Socratic Argument In The Apology, Socrates Is Essay

PAGES
4
WORDS
1259
Cite

Socratic Argument In the Apology, Socrates is being placed on trial by three of his rivals for different activities that he is accused of being involved in. The most notable include: corrupting the youth of Athens and not supporting the same religious beliefs as everyone else. During the trial, his enemies are utilizing these charges to demonstrate how he knowingly engaged in these actions. They are demanding that he apologize for the crimes that he committed and begin to conform to the most common practices in contemporary society. (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)

However, Socrates uses this as a forum to ridicule these individuals, question the legitimacy of the trial and to defend himself. This is problematic, as these cavalier attitudes will eventually lead to him being found guilty and sentenced to death. To fully understand what is taking place requires carefully examining his key arguments and how they influenced the jury. Together, these elements will highlight the way he presented his case and the lasting impact. (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)

Main Arguments in the Apology

In the Apology, Socrates tells the jury how their minds have been influenced by his enemies. They are focused on destroying him at all costs and are jealous of his success. This is because he is more intellectual and sophisticated than they are. These individuals cannot stand the fact that he is wiser than them and wants to discredit him at any cost. (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)

Evidence of this can be seen with Socrates saying, "There have been many who have accused me...

...

These earlier ones, however, are more so gentleman; they got a hold of your from childhood, persuaded you and accused me quite falsely. They are saying that there is a man named Socrates. He is a wise man, a student of all things in the sky and below the Earth who make the worst arguments stronger." This is illustrating how Socrates believes that he is being framed by his enemies. These arguments are based upon the fact that he is questioning their views of the world and how they see everyone around them. (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)
Next, Socrates claims that he is on a divine mission. This is occurring from his ability to question the ideas of the gods and provide more clarity about the insights of the oracle. According to him, an ignorant man could be misunderstood and is in fact wise. This is because there are many theologians, scholars and poets who are well respects in contemporary society. However, when someone is examining their different works, they will often seem ambiguous and confusing. Only after careful reflection and analysis can everyone gain a greater understanding of these concepts. (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)

As a result, Socrates argues that questioning everything has helped him to have a different perspective of the world around him. When this happens, he is able to provide more insights about the underlying meaning of various social norms and customs. It is at this point that he claims ignorant minds are trying to negatively influence his beliefs (which are leading to the trial and false charges against him). (Plato, 2000) ("The Apology," 2012) ("Analysis of the Apology," 2010)

This is significant in showing how he is supporting the ideas of the deities and traditional theological norms. However, what makes him different is that Socrates is willing to question the interpretations of them and look for more empowering answers. It is from these actions that his enemies are using this. In order, to demonstrate that he is an annoying busy body, who…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Analysis of the Apology. (2010). CMU. Retrieved from http://caae.phil.cmu.edu/cavalier/80250/part2/ApologyAnalysis.html

The Apology. (2012). Spark Notes. Retrieved from: http://www.sparknotes.com/philosophy/apology/analysis.html

Plato. (2000). The Trial and Death of Socrates. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing.


Cite this Document:

"Socratic Argument In The Apology Socrates Is" (2013, March 18) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/socratic-argument-in-the-apology-socrates-86819

"Socratic Argument In The Apology Socrates Is" 18 March 2013. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/socratic-argument-in-the-apology-socrates-86819>

"Socratic Argument In The Apology Socrates Is", 18 March 2013, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/socratic-argument-in-the-apology-socrates-86819

Related Documents

Socrates The main themes of Plato's Apology are the great irony of many of Socrates' claims, his use of the Socratic method of teaching, and his surprising strategy of questioning the fundamental validity of his trial itself, rather than putting on a vigorous and elegant defense of his actions as was expected by both his supporters and detractors, and likely by the people of the jury. Plato's Apology is a detailed

Socrates argues that the accusation is absurd, as the accusation implies that he is solely responsible for the state of the youth. Socrates uses the allegory of a horse trainer to explain that he is a trainer, rather than corruptor, of the youth (Cavalier, "Ancient Philosophy"). Socrates' second argument in his defense is that, had harmed the youth, the philosophy that evil begets evil would dictate that the youth would

In short, Socrates saw the elimination of ignorance as the first step that would lead people to become virtuous. As a result, he created a technique for testing knowledge by argument and questioning that became known as "the Socratic method." Basically, through an ironic mockery of words, Socrates mocks everyone present by mocking himself. He was the wisest man, he says, because he was the only one who understood he

How the respective societies responded to the various ideas? Socrates would have a dramatic impact upon society, as the various ideas he presented would become a part of the moral code that is often cited, as a part of basic sociology. A good example of this can be seen with social contract theory. This simply states that humans are motivated by conscious / unconscious actions and the experiences, they have from

Socrates and Virtue Comparing and Contrasting Virtue in Taoism and Socrates' Philosophy The idea of virtue in Taoism may be compared and contrasted to the idea of virtue in the teachings of Socrates. For Socrates, virtue is related to the pursuit of wisdom through philosophy, and is ordered to that which is true and good. Taoism similarly calls upon the practitioner to devote himself to the Way, which is the order that

Socrates Was Not an Enemy to the State Was Socrates an enemy of the state? There are two appropriate answers -- "yes" and "no." But first a definition of "enemy" is needed. In Mark Twain's short story "The Mysterious Stranger," Satan explains why there will always be war. It is because "a loud little handful" at first instigates it then, "…the great, big, dull bulk of the nation will rub its