Moment Of Reflection Vs Moment Of Prayer Term Paper

PAGES
1
WORDS
323
Cite

Illinois Silent Reflection Act

The Illinois Silent Reflection Act was passed in 2007 and requires that all public schools begin each day with a moment of silence for silent reflection, during which students may engage in silent prayer or reflection. This law was challenged in court, but the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals upheld its constitutionality. The appellate court upheld the act in 2011, ruling that it was not an unconstitutional establishment of religion. This decision is in line with the Supreme Court's ruling in Kennedy v. Bremerton in 1984, which found that moments of silence can be constitutionally permissible. The Supreme Court in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District found that a similar moment of silence law in Washington was constitutional, as long as the state's intent was to promote quiet reflection rather than religious worship.

Possible concerns raised by students and parents about the Illinois Silent Reflection Act might include worries that this could be used to promote religious prayer or indoctrination in public schools. Additionally, some may feel that this infringes on their right to free speech as it limits the ability to use this time for other purposes. Another concern is that it may be perceived as promoting or endorsing a particular religion, or that it may make students who do not wish to participate feel uncomfortable or marginalized. Some might even argue that a moment of silence is not an effective way to promote reflection or quiet contemplation.

I would say that moments of reflection can be helpful in gathering ones thoughts, and that the state should not prohibit them just because some might take the opportunity to pray. Prayer is not illegal and should not be made illegal, just because some object to it. The court was right to uphold the Act, and make moments of reflection available to students.

References

Illinois General Assembly. (2022). (105ILCS20/) Silent Reflection and Student Prayer

Act. Retrieved from https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=1008&ChapterID=17

Cite this Document:

"Moment Of Reflection Vs Moment Of Prayer" (2023, January 13) Retrieved April 28, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moment-reflection-vs-prayer-term-paper-2178061

"Moment Of Reflection Vs Moment Of Prayer" 13 January 2023. Web.28 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moment-reflection-vs-prayer-term-paper-2178061>

"Moment Of Reflection Vs Moment Of Prayer", 13 January 2023, Accessed.28 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/moment-reflection-vs-prayer-term-paper-2178061

Related Documents

Holistic Victim Restitution Plan Reflection Victimology is one of the disciplines that has emerged in the criminal justice field to examine situations and vulnerabilities that make it more likely for people to become victims of crime. Additionally, this discipline also focuses on examining and understanding the harm people suffer due to being victims of crime or illegal activities. One of the core components of victimology is understanding who and/or what are

Origin of Evil The origin of evil has been a controversial issue not only in the contemporary Christian circles but also among the ancient Greek Christians. The point of contention in the discussion about the origin of evil is why a good God would have created evil. The Judeo-Christians struggled to understand how a good, powerful, and all-knowing God could allow evil to exist. The logical conclusions were that either God

Journals of Herrera and Gottleib Books A healthy child is the joy of the family. Social and academic development of a child depend on his ability to use his eyes and ears effectively. When one of these organs is impaired, the child will face challenges to communicate or see effectively, which will affect the child's social and academic developments. When a child has developed a vision or ear impairment, early

Assessment Competencies Abstract Assessment in education is referred to a range of tools or methods used by educators to measure, document and evaluate the academics readiness, skill acquisition, progress and learning needs of students. The tracking progress report plays an important role to the student since it gauges where they are heading in terms of academics. Assessment is often likened to the traditional standardized tests but educators nowadays, use different types of

Discussion Reflection 1. I think the concepts that were most interesting to me in this class were more the high level concepts like the Five Forces. These are the sorts of tools that I think can be relevant in any industry. They force you to think not just about what the company does, but how the business works. For example, you can be good at some aspect of the business, but

theological education is, as Trokan suggests, "to promote personal wisdom," then theological reflection is an essential component of that education (144). According to Paver, there are numerous approaches to theological reflection including ministerial, spiritual, wisdom, feminist, enculturation and practical styles (36). Each of these has relevance and can be part of a holistic and comprehensive theological undertaking that has meaning, value, and practical purpose. Of these styles, the spiritual