Mental Health and the U.S. Criminal Justice System
This paper examines the systemic failures of the U.S. criminal justice system in addressing the needs of individuals with mental illness. Drawing on a review of current literature, the paper traces the origins of the problem to the deinstitutionalization of psychiatric hospitals beginning in the 1960s, which shifted mentally ill individuals from treatment settings into the criminal justice system. The paper surveys current conditions — including overrepresentation of mentally ill persons in jails and prisons, the harmful effects of solitary confinement, and high recidivism rates linked to co-occurring substance use disorders — and projects future consequences if no reforms are enacted. Six concrete policy recommendations are proposed: revamping crisis response, establishing therapeutic diversion units, addressing dual-diagnosis recidivism, accounting for racial disparities, reducing unnecessary criminal justice contact, and prioritizing early intervention.
- Introduction: Framing the problem and defining mental illness
- Background: Deinstitutionalization and Criminalization: How hospital closures shifted mentally ill into prisons
- Current Issues in the Criminal Justice System: Overrepresentation, solitary confinement, recidivism, and crisis response failures
- Probable Future Concerns: Costs and consequences of maintaining the status quo
- Policy Recommendations: Six reforms to improve criminal justice mental health outcomes
- Conclusion: Call for stakeholder collaboration and systemic reform
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its argument in a clear definition of mental illness at the outset, ensuring analytical consistency throughout the discussion.
- It moves logically from historical context to current conditions to future projections before arriving at recommendations — a structure that makes the policy case compelling and well-supported.
- Each recommendation is tied directly back to evidence cited earlier in the paper, creating strong internal coherence between the problem analysis and the proposed solutions.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper effectively uses a problem-cause-consequence-solution framework. By first establishing the historical roots of the crisis (deinstitutionalization), then documenting its present-day manifestations with empirical sources, and finally projecting future costs of inaction, the author builds a layered evidential foundation that makes each policy recommendation feel both necessary and actionable. This technique is particularly useful in applied policy writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an abstract and introduction that frame the core problem and define key terms. A background section traces the historical origins of the issue. A current-issues section documents present conditions using peer-reviewed studies. A future-concerns section projects negative outcomes if the status quo continues. The recommendations section offers six labeled, discrete policy proposals supported by earlier evidence. The conclusion briefly synthesizes the argument and emphasizes stakeholder collaboration.
Introduction
Various researchers and analysts in the criminal justice realm have observed that a disproportionate percentage of mentally ill individuals are incarcerated in U.S. jails and prisons. Assessments of the country's criminal justice system further indicate that it fails to meet the treatment demands of mentally ill individuals who interact with the system at one point or another. What exists at this moment is a criminal justice system that is effectively rigged against persons with mental illness. With ineffective arrest and detention policies, a disproportionate number of mentally ill persons are sent to prison, only for their conditions to be worsened by an unconducive jail environment. When these persons are released, they lack access to treatment and therapeutic services that would decrease their chances of re-engaging with the criminal justice system — a dynamic that creates a vicious cycle. For this problem to be addressed effectively, there is a need not only to trace its genesis, but also to explore the current state of affairs and consider the consequences of inaction. Only then can meaningful recommendations be made to ensure that the criminal justice system is responsive to the unique needs of mentally ill persons.
From the outset, it is worth noting that symptoms associated with various mental health conditions are subject to interpretation by mental health experts. However, for purposes of this discussion, a concise and definitive definition of mental illness is necessary. As Remch et al. (2021) indicate, mental illness may be conceptualized as "any diagnosed mental disorder (excluding substance abuse disorders) currently associated with serious impairment in psychological, cognitive, or behavioral functioning that substantially interferes with the person's ability to meet the ordinary demands of living" (p. 621). This is the definition embraced throughout this discussion.
Background: Deinstitutionalization and Criminalization
Various theorists and experts have argued that the criminal justice system should treat offenders presenting with symptoms of mental illness differently than those who are mentally sound. For instance, as Scully (2021) — cited in a National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) piece — notes, "in the mid-1800s, Dorothea Dix first advocated for the creation of a system of care for people with mental illness after she witnessed deplorable conditions in a Massachusetts jail." Previous studies have also demonstrated that incarceration can worsen mental health disorders (Remch et al., 2021).
Montross (2020) argues that various government decisions made over the past several decades have led to the current inappropriate handling of mentally ill persons by the criminal justice system. According to the author, the increase in the number of mentally ill persons in prison was originally triggered by the systematic closure of state psychiatric hospitals — a process that unfolded primarily during the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s. To a large extent, this move was well-intentioned, as it followed findings that some long-term psychiatric institutions were notorious for cruel and egregious treatment of patients. It was established that asylums were in some instances worsening the very problem they were meant to solve, hence the decision to defund and close them and shift care to community settings. However, according to Montross (2020), the intended gains were never realized. Relevant social support systems were never established, and treatment and vocational training needs were never addressed as originally planned. As Montross (2020) observes, "without funds, without treatment, and suddenly also without housing, our nation's most vulnerable citizens fell out of health care and into the realm of the legal system… the criminalization of mental illness had begun."
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.