Great Places to Work: Quicken Loans, AFLAC & Methodist Healthcare
This paper examines how three companies — Quicken Loans, Methodist LeBonheur Healthcare, and AFLAC — earned recognition on Fortune magazine's annual Best Places to Work list. It begins by reviewing Fortune's award methodology, which draws on anonymous employee surveys and a culture audit to evaluate trust, leadership credibility, and camaraderie. The paper then analyzes each company's distinct HR practices, employee benefits, and organizational culture. It concludes with a reflection on the author's personal HRM philosophy, grounded in the biblical "Golden Rule," and argues that treating employees with respect and trust is the common thread linking all three award-winning organizations.
- Fortune's Best Places to Work: Award Methodology: How Fortune evaluates and selects award winners
- Quicken Loans: Engagement as a Business Strategy: Culture, ISMs booklet, and team member engagement
- Methodist LeBonheur Healthcare: Caring for Caregivers: HRM practices supporting clinical staff and nurses
- AFLAC: Rewarding Employees and Sales Agents: Recognition culture and sales agent support programs
- A Personal Philosophy of HRM: Golden Rule as foundation of effective HRM
- Conclusion: Shared HRM traits behind Fortune award success
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses direct quotations and statistics from primary and secondary sources to support each company profile, giving the analysis a grounded, evidence-based quality.
- Maintains a consistent comparative structure across all three company sections, making it easy for readers to identify shared HRM themes.
- Connects a personal HRM philosophy to a recognizable ethical framework (the Golden Rule), tying the analytical sections together with a normative conclusion.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of source integration: rather than simply summarizing company information, the author consistently pairs direct quotations with interpretive commentary that advances the central argument — that employee-centered HRM practices are the defining feature of great workplaces. This technique keeps the paper analytical rather than merely descriptive.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a methodology section that establishes the credibility of Fortune's award criteria. Three parallel company profiles follow, each addressing culture, benefits, and HRM practices. A fifth section shifts to a normative, first-person reflection on HRM philosophy rooted in biblical principles. The conclusion synthesizes findings across all three companies and restates the central argument about competitive advantage through human capital.
Fortune's Best Places to Work: Award Methodology
Each year, Fortune magazine publishes its list of best companies to work for using a standard set of criteria that includes factors such as the quality of leadership and perceived credibility, based primarily on employee feedback. Three companies that have received this award over the past five years include Quicken Loans, Methodist LeBonheur Healthcare, and AFLAC. This paper examines how these three companies achieved this noteworthy status by first reviewing the relevant literature to describe the methodology used by Fortune magazine to select award recipients, followed by an analysis of their specific and unique company benefits, culture, and human resource management (HRM) practices. Finally, the paper presents a personal philosophy of HRM grounded in biblical principles, followed by a summary of the key findings concerning these three companies.
The winning organizations of each year's "Great Place to Work U.S." award offered by Fortune magazine are evaluated on a number of factors, including the level of trust, credibility, and respectful leadership, as well as measures such as employees' level of pride in their work and camaraderie (Award methodology, 2018). Besides other sources of industry information, Fortune interviews and surveys more than 300,000 employees to develop its list of annual award winners. In this regard, Fortune reports that "each company is scored on our analysis of anonymous employee responses to more than 50 survey questions on our Trust Index Survey, together with our evaluation of company programs and practices as measured through our Culture Audit assessment" (Award methodology, 2018, para. 2).
In order to be considered for the Best Places to Work award, organizations must have at least one thousand employees and receive a sufficient number of survey responses to provide a 95% confidence level with a maximum 5% margin of error (Award methodology, 2018). In sum, Fortune magazine evaluates and compares the manner in which people are actually treated on the job using primary data provided directly by employees, making the award highly prestigious, timely, and noteworthy. Three companies that have achieved this status — Quicken Loans, Methodist LeBonheur Healthcare, and AFLAC — are discussed in turn below.
References
Fortune 500 methodology. (2018). Fortune. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/best-companies/.
Methodist Le Bonheur Healthcare. (2018). Great Place to Work. Retrieved from http://reviews.greatplacetowork.com/methodist-le-bonheur-healthcare.
Phillips, J. J., & Phillips, P. P. (2015). High-impact human capital strategy: Addressing the 12 major challenges today's organizations face. New York: AMACOM.
Shorb, G. S. (2016, Fall). The quality/cost pressures on healthcare providers. Business Perspectives, 18(1), 14–17.
Zoltners, A. A., & Prabhakant, S. (2009). Building a winning sales force: Powerful strategies for driving high performance. New York: AMACOM.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.