Jean Franco's Argument Jean Franco Term Paper

PAGES
3
WORDS
1113
Cite

Tell Them Not to Kill Me!" is a story about revenge. An old man pleads to his own son, Justino, to intervene on his behalf, and try to save his life. Another son, colonel, has come back and orders the old man to be shot - years ago during a drought he had killed the colonel's father: "There he was, slumped down at the foot of the post. His son Justino had come and his son Justino had gone and had returned and now was coming again." (Rulfo: 289). Fear is the main feeling driving the old man; he begs for his life and struggles to survive in every way he can think of. His fear of dying is opposed to the colonel's coldness and decisiveness as he does not change his mind despite the old man's begging and crying. In the case of this story, machismo is not the trait of superiority of men over women, but the superiority of man over man.

Fury and the thirst for revenge engulf any other feelings. Love does not exist. It is not the love of a son that is fueling the colonel's thirst for vengeance, but hatred. Although the colonel himself has lost his father who had been cruelly murdered, he does not find it in his heart to forgive the old man who was responsible for the murder. However, the colonel does show some mercy when ordering his men to make the execution as painless as possible for the old man: "Immediately the voice from inside said, 'Tie him up and give him something to

...

The old man, on the other hand, admits to his crime and is aware of its implications. His is not so much a struggle to survive but one not to be killed. That could perhaps account for the fact that he begs his son to go and talk to the colonel on his behalf, and try to convince the latter to spare his life.
In this world there seems to be no room for compassion or forgiveness. Neither the colonel nor the old man can truly hear what the other one is saying because the conclusion that Rulfo wants to convey is that man is lonely and isolated. In this sense, there is an almost Biblical feel to this story in which human nature struggles to reassert itself through the old man's desire to live, and his pathetic anxiety to convince the colonel that he has already paid for his sins by living the life of a "leper." Mexican society as described by Rulfo especially in this story is dominated by the idea of revenge, and does not feature forgiveness. Instead, this society is based on the concept of "eye for an eye," and the colonel is not moved by human suffering, but by vengeance and hatred..

Rulfo, Juan. "Macario." The Burning Plain: and other Stories. University of Texas Press, 1971. 2-9.

Rulfo, Juan. "Tell them not to kill me!." The Burning Plain: and other Stories. University of Texas Press, 1971. 83-105.

Sources Used in Documents:

In this world there seems to be no room for compassion or forgiveness. Neither the colonel nor the old man can truly hear what the other one is saying because the conclusion that Rulfo wants to convey is that man is lonely and isolated. In this sense, there is an almost Biblical feel to this story in which human nature struggles to reassert itself through the old man's desire to live, and his pathetic anxiety to convince the colonel that he has already paid for his sins by living the life of a "leper." Mexican society as described by Rulfo especially in this story is dominated by the idea of revenge, and does not feature forgiveness. Instead, this society is based on the concept of "eye for an eye," and the colonel is not moved by human suffering, but by vengeance and hatred..

Rulfo, Juan. "Macario." The Burning Plain: and other Stories. University of Texas Press, 1971. 2-9.

Rulfo, Juan. "Tell them not to kill me!." The Burning Plain: and other Stories. University of Texas Press, 1971. 83-105.


Cite this Document:

"Jean Franco's Argument Jean Franco" (2008, April 06) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jean-franco-argument-jean-franco-30935

"Jean Franco's Argument Jean Franco" 06 April 2008. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jean-franco-argument-jean-franco-30935>

"Jean Franco's Argument Jean Franco", 06 April 2008, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/jean-franco-argument-jean-franco-30935

Related Documents

" Here, Burke argued that revolution in general, and the French Revolution in particular, must be matched with reason and a reluctance to completely give up to radical thinking. Rousseau gave in directly to the revolution, arguing that it is a direct result of man's socialization, but Burke was much more cautious: Revolution is not automatically good for Burke, nor is it intrinsic to man. Given Burke's record as a strong supporter of

Cholera Aging Always Puts a
PAGES 10 WORDS 3261

Professor Mabel Morana of Washington University in St. Louis, professor of Spanish and Latin American Studies, explains that Garcia Marquez is a genius at restoring the "time-honored mission of entertaining by means of the mere act of narrating" (Morana, 1990). In other words, Garcia Marquez's writing is so effective it really isn't crucially important who or what he is writing about. Just jump on board and enjoy the ride. Getting

Europe After World War II Historical Development Unification Historical Development of Unification Ideas in Europe after World War II Europe was torn to shreds by the ugly forms of national and ethnic hatred after World War II (1939-1945). Europe is geographically situated in middle of such a global power system, where failing of peace means global annihilation. After World War II, the Europeans established such a framework that can allow peace and regional

Spring Breakers and Rape Culture In the film Spring Breakers, four young girls who look to be in their late teens or early twenties go on Spring Break. However, they do not have the money for a vacation and three members of the group, Brit, Candy, and Cotty, rob a fast food restaurant to fund the trip. The so-called innocent one of the group, Faith, is shocked by their actions but

Country of Origin Effect on
PAGES 20 WORDS 6167

With this in mind communications strategy has to be developed and implemented. The central debate remains that of degree of uniformity. The pros and cons are obvious, i.e. economies of scale, consistent message across markets, centralized control, different market characteristics, media availability and costs and government regulations (Balabanis & Diamantopoulos, 2011). The stronger argument appears to be that different strategy appears to work in different situations, rather than a

The characters in the film are multi-layered. When we get below the surface we find that these members of the aristocracy do not present a favorable appearance at all. Their hidden world is one of scandal. Renoir's characters go beyond a love triangle. They come to represent many complex relationships and interactions. There are love triangles within love triangles and many innuendos throughout the film. The revelation of these many