Employment Morality: Employee and Employer Obligations
This essay examines the ethical dimensions of the employment contract, exploring what obligations employers and employees owe one another beyond simple wage exchange. Drawing on John Locke's political philosophy of freedom and market liberty, Benjamin Franklin's autobiographical account of exploitative apprenticeship, and John Winthrop's Christian model of communal responsibility, the paper argues that a purely free-market approach to employment is insufficient to guarantee fair treatment. It considers historical examples—from indentured servitude to the Enron pension scandal—to conclude that some degree of government oversight is necessary to protect employees, while employees must ultimately take ownership of their own economic futures.
- Introduction: What Employer and Employee Owe Each Other: Competing interests of employers and employees defined
- Locke's Philosophy of Freedom and the Employment Relationship: Locke's liberty applied to employment contracts
- Market Failures and the Limits of a Free Marketplace: Enron and wage collusion challenge free-market ideals
- Franklin's Apprenticeship and the Ethics of Bonded Labor: Franklin's exploitative apprenticeship as a case study
- Winthrop's Moral Framework and Corporate Responsibility: Winthrop's Christian charity counters pure profit motive
- Conclusion: Striking a Balance Between Freedom and Obligation: Government oversight and employee responsibility as balance
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Synthesizes multiple primary sources—Locke, Franklin, and Winthrop—into a coherent philosophical argument about workplace ethics, showing range beyond a single-source analysis.
- Uses concrete historical and contemporary examples (Franklin's apprenticeship, the Enron pension collapse) to ground abstract philosophical claims in real-world consequences.
- Maintains intellectual balance by presenting both the free-market libertarian position and its moral limitations before arriving at a nuanced conclusion.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective comparative analysis across texts from different eras and genres—political philosophy, autobiography, and religious address—applying each framework to a single sustained question about employment morality. This cross-textual synthesis shows how to build an argument from multiple sources rather than treating each source in isolation.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by defining the competing interests of employer and employee, then introduces Locke's philosophy as the theoretical baseline. It proceeds to test that philosophy against market failures and historical examples (Franklin's apprenticeship, Enron), introduces Winthrop as a moral counterweight, and closes with a synthesized position that endorses limited government oversight alongside individual employee responsibility. The argument builds progressively, with each source adding a new layer of complexity.
Introduction: What Employer and Employee Owe Each Other
Before entering into an employment contract, an employee's first concern is usually to gain a living wage, then to acquire experience in a particular profession, and perhaps finally to achieve advancement within a corporate structure, industry, or trade. An employer's main concern in hiring is typically whether the employee can perform the job, whether he or she will merit the wage offered, and whether he or she will remain for the necessary hours and duration. However, once the employee has committed to work and the employer has committed to pay, the relationship and its ratio of obligations inevitably grows murkier. What obligation does the employer have to the quality of life of the employee—and to enhancing the employee's experience—when, as in an internship or apprenticeship, the employee accepts a lower wage in exchange for education?
Works Cited
Franklin, Benjamin. "From the Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin." 1723.
Franklin, Benjamin. "Benjamin Franklin, How I Became a Printer in Philadelphia."
Locke, John. Two Treatises of Government. 1690.
Winthrop, John. "A Modell of Christian Charity." 1630.
Winthrop, John. "A Little Speech on Liberty." 1645.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.