Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,459 words

Liberal Arts Education and Poverty: Earl Shorris's Argument

~8 min read 5 sections Literature · Argument
Abstract

This paper analyzes Earl Shorris's 1997 Harper's Magazine article, "On the Uses of a Liberal Education as a Weapon in the Hands of the Restless Poor," in which Shorris argues that limited access to the Humanities is a root cause of persistent poverty. The paper traces Shorris's evolving understanding of poverty after a conversation with inmate Viniece Walker, examines the design and goals of the Clemente Course he created, and discusses the experiences of individual students who participated in the program. It concludes with a critical assessment of whether the program's outcomes confirm that Humanities education specifically — rather than any quality educational opportunity — is the decisive factor in helping poor students develop reasoning skills and political agency.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Overview of Shorris's article and central argument
  • Understanding the Actual Causes of Poverty: Humanities access as a missing cause of poverty
  • The Clemente Course Students: Individual student experiences and outcomes
  • Retrospective Review of the Value of the Clemente Course: Statistical outcomes and program effectiveness
  • Conclusion: Program value weighed against Humanities specificity
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper stays closely grounded in the source text, supporting each analytical point with direct quotation or precise paraphrase from Shorris's article.
  • Individual student profiles (Lomas, Smoot, Anderson) are used as concrete evidence rather than mere illustration, allowing the analysis to build incrementally toward its evaluative conclusion.
  • The conclusion introduces a productive critical counterpoint — questioning whether Humanities specifically, versus any quality education, produces the observed outcomes — without overreaching beyond what the evidence supports.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates source-driven argumentation: the student extracts and contextualizes a long block quotation early on, then uses it as an analytical anchor to measure how Shorris's own thinking evolved. This technique shows readers both what the author originally believed and what changed his mind, giving the analysis a clear before-and-after structure that is easy to follow and evaluate.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a summary of Shorris's central claim and methodology, then devotes a substantial middle section to two interrelated topics: the theoretical argument about poverty's causes and the individual student cases that test that argument. A short retrospective section evaluates outcomes statistically before a conclusion that endorses the program's value while raising a measured skeptical question about the role of the Humanities specifically. The structure mirrors a classic analytical essay: claim → evidence → evaluation.

Essay 1,459 words

Introduction

In his 1997 Harper's Magazine article, "On the Uses of a Liberal Education as a Weapon in the Hands of the Restless Poor," Earl Shorris presents the argument that the common explanation for why poor people remain poor neglects a critical element. Generally, the article details the author's first-hand research in the form of recruiting participants for, and then teaching, a class in the Humanities for individuals from poor neighborhoods and circumstances in the New York Metropolitan area. He begins by tracing the origin of his changed beliefs based on a conversation with an inmate at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in Westchester, a northern suburb of New York City. The rest of the article details the manner in which Shorris applied the lessons he learned from that inmate to develop a new program intended to help those of limited means improve their situations.

Specifically, Shorris argues that there is a fundamental importance to a Liberal Arts education that emphasizes the Humanities in particular, and that providing greater access to an introduction to the Humanities is the key to helping those facing poverty improve their lives.

4 Sections Hidden · 1,005 words
Understanding the Actual Causes of Poverty390 words
Shorris argues that the factors traditionally associated with poverty as causative factors omit a crucial component: the political power that comes with the benefits of appreciating the Humanities. Shorris (p. 50) expresses his initial beliefs about poverty and the…
The Clemente Course Students330 words
When Shorris first met Abel Lomas, Lomas was a street-hardened orphan living on the streets after having been abandoned by his father and losing his mother to murder at the hands of his stepfather. In their first conversation, Lomas failed to understand why dealing drugs…
Retrospective Review of the Value of the Clemente Course155 words
In some respects, the Clemente Course seems to have confirmed the initial assumptions that led to its creation. In other respects, it may be more difficult to conclude that…
Conclusion130 words
There seems to be little reason to doubt that a program such as the Clemente Course is extremely beneficial in that it encourages poor individuals to appreciate education and to discover intellectual abilities they may not otherwise have the chance to discover. On one hand, the experience recounted by Shorris seems to prove…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Clemente Course Humanities Education Poverty Causes Political Power Surround of Force Critical Thinking Social Mobility Liberal Arts Viniece Walker Kantian Ethics
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Liberal Arts Education and Poverty: Earl Shorris's Argument. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/liberal-arts-education-poverty-earl-shorris-54123

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.