Verified Document

Child Protection Law And Admissible Evidence Essay

Florida Child Law

1. Yes, some of the statements made by Susan would be admissible as evidence in court pursuant to the Florida Rules of Evidence. Specifically, the statement she made to the attending nurse at the emergency room would likely be admissible as an excited utterance, which is a statement made under the stress of a startling event and before the person has had time to reflect or fabricate. The legal justification for admitting an excited utterance is that it is considered to be inherently reliable due to the spontaneous and sincere nature of the statement (Excited Utterance (90.802(2))).

2. Yes, Susan's therapist or the treating physician could be called to testify in this case. The permissible scope of their testimony would likely be limited to their observations and interactions with Susan, including any statements she made to them about the alleged abuse. However, they would likely be prohibited from offering any opinion or conclusion as to whether or not the abuse actually occurred.

3. Yes, Susan's mother could be called to testify against her former husband. However, any statements made by the former husband to his lawyer would likely be protected by attorney-client privilege and would not be admissible in court unless the privilege is waived by the former husband (Lawyer Client Privilege 90.502). These statements would constitute hearsay within the legal definition provided in the Florida Rules of Evidence, as they are being offered for their truth but are not being made under oath by the person who made them.

4. Yes, Susan could be forced to undergo a court-ordered evaluation pursuant to the Florida Rules of Juvenile Procedure. The court has the authority to order a psychological or psychiatric evaluation of a child if it is deemed necessary to assist in the resolution of the case (Fla.R.Juv.P. 8.250). However, the evaluation would have to be conducted by a qualified professional and would be subject to certain confidentiality and privacy protections. Ultimately, Section 39.201 grants the dependency court jurisdiction over cases involving abused children, which may include Susan's case if the allegations are proven.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Court Services Management
Words: 1519 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Court Systems The structure and platform on which the legal system is based upon is very important in understanding the total landscape of how justice is carried out within the confines of the government. The purpose of this essay is to explore the inner workings of both the federal and state court systems and highlight their similarities and differences. Also, this essay will investigate the roles of court administrators in the

Court Management Policy Proposal
Words: 2514 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Court Management Policy Proposal The retributive and rehabilitative approaches of justice are dominant, and research suggests that they have disappointed the juvenile legal system. The rise in youth crime and critiques of the juvenile legal approaches has led to demands for reforms in the way of charging youth offenders. The retributive approach of justice suggests that juvenile offenses are violations against the state and holds the state accountable for sentencing youth

Court Services Management
Words: 1436 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Court Service Management How does a court system cope with a changing of the guard when a new administration is elected and key executives and managers are replaced, and/or when policy changes direction as a new political party assumes power? The court deals with transitions of power by maintaining the established traditions and principles from the Constitution. This is used to ensure that case precedent is respected and to provide stability for

Court Analysis Justice and Court Administration and
Words: 1185 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Court Analysis Justice and Court Administration Administration and management of courts is filled with challenges. Often depending upon the geographical context of the court, such challenges will include resource shortage, a perpetual docket of criminal cases and the broader complexity of providing civil order and justice to communities while balancing constitutional law and local ordinance. Moreover, the complexity of administering justice in and of itself plays a part in the difficulty of

Court Case Historically, Gaines V.
Words: 3457 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

But if Houston insisted that Plessy be enforced that is, if the NAACP sued a state to make its schools for black children equal to those for whites which Plessy did require then he could undermine segregation. (Jomills Henry Braddock. A Long-Term View of School Desegregation: Some Recent Studies of Graduates as Adults. Phi Delta Kappan. 259-61. 1984) He reasoned that states would either have to build new schools for

Court System Understanding the Court
Words: 1058 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

In his joint article with Oleg Smirnov, "Drift, Draft, or Drag: How the Supremes React to New Members," Smith takes an even closer look at the Supreme Court and the history of its political (or interpretive) makeup. Specifically, these authors find that the Court counter-balances changes to its ideological makeup through the addition of new members by changes in the overall interpretative stances of opposing justices -- the addition of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now