Education From The First Paragraph Of His Essay

PAGES
2
WORDS
784
Cite

¶ … Education From the first paragraph of his article it is apparent that John Marsh is questioning the value of a traditional college graduation -- ridiculing the pomp and ceremony that is part of the festivities surrounding commencement in Champaign Illinois. But reading deeper into the article by Marsh one can see he and other professors have given altruistically and generously of their time to help create a graduation situation (the Odyssey Project) for low income people in the neighborhood who otherwise would likely not have a chance to further their education.

Mixed in with his description of this alternative educational program with a very modest commencement ceremony is Marsh's questioning of the belief that poverty and other ills are caused by a lack of education. He frankly states that "education alone with not change things" and he believes too much emphasis has been put on education as the way to bring people out of poverty. In short, Marsh, a professor whose education brought him a higher salary then he ever thought he would receive, says the country needs to "stop believing" that education is "a magic potion for the poor or anyone else" (Marsh, 2011, p. 7).

Meanwhile, although he agrees in some ways with Marsh, journalist Mike Rose writes from a somewhat different perspective in his article "What College Can Mean to the Other America." Rose explains that "…Hope and desire are brimming" among students at the

...

Not because they are taking classes in the classics (Plato, Shakespeare, et al.) like the courses Marsh taught; but because they are taking "occupational programs" that enhances their basic skills and prepares them for a real job (Rose, 2011, p. 2).
Rose begins his article by panning President Barack Obama's mantra that America needs to "out-innovate, out-educate, and out-build" our competition, in order for the U.S. To "achieve fuller prosperity." The development of innovation through new technologies may be important, but as far as digging the U.S. out of its terrible economic situation, Rose insists, it is "mostly nonsense" (he quotes from an article in The Economist). Instead of looking at "the horizon of innovation" the leaders in America should be "looking straight in front of us at the tens of millions of chronically unemployed Americans." What is needed is "comprehensive occupational, educational, and social services," Rose writes.

The majority of students…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Marsh, John. "Why Education Is Not an Economic Panacea." The Chronicle of Higher

Education. Retrieved October 2, 2011, from http://chronicle.com/article/why-education-is-not-an/128790/. (2011).

Rose, Mike. "What College Can Mean to the Other America." The Chronicle of Higher

Education. Retrieved October 2, 2011, from http://chronicle.com/article/what-college-can-mean-to-the/128936/.


Cite this Document:

"Education From The First Paragraph Of His" (2011, October 03) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/education-from-the-first-paragraph-of-his-52276

"Education From The First Paragraph Of His" 03 October 2011. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/education-from-the-first-paragraph-of-his-52276>

"Education From The First Paragraph Of His", 03 October 2011, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/education-from-the-first-paragraph-of-his-52276

Related Documents

Optometric Employment As the primary eye care profession, optometry provides a uniquely rewarding opportunity to improve the health and general well-being of persons afflicted with mild to severe eye conditions. In addition to helping people see and function more easily in the world, optometry is an attractive career path for students seeking to balance a challenging and rewarding career with an equally rewarding personal life, as it provides you with

Education Richard Rodriguez and Mike Rose both write about their education. In "I Just Wanna Be Average," Mike Rose recounts his experience in Catholic school as an Italian-American from a working class family background. Because of a school error, he was placed in the vocational tract at school. The experience taught Rose a lot about the low expectations place on students, the lack of effective role models in the classroom, and

Auto loans, credit card loans, and mortgages have all declined. Another issue plaguing higher education is how to curtail of abates the influence of these rising costs on the lives of their students. Many of these costs are indirectly correlated to tuition and are therefore uncontrollable in a market subsidized by government. However, many issues are directly related to the tuition, and are therefore controllable. These include student demographics, institution

When this phase is complete, the assessment phase can begin. Step 7: Assessment Assessment will occur on two basic levels: informal and formal. Informal assessment will occur during the group work process, where each group is assessed for its ability to cooperate and learn from each other. A value out of 10 is assigned for each group, where higher values denote a higher level of cooperation. Formal assessment will occur in two

We must move from knowledge that lives in books to knowledge that lives in students. 3. Identify at least two areas of weakness in the Erickson text. Provide a rationale for selecting each area of weakness identified. It is difficult for me to identify any weaknesses in the Erickson text. Her arguments and opinions are all supported by research. Neither her analysis nor presentation was lacking. Upon reflection - perhaps her

While both gender and race are positionalities that are difficult to hide (not that one should need or want to, anyway), sexual orientation is not necessarily something that is known about a person, and its affects on the learning process can be very different. The very fact that sexual orientation can be hidden can create a situation where the learner closes off, hiding not only their sexuality but demurring away