012 and will be America's 57th quadrennial presidential election. As the election approaches, various initiatives and measures have been taken to educate and empower America's voting public and create an increasingly responsible government. These efforts have primarily involved the provision of comprehensive, non-partisan information that relate to presidential candidates, news, issues, and political parties.

Presidential Election and the State of the Market finance and capital market fluctuates to both positive and negative events. It is argued that the presidential election in November 2012 in the U.S. can have worldwide financial ramifications. There are arguments from economic agencies like Bloomberg that there is an importance of elections for the markets, but it is stated that some of the fears are myths. The U.S. presidential election