Skip to main content
Case Study Undergraduate 1,197 words

RTI Case Study: Evaluating Interventions for a Struggling Reader

~6 min read 7 sections Education · Case Study
Abstract

This paper examines a Response to Intervention (RTI) case study involving a 10-year-old third-grade student whose reading scores declined consistently over the course of a year despite multiple instructional interventions. The analysis evaluates what the interventionists did correctly — providing structured attention and systematic documentation — and what they did incorrectly, namely failing to assess non-instructional variables such as biological, psychological, and socioeconomic factors. Drawing on scholarship by Reschly, Goldstein, Farmer, and Hawkins, the paper recommends a holistic, whole-child assessment approach and suggests targeted professional development opportunities for teachers. The paper also discusses how NCLB and IDEA frameworks apply to the case.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Background on student's declining reading scores
  • What Is Being Done Correctly: Positive aspects of RTI attention and documentation
  • What Is Being Done Incorrectly: Critique of narrow, repetitive intervention methods
  • Suggestions for Improvement: Whole-child assessment drawing on scholarly frameworks
  • NCLB, IDEA, and RTI in Practice: Federal policy frameworks applied to the case
  • Professional Development for Teachers: Skills teachers need beyond classroom instruction
  • Conclusion: Summary of findings and holistic intervention argument
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper moves logically from description to evaluation to recommendation, giving each section a clear and distinct purpose that builds on the previous one.
  • It balances acknowledgment of what practitioners did right with a substantive critique of their methodological limitations, avoiding one-sided judgment.
  • The use of multiple scholarly sources (Reschly, Goldstein, Farmer, Hawkins) to support the recommendation for a whole-child approach gives the argument theoretical grounding rather than relying solely on opinion.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates applied case study analysis: it uses a real student scenario as the evidence base and evaluates it against established educational frameworks (RTI, NCLB, IDEA) and scholarly theory. This technique — moving from observed data to theoretical explanation to practical recommendation — is a core method in education and social science writing.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens with a background narrative establishing the student's situation, then splits its evaluation into two clearly labeled sections (correct and incorrect practices). It follows with recommendations grounded in cited scholarship, a discussion of relevant federal policy frameworks, a section on teacher professional development, and a brief conclusion. The structure mirrors a standard professional case analysis report.

Essay 1,197 words

Introduction

The rights and wrongs of general and special education teacher practice, and Response to Intervention (RTI), are demonstrated through case studies, which can be effective tools for learning. Interventions that address student development can be a delicate process because of the many different factors — both external and internal, ranging from social and economic environment to biological and psychological disabilities — that must be considered before the right intervention can be performed. This paper uses one student's case in order to better understand how interventions can help or hurt a student's progress.

The student in question is a 10-year-old in the 3rd grade whose reading level has consistently declined over the past year. In 2004, her reading level as measured by the Idaho Reading Indicator was at or near grade level. Four months later, at the start of 2005 and midway through the school year, her reading level had dropped to below grade level. Instead of advancing, her scores showed regression. This trend continued throughout 2005, and the various interventions that were utilized — including additional time spent in different reading level groups and a small 1-on-2 group with special teacher focus — did nothing to reverse it. Different books and approaches were also employed, and different assessments were conducted, such as the DIBELS oral reading fluency assessment, but the student still fell short of her reading goals.

6 Sections Hidden · 785 words
What Is Being Done Correctly185 words
What is being done correctly in this case is that the student is receiving attention and extra assistance as a means of helping her develop and boost her reading skills to where they should be for her grade level. Even if the overall result is negative, this RTI method is…
What Is Being Done Incorrectly100 words
Rather than continuing to apply the same intervention approach — that is, more concentrated efforts at reading instruction — the student's external and internal variables should be tested in order to determine whether the cause of her regression is related to something outside her control and outside the teacher's control. There is no indication that the interventionists ever considered these possibilities.…
Suggestions for Improvement185 words
As Reschly (1996) asserts in his assessment of students with learning disabilities, the primary suggestion for improvement focuses on taking a comprehensive view of the situation — not just the student in isolation. Children are products of their environment as well as of their…
NCLB, IDEA, and RTI in Practice115 words
The principles of No Child Left Behind (NCLB) and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) are being applied in this case in the sense that the student is receiving attention because of her low test scores: she is not being "left behind" in the sense that she is not being ignored by teachers, even if they have been unable to improve her reading. Additionally, the science-based approach to identifying a potential learning disability is…
Professional Development for Teachers110 words
The teacher may benefit from the opportunity to develop psychological assessment skills as well as social work skills that could be applied in building a fuller relationship with the student, following Goldstein's (2014) model of reaching out and participating in the child's broader life. The NCLB and IDEA frameworks are essential and helpful in identifying…
Conclusion90 words
The student's regression as a reader is clearly not the result of a lack of the right book or the right teacher. The various interventions have employed these methods with no better results.…

References

Farmer, T. W., Price, L. N., O'Neal, K. K., Man-Chi Leung, Goforth, J. B., Cairns, B. D., & Reese, L. E. (2004). Exploring risk in early adolescent African-American youth. American Journal of Community Psychology, 33(1–2), 51–59.

Goldstein, D. (2014). The Teacher Wars: A History of America's Most Embattled Profession. New York: Doubleday.

Hawkins, B. (2010). Economic recession, college athletics, and issues of diversity and inclusion: When White America sneezes, Black America catches pneumonia. Journal of Intercollegiate Sport, 3(1), 96–100.

Reschly, D. (1996). Identification and assessment of students with disabilities. Special Education for Students with Disabilities, 6(1), 40–53.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Response to Intervention Reading Regression Whole-Child Approach Learning Disability NCLB IDEA Non-Cognitive Barriers Special Education Dyslexia Professional Development
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). RTI Case Study: Evaluating Interventions for a Struggling Reader. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/rti-case-study-struggling-reader-interventions-2159070

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.