Why Euthanasia Should Remain Illegal: Key Arguments
This paper argues that euthanasia should remain illegal in the United States, presenting a multi-faceted case against both voluntary and physician-assisted suicide. Drawing on medical ethics, criminal law, and social equity, the paper contends that a profit-driven health care system exploits depressed and vulnerable patients rather than providing adequate palliative care. It examines the inadequacy of physician training in end-of-life care, the role of depression in suicide requests, conflicts of interest in surrogate decision-making, the disproportionate impact on minorities and the poor, and the broader dangers of the so-called slippery slope toward cost-driven euthanasia. The paper concludes that protecting terminally ill patients requires keeping euthanasia illegal and investing in improved palliative and psychiatric care.
- Introduction: Defining Euthanasia and Its Legal Landscape: Defines euthanasia types and outlines legal history
- The Case Against Euthanasia: AMA position and Hippocratic Oath arguments
- Physician Ethics and the Hippocratic Tradition: Historical medical ethics versus utilitarian shift
- Depression, Coercion, and Inadequate Medical Training: Depression rates, training gaps, and family pressure
- Equity, Conflicts of Interest, and the Slippery Slope: Minority risk, cost containment, and slippery slope
- Conclusion: Policy recommendations to keep euthanasia illegal
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a range of source types — medical research, legal testimony, ethical philosophy, and case studies — to build a layered argument against euthanasia rather than relying on a single line of reasoning.
- Grounds abstract ethical claims in concrete evidence, such as AMA testimony, Foley's residency survey data, and the Terri Schiavo case, making the argument accessible and persuasive.
- Anticipates and directly addresses counterarguments (autonomy, compassion, patient choice), then systematically refutes them with medical and sociological evidence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of refutation through evidence: it acknowledges the strongest pro-euthanasia arguments (patient autonomy, dignity in dying, compassionate relief of suffering) before dismantling each with empirical data on physician training gaps, depression prevalence in terminally ill patients, and financial incentives in managed care. This technique — sometimes called the "concede and rebut" structure — strengthens the writer's credibility by showing awareness of competing views.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a definition and historical overview of euthanasia, then transitions into a sustained argument against legalization organized around four pillars: medical ethics and the Hippocratic tradition; inadequate physician training and the role of clinical depression; equity concerns and conflicts of interest illustrated by a high-profile case; and the slippery slope toward cost-driven death. The conclusion synthesizes all four strands and returns to the paper's central policy claim. The numbered section headings (2.0, 3.0) reflect an undergraduate policy-paper format.
Introduction: Defining Euthanasia and Its Legal Landscape
Euthanasia is the act of putting to death painlessly, or allowing to die by withholding extreme medical measures, a person or animal suffering from an incurable, often painful, disease or condition. Today, medical advances have made it possible to prolong life in patients with no hope of recovery, and the term negative euthanasia has arisen to classify the practice of withholding or withdrawing extraordinary means — such as intravenous feeding, respirators, and artificial kidney machines — to preserve life. Positive euthanasia, on the other hand, refers to actions that actively cause death, such as administering a lethal drug.
Much debate has arisen in the United States among physicians, religious leaders, lawyers, and the general public over euthanasia. Pro-euthanasia societies were founded in 1935 in England and in 1938 in the United States. The Hemlock Society is one group that has pressed for right-to-die legislation on a national level. Positive euthanasia is, for the most part, illegal in the United States, but physicians may lawfully refuse to prolong life when there is extreme suffering. In the early 1990s, Dr. Jack Kevorkian gained notoriety by assisting a number of people to commit suicide and became the object of a 1992 state law forbidding such activity. Kevorkian, who had been tried and acquitted repeatedly in the assisted deaths of seriously ill people, was convicted of murder in Michigan in 1999 for an assisted suicide shown on national television. In 1997, the Supreme Court upheld state laws banning assisted suicide.
Unfortunately, in 1994, Oregon voters approved physician-assisted suicide for terminally ill patients; the law went into effect in 1997. In 2001, the Bush administration tried to undermine the law with a directive issued under the federal Controlled Substances Act, but Oregon successfully sued to prohibit its enforcement. In 1993, the Netherlands decriminalized, under a set of restricted conditions, voluntary positive euthanasia — essentially physician-assisted suicide — for the terminally ill, and in 2002 the country legalized physician-assisted suicide if voluntarily requested by seriously ill patients who face ongoing suffering. In 2002, Belgium also legalized euthanasia for certain patients who have requested it.
Growing acceptance of positive euthanasia represents a disturbing trend in medical and social ethics. Those who support the practice of active euthanasia argue that helping the terminally ill to bring about their own deaths — allowing them to determine the how and when — is not only humane, but also allows the person, who is simply "living to die," to maintain dignity by orchestrating their own end, thus letting them die at peace rather than suffer to the end, perceiving themselves to be a burden to those they love.
However, this paper presents a strong case for why the intentional killing of another person is wrong. It demonstrates that a profit-driven health care system is effectively transferring control from patients to the medical profession in order to save money — or to serve the interests of those who place their own interests before the best interests of the patient. Rather than pursue adequate training in how to care for terminally ill patients, it is more cost-effective to take advantage of depressed individuals who have been made to feel that they are wasteful consumers of medical services. As usual, the majority of victims will be the financially disadvantaged and minorities. Once euthanasia becomes accepted, society is well on a slippery slope toward preferring cheap lethal medications over more expensive, quality health care. The only option that will prevent the victimization of the terminally ill by profit-driven health care institutions is to keep euthanasia illegal and to continue fighting the legality of physician-assisted suicide in Oregon.
The Case Against Euthanasia
Fortunately, the American Medical Association (AMA) has not endorsed euthanasia, recognizing the conflict of interest between a physician's responsibility to save lives and participation in euthanasia. In testimony before a congressional committee on April 29, 1996, Dr. Lonnie R. Bristow, president of the AMA, made the following statement (Kennedy, 1996):
"The AMA believes that physician-assisted suicide is unethical and fundamentally inconsistent with the pledge physicians make to devote themselves to healing and to life. Laws that sanction physician-assisted suicide undermine the foundation of the patient-physician relationship that is grounded in the patient's trust that the physician is working wholeheartedly for the patient's health and welfare."
Bristow also stated that "No other country in the world, including the Netherlands, has legalized assisted suicide or euthanasia. This is one movement in which the United States should not be a 'leader.'"
Bibliography
"Active Euthanasia — A Kantian Perspective." PlanetPapers. 07 Dec. 2003.
Bopp, James, and Coleson, Richard. "The Constitutional Case Against Permitting Physician-Assisted Suicide for Competent Adults with 'Terminal Conditions.'" Oregon Right to Life. 07 Dec. 2003.
Burke, J. Balch and O'Steen, David N. "Why We Shouldn't Legalize Assisting Suicide." National Right to Life Committee. 08 Dec. 2003.
Chastain, Jane. "Another 9-11 Date With Death." WorldNetDaily.com. 04 Sept. 2003. 08 Dec. 2003.
Eckstein, Cheryl. "Can There Ever Be a 'Right' to Be Killed." Citizen, p. 6. 25 July 1995.
"Euthanasia." Infoplease.com. 07 Dec. 2003.
Egendorf, Laura K. Assisted Suicide: Current Controversies. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1998.
Foley, Kathleen. "Competent Care for the Dying Instead of Physician-Assisted Suicide." New England Journal of Medicine. Vol. 336, No. 1, pp. 53–58. 2 Jan. 1997.
Gunning, Karel F. "Why Not Euthanasia." Oregon Right to Life. 08 Dec. 2003.
"Inequities in Health Care for Minorities and the Poor." International Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide. 07 Dec. 2003.
Kennedy, D. James. Issues Tearing Our Nation's Fabric. Fort Lauderdale: Coral Ridge Ministries, 1996.
Marker, Rita L., and Hamlon, Kathi. "Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide: Frequently Asked Questions." International Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide. 08 Dec. 2003.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.