Democratizing Iraq vs. Post-WWII Germany: A Comparison
This paper examines whether democratization in Iraq and Afghanistan can succeed by comparing these cases to the successful post-World War II democratization of West Germany. Drawing on scholars including Eva Bellin, Andrew Enterline, J. Michael Greig, and Michael McFaul, the paper first establishes democracy as an international norm before identifying five critical differences between post-war Germany and present-day Iraq: levels of economic development, ethnic homogeneity, strength of government institutions, prior democratic experience, and the presence of committed national leaders. The analysis concludes that while a democratic Iraq could bring regional stability, the structural conditions in Iraq fall far short of those that made German democratization viable.
- Introduction: Democratization After Conflict: Post-WWII democracy efforts and Iraq parallels
- Democracy as an International Norm: McFaul's three reasons democracy became global norm
- Comparing Post-War Germany and Iraq: An Overview: Framing the Germany-Iraq democratization comparison
- Economic Development and Democratic Outcomes: Economic gap between Germany and Iraq analyzed
- Ethnic Homogeneity, Institutions, and Historical Precedent: Ethnic divisions and weak institutions hinder Iraq
- Leadership and the Prospects for a Democratic Iraq: Exile of Iraqi leaders weakens democratic transition
- Conclusion: Weighing benefits against structural obstacles in Iraq
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper organizes a multi-factor comparative analysis clearly, moving systematically through five distinct structural differences between Germany and Iraq rather than conflating them into vague generalizations.
- It balances competing scholarly perspectives — using Bellin's cautionary analysis alongside Enterline and Greig's more optimistic framing — giving the argument intellectual fairness.
- Direct quotations from primary scholarly sources are used purposefully to anchor claims rather than pad word count, and each is followed by the author's own interpretive commentary.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective comparative historical analysis: it establishes a baseline case (West Germany) whose outcome is known, then systematically tests whether the conditions that enabled that outcome are present in the new case (Iraq/Afghanistan). This structure allows the student to derive analytical conclusions without overstating certainty — a hallmark of rigorous social-science writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical context and a motivating problem, moves into a theoretical section on democracy as a norm, then transitions into the heart of the argument: a five-factor comparison between post-WWII Germany and Iraq. Each factor (economic development, ethnic homogeneity, government institutions, historical democratic precedent, and national leadership) receives its own paragraph. The paper closes by weighing the optimistic case for a democratic Iraq against Bellin's cautionary evidence.
Introduction: Democratization After Conflict
After World War II ended, significant efforts were made by the Allied powers to implement democracy in West Germany and Japan. The transition from authoritarianism to democracy would not be an easy task to accomplish efficiently (Katz). In time, both countries were transformed from militarist regimes with weak democratic cultures into models of democracy (Enterline and Greig). In their foreign policy analysis, Andrew J. Enterline and J. Michael Greig stated the following:
West Germany and Japan were critical to the functioning, and ultimate success, of the Western security system during the Cold War, and served as beacons of democracy, economic prosperity, and peaceful foreign relations in regions notable for authoritarian regimes, state-controlled economics, domestic turmoil, and interstate conflict.
In 2003, after entering Baghdad, a senior U.S. staff officer found himself and his division in a similar situation of turmoil. They were given no instructions or orders regarding what to do or where to go from there (Katz). The United States found itself once again in the position of democratizing a nation with no assurance of success. Several controversies arise when arguing for or against the democratization of Iraq or Afghanistan — whether it can be done and, furthermore, whether it can flourish.
Democracy as an International Norm
Over the years, and particularly after the successful implementation of democracy in West Germany, democracy has become the standard international norm. Nevertheless, it is worth asking why democracy has become the norm, and whether this norm can be applied to Middle Eastern nations such as Iraq and Afghanistan. In Michael McFaul's "Democracy Promotion as a World Value," he provides three distinct reasons why democracy has developed over time to become the norm.
His first claim is that democracy "is stronger today than ever, and democracy itself is widely regarded as an ideal system of government. Democracy also has a near-universal appeal among people of every ethnic group, every religion, and every region of the world." He further argues that democracy as a foreign policy goal has become increasingly acceptable; however, the United States no longer holds full control over democracy, even though it has played a vital role in its development and growth as an accepted foreign policy. Since the U.S. is no longer recognized as holding exclusive ownership of democracy, this has been viewed as a sign that democracy is not merely an American project, but a model accepted internationally.
Finally, McFaul concludes that although democracy has become the accepted standard, that does not automatically mean it will be followed in every case. Furthermore, choosing not to follow or embrace democracy does not necessarily prove that it is not influential. Regardless of such instances, democracy remains widely accepted as the international norm.
References
Bellin, Eva. "The Iraqi Intervention and Democracy in Comparative Historical Perspective." Political Science Quarterly 119.4 (2004–2005): 595–608. The Political Science Quarterly. Web. 21 Apr. 2011.
Enterline, Andrew J., and J. Michael Greig. "Against All Odds? The History of Imposed Democracy and the Future of Iraq and Afghanistan." Foreign Policy Analysis 4 (2008): 321–347. Wiley Online. Web. 21 Apr. 2011.
Katz, Stanley N. "Gun Barrel Democracy? Democratic Constitutionalism Following Military Occupation: Reflections on the U.S. Experience in Japan, Germany, and Afghanistan and Iraq." Princeton Law & Public Affairs Paper No. 04-010. Web. 21 Apr. 2011.
McFaul, Michael. "Democracy Promotion as a World Value." The Washington Quarterly 28.1 (2004): 147–163. Project Muse. Web. 21 Apr. 2011.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.