Faith, Nationalism, and Environment in IRA Terrorism
This paper investigates how the intersection of Catholic religious identity, Irish nationalism, and environmental conditions gave rise to the Provisional Irish Republican Army (IRA). Drawing on a literature review of IRA ideology, organizational structure, and tactics, the study traces the historical roots of the conflict from the sixteenth century through the Troubles of 1969 onward. It identifies a gap in the literature regarding how religious morality, nationalist sentiment, and hostile socio-political conditions mutually reinforced one another to produce a Western terrorist organization. A qualitative methodology using unstructured interviews with Irish Catholics across generations is proposed to fill this gap, with findings intended to inform counter-terrorism strategies applicable to other Western societies experiencing cultural division and rising nationalism.
- Introduction: Research questions on religion, nationalism, and IRA terrorism
- Historical Background of the IRA: Centuries of Catholic-Protestant conflict leading to IRA
- Ideology: IRA's militaristic ideology and organizational structure
- Nationalism: Irish Catholic identity and united Ireland as IRA goals
- Environment: Hostile conditions shaping IRA tactics and secrecy
- Gaps in the Literature: Religion's role in IRA formation needs deeper study
- Methodology: Qualitative interviews to explore IRA's intersecting causes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper frames a familiar historical case — the IRA — as an entry point into a broader theoretical question about whether religion, nationalism, and environment together produce political violence, giving the argument both specificity and wider relevance.
- The literature review is organized thematically (ideology, nationalism, environment) rather than chronologically, which keeps the analysis focused on the research question.
- The paper explicitly identifies a gap in existing literature and explains how the proposed methodology is designed to address it, demonstrating sound research design logic.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a gap-identification structure: it surveys existing literature across three thematic lenses, then shows precisely where the literature falls short before proposing a qualitative design to fill that gap. This is a standard and effective structure for a research proposal or term paper in social science and political studies, and the author handles it clearly.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a broad question about religion and terrorism, narrows to the IRA as a case study, and states dual research questions. A historical background section contextualizes the conflict. The literature review covers ideology, nationalism, and environment in separate subsections before a "Gaps" section transitions to the methodology. The methodology justifies the choice of qualitative design, explains the interview approach, and connects back to the research questions. A full reference list closes the paper.
Introduction
While terrorist groups are rarely defended by non-members, there is often a sense among objective observers that not all members of a religion said to have "spawned" terrorism are themselves terrorists or sympathetic to terrorism. For instance, not every Muslim supports ISIS or al-Qaeda, and not every Irish Catholic supports the Irish Republican Army (IRA). Most Muslims and Catholics view their religions as religions of peace. On the other hand, critics of religion tend to hold the opinion that all religions lead to extremism when taken seriously, and that people from these groups who become "extremists" and turn to terrorism are simply adhering body, mind, and soul to the ideology of their religion. But how true is this criticism? Is it possible that in every Muslim or Catholic there exists a potential jihadist or a potential Crusader?
Most research into terrorism focuses on the Middle East, the Muslim religion, and the way nationality and environment intersect to produce extremists, radicals, or terrorists. This study looks at Western terrorism and the IRA as an opportunity to investigate the research question in a way that is more relatable to Western audiences. The primary research question is: How did the intersection of religion, nationalism, and environment produce Westernized terrorists within the IRA? The secondary question is: How could this information be used to help develop a counter-terrorism strategy?
The purpose of this study is to understand the intersection of ideology, nationalism, and environment with regard to why the IRA formed and what the group sought to accomplish through its underground, terroristic methods. By reviewing the available literature on the IRA and by conducting interviews via Zoom with different generations of Irish Catholics, this study will produce data to fill the gap in present literature regarding the IRA, why it came about, and whether it still holds any interest or support among Irish Catholics today.
By understanding what motivates — and what motivated — the IRA, and how it emerged from a culture of conflict, it is hypothesized that an appropriate counter-terrorism strategy can be developed and implemented to prevent similar occurrences in other parts of the Western world where cultural rifts, rising nationalism, and a sense of disenfranchisement may be seeding ground for new terror organizations.
Historical Background of the IRA
The IRA formed as a result of a long-standing feud between Protestant England and Catholic Ireland — a feud that stretched all the way back to the apostasy of King Henry VIII in the sixteenth century. The first landmark killing came with the death of Thomas FitzGerald, who declared publicly in 1534 that he would not serve the apostate king after Henry required all subjects to accept the Act of Succession. A rebellion against Henry's daughter Elizabeth followed at the end of the sixteenth century, launching the Nine Years' War in Ulster. In 1641, the Irish Rebellion occurred, succeeded by the Confederate Wars and the Rebellions and Battles of 1798.
While the nineteenth century saw a union between the Protestant kingdom and the Catholic country, the Irish Republic was formed the following century through the Easter Rising and the Irish War of Independence in 1921. The Troubles began in 1969 in Northern Ireland, and the Provisional Irish Republican Army — commonly known as the IRA — formed to oppose through a strategy of violence the oppression of Catholics and Catholic interests in the North (Bamford, 2005).
Ideology
This literature review drew on sources focused specifically on the cultural and historical characteristics of the IRA and the counter-insurgency efforts of the British. The purpose was to identify the main themes relating to this subject and to situate them within the context of ideology, nationalism, and environment. Books, scholarly articles, and primary sources were accessed using Google Scholar and keyword searches related to the IRA, counter-terrorism, and the intersection of the identified themes.
The Provisional IRA formed in response to the deteriorating situation in Northern Ireland and the failure of peaceful Catholic protests to achieve any recognition from the Protestant government. In the United States, non-violent protests had won the African American community the Civil Rights Act. In Northern Ireland, they won nothing. The IRA also rejected any political settlement or truce that would mask the underlying issues (Tuck, 2007). The IRA sought a victory in socio-political terms — a victory for Catholic Ireland in ideological terms. The co-founder of the IRA, Sean MacStiofain, stated: "You've got to have military victory first and then politicize the people afterwards. To say you've got to unite the Catholic and Protestant working class is just utter rubbish" (Shanahan, 2008, p. 1). In short, the IRA viewed the conflict as a war and its own efforts as militaristic, not terroristic.
The ideology supporting this militaristic stance was grounded in the group's belief in a Catholic culture and Catholic identity, tied to their conviction that they had a right to form a Catholic government. The group felt that Catholics were marginalized and oppressed in the North, and they viewed action as the only means of compelling the British to take notice. The removal of the British from Ireland was the objective, and the group employed local gangs, volunteers, foreign support, and paramilitary forces to pursue it (Bell, 2008).
Prior to its adoption of a cell structure in the late 1970s, the group maintained a hierarchical structure that reflected its stated aims: it had an Army Council and a Chief of Staff, and its members could send representatives to the General Army Conventions, though these were held irregularly over the decades (O'Brien, 1999). The Army Council oversaw tactics, policy, and the process for electing a Chief of Staff (Moloney, 2010). Members of the organization were considered volunteers, and membership was kept secret to avoid detection by British agents believed to have infiltrated the organization. This secrecy made it very difficult to maintain trust within the ranks, and the effectiveness of the IRA was widely questioned by many Irish people (O'Brien, 1999). Yet the British had been burning Catholic homes and forcing Catholic migration out of Belfast, and so the IRA responded with a gang-style method of operations: bombings, attacks, and a general war of attrition, all outlined in the Green Book (O'Brien, 1999).
References
Bamford, B. (2005). The role and effectiveness of intelligence in Northern Ireland. Intelligence and National Security, 20(4), 581–607.
Bell, J. B. (2008). The secret army: The IRA. Transaction Publishers.
IRA Green Book. (1977). Retrieved December 14, 2015, from https://tensmiths.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/15914572-ira-green-book-volumes-1-and-2.pdf
Moloney, E. (2010). Voices from the grave: Two men's war in Ireland. Faber & Faber.
O'Brien, B. (1999). The long war: The IRA and Sinn Féin. Syracuse University Press.
Rooney, N. (2007). Violent nationalism in Catholic communities: The Provisional IRA and ETA. Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism, 7(3), 64–77.
Shanahan, T. (2008). The Provisional IRA and the morality of terrorism. Edinburgh University Press.
Taylor, P. (2001). Brits. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Tuck, C. (2007). Northern Ireland and the British approach to counter-insurgency. Defense and Security Analysis, 23(2), 165–183.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.