Substance Abuse Disorder That Can Mimic a Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

substance abuse disorder that can mimic a mental health or medical diagnosis. -Addictions or substance abuse counseling

Brooks, AJ & Penn, PE (2003) Comparing Treatments for Dual Diagnosis: Twelve-Step and Self-Management and Recovery Training THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF DRUG AND ALCOHOL ABUSE, 29, 359 -- 383

Brooks and Penn (2003) compared the effectiveness of the 12-step approach with the cognitive-behavioral (Self-Management and Recovery Training [SMART]) approach for people with a dual diagnosis of serious mental illness and substance use disorder. The 112 participants were tested in an intensive outpatient/partial hospitalization setting and were assigned to two treatment conditions. 50 participants completed the 6-month treatment program. The participants were tested during five intermittent periods. Researchers discovered that the 12 Steps program was more efficacious in decreasing alcohol use and increasing social interactions, but that it resulted in a worsening of medical problems, health status, employment status, and psychiatric hospitalization. SMART, on the other hand, showed positive associating with finding employment and improved psychiatric status, but it resulted in increased drug (specifically marijuana) use. Both approaches showed decrease in use of alcohol and increase in life satisfaction. The participants who stayed longer with either program showed greater improvement, whilst completion of the entire program showed positive association with better financial health, less alcohol use, and fewer medical problems.

Although initially a large sample was involved (112 individuals), only 50 completed the program and this may provide too small a sample against which one can draw conclusions for an entire population of people with dual diagnosis. 70 individuals completed a 3-month segment. This shows partial results and is a bit larger. Nonetheless, when one considers the general population of people with dual diagnosis, this, too, may be too small. This is particularly so since so many other variables intervene in influencing factors such as employment, illness, alcohol use, and health status and the demographics of these participants may not have considered every factor, nor may they include factors that individuals outside this sample may experience.

On the other hand, the participants were rigidly tested five times, during different periods of the study, in order to control for distracting factors and in order to follow their progress. Five authoritative and reliable measures were used to test for key constructs and sufficient time (a year) was given following relapse in order to see whether symptoms had disappeared. A significant number of the participants showed similarities in reductions of the same symptoms, and since a pattern appeared and testing was consistent one can say that results were interesting and contributive. However, the disorder does have a cyclical nature and involves far more complex impairments than were taken into consideration in this study.

As regards helpfulness of this study, it is certainly helpful in pointing to practitioners the various benefits of both 12 Steps and the SMART program. Each offers its particular benefits and each contributes different results. The study is immensely helpful in pointing out the results of each. A recommendation would be to integrate both programs for maximum efficacy. Nonetheless, further study, involving multiple measures of substance use and conducted on larger and more diverse populations would be helpful.

2. Timko, C, Dixon, K., & Moos, RH (2005). Treatment for Dual Diagnosis Patients in the Psychiatric and Substance Abuse Systems Mental Health Services Research, 7, 4,

The purpose of this study was to investigate and compare the extent to which psychiatric and substance abuse programs treated dual diagnosis patients in their residential and outpatient Modalities and whether their treatment was affective for this population sample. Managers of 753 programs in the Department of Veterans Affairs that had treatment programs oriented for this population completed surveys .Researchers found that both psychiatric and substance abuse programs contained commonalities. Substance abuse programs, however, seemed to be superior to psychiatric interventions in that they offered helpful supplementary programs such as cognitive behavioral treatment programs as well as assignment of a single case manager to each patient. More so, outpatient psychiatric programs also tested poor on essential management aspects as well as lacking key treatments. Dual-diagnosis is a recurring and recycling situation, and both psychiatric and substance abuse programs lacked long-term interventions that were necessary to deal with the recurrence of the problem. The researchers, therefore, concluded by prescribing…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Substance Abuse Disorder That Can Mimic A" (2012, October 23) Retrieved December 7, 2016, from

"Substance Abuse Disorder That Can Mimic A" 23 October 2012. Web.7 December. 2016. <>

"Substance Abuse Disorder That Can Mimic A", 23 October 2012, Accessed.7 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Personality Disorders and Drug Disorders

    Therefore, it is likely that "men who are highly comorbid for antisocial PD and alcohol and drug use disorders are more likely to die young or be incarcerated than women and thus less likely to be represented in general population surveys." (Grant et al., 2006, p. 128). However, because incarcerated or dead men do not present for treatment, these findings are still of use to the practitioner. Conclusion Both articles do

  • Treatment of Co Occurring Disorders the

    Clients attend multiple twelve-step meetings and participate in twelve-step work to gain freedom from alcohol and/or drug addiction. In addition, they participate in individual and group counseling in order to alleviate the depression and anxiety underlying the addiction ("Dual diagnosis...," 2006). Happiness, in their opinion, is the cure for addictions. Giving and receiving love is the key to happiness. This concept is the main reason for Hope and Serenity's success

  • Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and Alcoholism Addiction

    Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and Alcoholism/Addiction Narrative Alcoholism and Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Overview PTSD and Co morbidity of Alcoholism: The Role of Trauma Childhood Abuse and Gender Differences in PTSD Association Between Alcoholism and Emotion Genetic and Environmental Influences Models of Assessment/Conclusions Abstract TC "Abstract" f C l "1" This study will examine the relationship between post traumatic stress disorder and alcoholism/addiction. The author proposes a quantitative correlation analysis of the relationship between PTSD and alcoholism be conducted to

  • Anxiety Disorders Have Been Increasingly

    Likewise, anxiety and depression represent the most prevalent problems facing young adults attending college, with these two conditions being ranked first and third, respectively, among college students seeking counseling services (Mccarthy, Fouladi, Juncker & Matheny, 2006). According to Armstrong and her associates (2003), adolescence and young adulthood is a period in life when most people engage in explorative behaviors and test their limits in ways that may contribute to their

  • Anti Social Personality Disorder Antisocial Personality

    Treatment and therapy for the condition is sought after clinical psychologists, in most cases when they face multiple court charges, diagnose the patient. Treatment of the condition entails the use of behavioral treatments like reward and punishment methods in psychology. A patient with antisocial personality disorder is rewarded for displaying the correct behavior, under the positive reinforcement method. Negative reinforcement entails promise and use negative consequences for any illegal

  • Eating Disorders Anorexia Nervosa Bulimia Nervosa Binge Eating

    Eating Disorders: Anorexia Nervosa, Bulimia Nervosa, Binge-Eating Disorder, Night Eating Syndrome and Eating Disorders Not Otherwise Specified Eating disorders are psychological illnesses associated with a host of adverse medical conditions, negative psychological affects, and substantial reductions in quality of life. This paper will explore some of the causes research has attributed to this behavior. According to Leslie Sim, et al. (2010) the main eating disorders are anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, binge-eating

  • Depressive Disorder According to the DSM

    Depressive Disorder According to the DSM -- IV -- TR (2000), Major Depressive Disorder is classified by the number of Major Depressive Episodes -- although only one is needed in order to diagnose Major Depressive Disorder -- and according to the severity, ranging from mild, moderate, severe without psychotic features, or severe with psychotic features (347). This means that, in practice, the signs or symptoms of Major Depressive Disorder are

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved