U.S. Drug Policy Reform: The Case for Legalizing Marijuana
This paper examines the United States' century-long effort to regulate and criminalize drug use, with particular focus on the increasingly unpopular "war on drugs." It reviews shifting public opinion toward marijuana legalization, the American Medical Association's position on reclassifying cannabis, and comparative data showing alcohol to be far more deadly than marijuana. The paper also addresses how drug criminalization has contributed to federal prison overcrowding, and draws on Portugal's successful decriminalization experiment as an international model. The author argues for an incremental reform approach beginning with marijuana reclassification and reduced sentences for marijuana convictions, with a broader long-term shift from punishment to treatment.
- Introduction: America's War on Drugs: History and unpopularity of U.S. drug war
- Marijuana: Medical Uses and Changing Public Opinion: Cannabis research, AMA stance, shifting legalization support
- The Social Cost of Drug Criminalization: Prison overcrowding and public costs of drug enforcement
- International Lessons: Portugal's Decriminalization Model: Portugal's successful treatment-based drug policy
- Toward Incremental Drug Policy Reform: Proposed step-by-step U.S. reform starting with marijuana
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Supports its central argument with a range of sources, including the American Medical Association, the World Health Organization, and an international case study from Portugal, lending credibility to policy claims.
- Uses concrete statistics — such as 76% of Americans viewing the war on drugs as a failure and alcohol being 114 times more deadly than marijuana — to ground the argument in measurable evidence.
- Balances factual reporting with a clearly stated personal position, then proposes realistic, incremental solutions rather than sweeping or abstract reforms.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper effectively uses comparative policy analysis, contrasting U.S. drug enforcement approaches with Portugal's decriminalization model to argue that treatment-focused strategies produce better outcomes. This technique strengthens the reform argument by showing a real-world precedent rather than relying solely on theoretical reasoning.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical context on the war on drugs, then narrows to marijuana as the central case study — covering medical evidence, public opinion, and legal status across states. It broadens back out to examine the social costs of criminalization, introduces the Portugal model as an international counterexample, and closes with the author's own reform proposals. This funnel-and-widen structure guides the reader logically from problem to solution.
Introduction: America's War on Drugs
The United States has been regulating and criminalizing the use of drugs for over a century. In recent decades, this effort became what is commonly referred to as the "war on drugs." However, this "war" has become largely unpopular with the American people. The federal government spends over twenty-two billion dollars annually on a campaign that 76% of the population views as a failure (Head, N.d.). Since Richard Nixon first declared war on drugs in the late 1960s, the effort has grown so unpopular that President Obama became the first president to stop referring to drug criminalization as a "war."
Marijuana: Medical Uses and Changing Public Opinion
One of the most divisive substances in the drug trade has been marijuana. Representatives in many states have already determined that cannabis has significant medical uses and have approved marijuana to be prescribed to patients by their doctors. The body of evidence focusing on the medical uses of cannabis continues to grow, and it is reasonable to expect that the recognized potential medical applications will expand further. The American Medical Association has publicly stated (AMA, N.d.):
"Our AMA urges that marijuana's status as a federal Schedule I controlled substance be reviewed with the goal of facilitating the conduct of clinical research and development of cannabinoid-based medicines, and alternate delivery methods. This should not be viewed as an endorsement of state-based medical cannabis programs, the legalization of marijuana, or that scientific evidence on the therapeutic use of cannabis meets the current standards for a prescription drug product."
Marijuana is often compared to alcohol, which is already legal. The World Health Organization (WHO) found that 3.3 million deaths in 2012 were attributed to alcohol consumption, and a comparative assessment published in Scientific Reports found alcohol to be 114 times more deadly than marijuana (Castillo, 2015).
Views on marijuana are rapidly changing within the general public. Compared to 1969, when only 12% of Americans supported legalizing marijuana, the majority of Americans today support legalizing its recreational use. Sixteen states have decriminalized the possession of marijuana — it is not fully legal in these states, but there are no criminal consequences for simple possession (Bloom, 2015). Furthermore, it is legal to purchase marijuana in four states — Alaska, Colorado, Oregon, and Washington — as well as in the District of Columbia (Stebbins, 2015). For a substance classified as a Schedule I drug, marijuana has become increasingly accepted in American culture.
The Social Cost of Drug Criminalization
The war on drugs has become unpopular with the majority of Americans. The criminalization of drugs has become one of the biggest drivers of prison overcrowding; more than half of federal prisoners in the U.S. have been convicted of drug-related crimes. Many families have had their lives directly affected by this policy. Even families that have had no direct or indirect interaction with drug enforcement operations are affected through their tax dollars, which fund the arrest, prosecution, and incarceration of individuals convicted on drug charges.
References
AMA. (N.d.). History of the American Medical Association (AMA) and marijuana. Retrieved from ProCon.org.
Bloom, S. (2015, July 2). States where marijuana is legal, decriminalized or medicalized. Retrieved from Celebstoner.
Castillo, S. (2015, May 6). Marijuana vs. alcohol: The effects psychoactive drugs have on physical and mental health. Retrieved from Medical Daily.
Head, T. (N.d.). Key facts about the war on drugs. Retrieved from Civil Liberties.
Kain, E. (2011, July 5). Ten years after decriminalization, drug abuse down by half in Portugal. Retrieved from Forbes.
Stebbins, S. (2015, September 16). The next 11 states that will legalize marijuana. Retrieved from Market Watch.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.