Skip to main content
Literature Review Graduate 5,877 words

ELL Misidentification and Special Education Referral Processes

~30 min read 7 sections Education · Special Education
Abstract

This literature review examines the identification and referral processes used for English Language Learners (ELLs) who may be misidentified as learning disabled (LD). The paper explores teacher perceptions and attitudes, structural barriers in assessment, and the limitations of standardized and discrepancy-based testing for linguistically diverse students. It reviews cultural intelligence theory and the Multiple Intelligences model as frameworks for improving classroom assessment. The paper also compares the Discrepancy Formula and Response to Intervention (RTI) models, presenting RTI as a more effective, culturally responsive approach to early identification and intervention that better distinguishes language proficiency issues from true learning disabilities among ELL student populations.

Key Takeaways
  • Teacher Understandings of Referral Processes for ELL and LD Students: Types of academic failure and referral process dysfunctions
  • Misidentification of ELL Students as Learning Disabled: Overrepresentation, testing bias, and ELL misplacement data
  • Issues in the Pre-Referral Process: Interpreter gaps, data barriers, and federal policy limitations
  • Defining the Problem of General Education Teacher Compliance: Teacher training gaps, attitudes, and inclusion resistance
  • Best Practices Theory in Assessing Language Minority Students: Cultural intelligence and multiple intelligences frameworks for ELL assessment
  • Linguistic Deficiency or Learning Disability: A Pre-Referral Model: Pre-referral models and discrepancy formula critiques
  • Response to Intervention Model for Assessing Learning Disability: RTI as evidence-based replacement for discrepancy testing
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • Synthesizes a large body of empirical research across multiple subfields — teacher attitudes, assessment methodology, federal policy, and intervention models — into a coherent literature review narrative.
  • Grounds abstract policy concerns in concrete data, including national tables on IEP and ELL enrollment and state-by-state teacher standards, giving readers a factual baseline before evaluating competing models.
  • Systematically compares two competing assessment frameworks (Discrepancy Formula and RTI), evaluating each against the needs of ELL students with multiple supporting studies.
  • Extends theoretical frameworks — cultural intelligence and multiple intelligences — beyond their original domains to generate practical recommendations for classroom practice.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates thematic synthesis: rather than summarizing each source individually, it groups studies by argument type (e.g., overrepresentation patterns, testing bias, teacher barriers) and builds a cumulative case that each theme reinforces. This allows the review to build logically toward a policy recommendation — RTI — as the evidence-supported best practice.

Structure breakdown

The review opens with a typology of academic failure (Garcia & Ortiz's three-category model), then moves through problem identification (misidentification patterns and data), institutional barriers (teacher attitudes and compliance), theoretical frameworks (cultural intelligence, multiple intelligences), and finally competing intervention models (Discrepancy vs. RTI). Each section builds on the prior one, culminating in a research-supported argument for RTI adoption.

Essay 5,877 words

Teacher Understandings of Referral Processes for ELL and LD Students

There is a clear need to objectively distinguish the needs of students who may be indicated for special services intervention. Garcia and Ortiz (2004) state that academic failure distinctions can be generalized into three categories: Type I, where students are in inappropriate classrooms for their particular learning needs (such as ELLs); Type II, where students have learning and achievement issues that do not fall into the special education/learning disabled category and therefore must be served in the general education classroom; and Type III, where students clearly have a functionally severe limitation such as a major disorder that limits the learning process (Garcia & Ortiz, 2004). Failure to distinguish between the three types may result in a student being inappropriately referred for special education when in fact they should not be. The question arises as to why the referral process may be dysfunctional, allowing this type of failure to occur in needs-assessments of students.

Various issues in the assessment process have been identified in the research literature. There are issues related to professional practices, with the spectrum ranging from one end where teacher perceptions and attitudes influence the assessment process — including their prejudices as well as their lack of awareness and training in properly assessing ELL students — to the other end, which represents inappropriate and inefficient professional methods of assessment, implementation, and follow-through. Additional barriers relate to the structure of assessment testing, with much criticism leveled at the use of IQ and achievement testing in assessing students for learning disabilities. This methodology does not adequately reflect the individual learning styles of students, and so may inappropriately identify students as learning disabled when in fact their issues are not due to learning disabilities.

Teachers may fail to understand the referral process. Ortiz et al. (1985) found, in assessing data gathered as part of referral and pre-referral processes on English language deficient learners in LD classrooms, that education professionals involved in the data-gathering phase of the referral process may not understand the learning issues underlying students with limited English language proficiency (Ortiz et al., 1985).

Misidentification of ELL Students as Learning Disabled

Wagner et al. (2005) report that the need for different approaches to identifying ELL students who have learning disabilities is paramount and increasingly recognized in the field of education. They state that the existing models of assessment and intervention do not effectively address the need for proper identification of students at risk. The needs of ELL students within the education system point to a need for a larger conceptualization of what constitutes a learning disability, including the proper distinction between learning disabled and language proficiency issues (Wagner, Francis, & Morris, 2005).

Spinelli (2008) points to the fact that misidentification of ELL students as learning disabled leads to those students being unable to receive appropriate services, and hence those students face greater emotional, social, behavioral, and educational challenges as time progresses and their needs continue to go unmet. Spinelli holds that an informal assessment measure is a viable option in the evaluation process that can be adapted to culturally and linguistically diverse students, their learning styles, and their unique characteristics which underlie their challenges (Spinelli, 2008).

Guiberson (2009) finds that not only are ELL students misidentified as learning disabled, but the forms in which the misidentification manifests are varied. These forms include overrepresentation of minority students in special education compared to the whole school population, underrepresentation when those ELL students with disabilities do not get correctly identified for intervention services, and misidentification when the ELL student is categorized as having a disability different from the one they actually possess (Guiberson, 2009).

Sandberg and Reschly (2010) state that the growing achievement gap between ELL students and language majority students is increasing, and that traditional standardized testing fails to bridge this gap. The use of curriculum-based measurement may be a better standard for assessing the academic needs of ELL students and correctly identifying those with true learning disabilities (Sandberg & Reschly, 2010).

Vaughn et al. (2003) report that the identification of LD students has increased by upward of 200% since 1977, with explanations ranging from a likely outcome of the growing knowledge field, to LD as a field serving as a catch-all for the failures of general education to meet the needs of students of varying abilities. The study investigators find not only that the heterogeneity of identified students is quite wide, but also that many students are overrepresented (misidentified) or underrepresented (unidentified). One major problem is the use of IQ tests to identify students as learning disabled. Using standardized tests fails to accurately identify those students who have reading difficulties or whose first language is not English. More emphasis is needed on response-to-instruction models of assessment and intervention to replace ineffective normalized standards for identifying students at risk and properly placing them for early intervention (Vaughn, Linan-Thompson, & Hickman, 2003).

Abedi (2008) reports that administering assessment tests in English for non-native English speakers may not provide reliable information about the academic levels of ELL students. Additionally, linguistic issues in the wording of tests that are outside of knowledge content further confound the issue. Language variables not pertinent to the academic content diminish the strength of testing outcomes. Test results used for identification of students at risk for learning disability may not be reliable, especially for ELL students at the low end of the English language proficiency curve. ELL students risk being misidentified by tests that do not accurately measure their knowledge or reflect their current academic levels (Abedi, 2008).

Waitoller et al. (2009) reviewed research on overrepresentation between 1968 and 2006. The study was intended to identify the characteristics of overrepresentation studies and to elucidate how those studies framed the problem of overrepresentation. The investigators found that most of the literature came from journals on special education, with study numbers increasing over time, with particular emphasis after the year 2000. Most studies focused on learning disabilities and African Americans. The studies were typically framed in one of three ways: sociodemographic models focusing on individuals and social contexts; critical perspectives involving power issues revolving around race; and professional practices leading to both the creation and maintenance of overrepresentation. This finding indicates that while awareness is increasing, the spheres in which it is occurring may need redressing, especially to capture the cultural factor of misidentifying ELL students as learning disabled (Waitoller, Artiles, & Cheney, 2009).

Contreras (2006) found that Spanish-speaking Latino students in a South Texas school district were twice as likely to be receiving special education services as their English-speaking counterparts. Further analysis revealed that the overrepresentation of ELL students receiving special education was at 77%. This clearly reveals an inappropriate method in those school districts where ELL students were misidentified as learning disabled, likely due to language proficiency issues (Contreras, 2006).

Sullivan (2009) reports that there has been a disproportionate representation of linguistic minorities in the research on misidentification of students for special education services, with most studies focusing on racial minorities. Sullivan finds that ELL students are not only underrepresented in the literature, they are also overrepresented in actuality for special education services (Sullivan, 2009).

August et al. (2005) report that ELL students who display slow development of their vocabulary cannot comprehend text to the same degree as their English-speaking counterparts. Outcomes for these students are that they are likely to perform poorly on assessment tests and hence risk being misidentified as learning disabled. The investigators suggest using native language testing, basic word-meaning tests, and appropriate support and reinforcement in instruction to mitigate the language deficits of ELL students (August, Carlo, Dressler, & Snow, 2005).

ELL students are at particular risk for being misidentified as learning disabled in the typical English-speaking educational system. Cultural and linguistic differences in testing and intervention do not account for the actual academic knowledge of students, with static models of testing and intervention potentially exacerbating and prolonging the situation for ELL students in terms of their academic needs not being met.

5 Sections Hidden · 2,920 words
Issues in the Pre-Referral Process320 words
Educators and school personnel are the people involved in identifying children at risk and in possible need of intervention services. Teachers may be affected by existing processes for referring students for…
Defining the Problem of General Education Teacher Compliance530 words
The setting of the general education classroom typically brings to mind an organized routine structured around various curricula activities such as the liberal arts and the sciences. Other activities include physical education and specialist classes such as information…
Best Practices Theory in Assessing Language Minority Students680 words
The lack of clarity in objective measures for assessing ELL students' abilities and determining their needs reflects a failure in the U.S. education system to take into account not only the resources needed…
Linguistic Deficiency or Learning Disability: A Pre-Referral Model520 words
Garcia and Ortiz (2004) offer a pre-referral model that addresses the needs of the students, the resources available, the training and qualifications of the teachers, and a step-wise process model that clarifies what issues need to be addressed at distinct stages (Garcia & Ortiz, 2004). One hallmark of this model is that it engages educators to…
Response to Intervention Model for Assessing Learning Disability870 words
The Response to Intervention (RTI) Model is based on early intervention to prevent academic failure through frequent progress checks and research-based instruction (Mellard & Johnson, 2008). This system allows for the early identification of students having academic…
Key Concepts in This Paper
ELL Misidentification Response to Intervention Discrepancy Formula Pre-Referral Process Cultural Intelligence Multiple Intelligences Special Education Referral Teacher Attitudes Language Proficiency Overrepresentation Learning Disability
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). ELL Misidentification and Special Education Referral Processes. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/ell-misidentification-special-education-referral-9587

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.