Applying Cooper's Ethical Decision-Making Model: Four Cases
This paper applies Cooper's ethical decision-making model to four distinct public administration scenarios: a racially discriminatory hiring decision, a questionable leave-of-absence agreement, an illegal public employee strike, and a patient privacy versus public safety dilemma. For each case, the paper evaluates how Cooper's model—particularly its phases of defining the ethical issue, identifying alternatives, and projecting probable consequences—guides decision-making. The paper also assesses the model's broader strengths and limitations, arguing that while Cooper's framework is a valuable starting point, it requires supplementation with virtue ethics, considerations of direct and indirect consequences, and comparative fault analysis to address more complex ethical dilemmas.
- Case 1: A Questionable Hire: Racially discriminatory hiring decision analyzed through Cooper's model
- Case 2: Taking a Leave: Principle versus consequence in a leave-of-absence contract dispute
- Case 3: The Illegal Strike: Cooper's model applied to an unlawful public employee strike
- Case 4: Privacy vs. Safety: Patient confidentiality weighed against public health consequences
- Benefits and Shortcomings of Cooper's Model: Critique of Cooper's model as a starting ethical framework
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Each case is analyzed using a consistent framework, making the application of Cooper's model easy to follow and compare across different ethical scenarios.
- The paper balances rule-based and consequentialist reasoning, showing how Cooper's model navigates tension between formal regulations and probable outcomes.
- The concluding section moves beyond mechanical application to offer a nuanced critique of the model's limitations, strengthening the paper's analytical depth.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied ethical analysis — taking a theoretical framework (Cooper's model) and systematically testing it against real-world scenarios. Each case isolates a different tension within the model (rule conflict, principle vs. consequence, stakeholder harm), allowing the writer to build a cumulative critique by the conclusion.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with four sequential case analyses, each self-contained but sharing a common analytical lens. The final section synthesizes observations from all four cases into a balanced evaluation of Cooper's model — identifying both its utility as a starting framework and its failure to adequately weigh competing moral principles against probable consequences in complex situations.
Case 1: A Questionable Hire
On the main issue of the ethical propriety of the group's decision to forego hiring Anne, Cooper's model and other objective ethical analyses would suggest that the group's decision was unethical. On the second issue of Felicia's choice to violate the strict rule about maintaining confidentiality regarding the decision, Cooper's model would likely have permitted certain kinds of rule violations but not others. In principle, Felicia's decision to violate confidentiality was ethical under the circumstances, but Cooper's model would have required closer attention to the phase pertaining to projecting the probable consequences of the decision on Felicia's part to fully satisfy her respective ethical obligations.
With respect to the main issue of the group's decision-making process, the most important element of Cooper's model would have been the phase of defining the ethical issue or dilemma. Felicia would have considered that the intended course of action of the group was both unethical and expressly illegal in the United States as a fundamental violation of the Civil Rights Act and of related legislation that absolutely prohibits the denial of a position on the basis of racial identity. Cooper's model does not specifically address the issue of what happens when one rule trumps another rule about the same subject matter and when adhering to one necessarily violates the other. Felicia would have been right to uphold the more authoritative federal law on civil rights in hiring decisions over agency regulations requiring absolute confidentiality.
Cooper's model would also have led to this conclusion on the basis of the phase involving projecting probable consequences. In that regard, Felicia could have weighed the probable consequences of allowing blatant racism in hiring within a government agency against the probable consequences of violating agency policy to address such violations. Either way, Cooper's model would have justified Felicia's decision to report the situation to appropriate authorities for investigation — just the same as if the group had made the decision out of overt racial animus — because applicable federal law does not allow employers any excuse for violating civil rights in hiring decisions.
Felicia would also have been ethically justified in seeking out confidential advice, such as from her priest or from a lawyer, because their formal obligations with respect to confidentiality preserve the same interests as those of agency policy. However, had Felicia better employed the projection-of-probable-consequences phase of Cooper's model, she would have considered the consequences of disclosures on the part of the priest, and she would have sought guidance on the identical issue without divulging any identifying information about her agency or the individuals involved.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.