Verified Document

Conscientious Objection In Nursing Ethics Situation Case Study

Applying Ethical Principles

The case study selected is "Conscientious Objection and Professional Responsibility," involving Nurse Amelia Brooks and Dr. Rebecca Martin at Riverside Medical Center. The ethical dilemma arises when Nurse Brooks, who has strong personal beliefs against abortion, is asked to assist in an elective abortion procedure for Sophie Turner. This situation presents a conflict between Amelia's personal convictions and her professional responsibilities.

Involved Parties

1. Nurse Amelia Brooks: Struggles with the decision to participate in the abortion procedure due to her religious beliefs.

2. Dr. Rebecca Martin: The obstetrician requesting Amelia's assistance.

3. Sophie Turner: The patient opting for an elective abortion.

4. The Medical Center: Represents the professional environment and standards of care.

Analysis Using Ethical Decision-Making Model

Moral awareness, moral judgment and ethical behavior are at the heart of this case. Amelia recognizes the conflict between her personal beliefs and professional duty. The core issue with her is balancing personal conscience with the obligation to provide patient care without discrimination. This is her moral awareness. Amelia must decide whether to prioritize her moral convictions or her professional responsibility to assist in medical procedures as needed. This is where her moral judgment comes into play. How Amelia chooses to act on her moral judgment, considering the potential impacts on all parties involved, will be the subject of her ethical behavior.

Factors Contributing to the Ethical Problem

The...

Amelias religious beliefs strongly influence her view on abortion, creating a personal moral conflict. The nursing profession mandates providing unbiased care to all patients, which clashes with Amelia's personal stance. The patient's right to choose medical procedures must be respected, complicating Amelia's decision. And, finally, legal and institutional policies may dictate...
…both Amelia's beliefs and the patient's rights, fostering professional collaboration and understanding within the organization.

Communication and Collaboration

Amelia's approach should promote open dialogue and respect for diverse viewpoints, enhancing interprofessional relationships. The likelihood of fostering professional collaboration depends on the institutional support for conscientious objection and the presence of policies facilitating such scenarios.

Conclusion

The case of Nurse Amelia Brooks shows the kind of the complicated interplay of personal ethics and professional duties that one might encounter in the field of nursing. This case especially shows the need for healthcare institutions to acknowledge and effectively manage conscientious objections so that patient care is not compromised. This analysis can be a guide for healthcare professionals in dealing with similar ethical dilemmas. It emphasizes the importance of using ethical decision-making models, shows how effective communication can help, and how one can apply the tools and benefits of academic research in resolving ethical…

Sources used in this document:

References

Gamble, N., & Saad, T. (2022). A taxonomy of conscientious objection in healthcare. ClinicalEthics, 17(1), 63-70.

Kwame, A., & Petrucka, P. M. (2021). A literature-based study of patient-centered care andcommunication in nurse-patient interactions: barriers, facilitators, and the way forward. BMC nursing, 20(1), 1-10.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nursing Ethics in the Late 20th and
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Ethics In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, medical technology has advanced enough to provide certain measures to keep the body "alive," but not necessarily the brain or the cognitive functions that make up quality of life (O'Keefe-McCarthy, 2009). Despite the fact that death is a cyclical part of life, humans still have a very difficult time dealing with issues surrounding terminal illness: hospice, do not resuscitate, costs for

Nursing Ethics Ethical Dilemma Ethics Identify the
Words: 865 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Ethics Ethical Dilemma Ethics Identify the potential ethical dilemma A nurse accused of stealing. She is a good nurse but cannot be allowed to continue stealing and breaking the law while she is performing her duties. Collect, analyze, and interpret data Nurses must protect clients' well-being, even while they strive to support other nurses. The case study is presented in such a manner which suggests that the nurse manager is fairly certain, given the evidence

Nursing Ethics Alcohol Consumption Among
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

In terms of underage drinking, a nurse can act in a public health manner that identifies circumstances and situations that make a population vulnerable, and take steps to either mitigate those circumstances or educate to prevent them in the first place. Colleagues -- Nursing is never a field in isolation. Instead, it works with a number of colleagues in various disciplines to support health issues. This would include teachers, school

Nursing Ethics Ethical Behavior, Especially in the
Words: 619 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing Ethics Ethical behavior, especially in the medical community, is important in all aspects, but especially in the treatment of patients. All patients, no matter what their religious affiliations or beliefs, deserve the best possible treatment within their own particular guidelines. Treating members of the Jehovah's Witness religion is a task that while not commonplace, will certainly be touched upon by most members of the nursing community. Looking for guidelines regarding the

Nursing Ethics the Most Important
Words: 435 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Would the advance(s) keep the patient alive just to keep her/him alive, or would the patient be capable of a productive and enjoyable way of living? These questions lead right into the code of ethics and the very first one deals with the respect for human dignity. Human dignity can encompass a variety of components and it must be considered when applying bioethics or ethics in general to prolonging someone's life

Nursing Ethics a Strong Ethical Component Undergirds
Words: 972 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Ethics A strong ethical component undergirds the nursing profession. Nurses have an express duty to care, and we are driven by the desire to help others. When completing the "My Nursing Ethic" questionnaire, I was asked to search for the roots of my passion and motivation. I was also asked to consider who or what inspires me, and to whom I am loyal. It is this latter question that becomes

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now