Verified Document

Restorative Justice In Education." In Other Words, Dissertation Or Thesis Complete

¶ … Restorative Justice in Education." In other words, how effective does the use of critical theory prove to be when applied to restorative justice in education? Author Dorothy Vaandering uses a logic and flow-driven narrative, which is informative and leaves a distinct impression that she has provided a worthwhile study for examination. What is restorative justice? Vaandering explains that restorative justice (RJ) is a process that eschews "punitive, managerial structures" in education -- that is, the "old school" system of hard core discipline that promises punishment if instructions are not followed -- and replaces those strategies with policies that "emphasize the building and repairing of relationships" (Vaandering, 2010, p. 145). Basically, RJ is a policy that allows the perpetrator of a wrongdoing to meet and interact with (and apologize to) the person harmed by those actions; and in the case of educational environments, the rather than just punish and isolate the bully, the bully sits down with counselors...

Is RJ a strategy that is sustainable? Does it have "transformative potential" that can bring it from "the margins to the mainstream of schooling"?
By using critical theory Vaandering believes RJ can be understood "in a broader sense" (151). On pages 164-65 Vaandering critiques the "shaming" aspect of RJ, which posits that both the people that offend others and the victims of those offensive actions experience shame. But both people in this scenario will "struggle to know how to deal with their shame if not given opportunity to do so." Hence, the offender (in RJ) might be stigmatized and the result could be him "re-offending, or offending with greater aggression; and the victim…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Logic and Flow (2011). Bloom's Taxonomy.

Vaandering, Dorothy. (2010). The Significance of Critical Theory for Restorative Justice in Education. The Review of Education, Pedagogy, and Cultural Studies, Vol. 32, 145-176.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Restorative Justice Individual Restorative Justice Paper: Case
Words: 1001 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Restorative Justice Individual restorative justice paper: Case study Traditionally, the debate about the purpose of the justice system has revolved around the question of whether punishment should be retributive or rehabilitative in nature. Those who favor a retributive model stress the need for criminals to pay their debts to society and view the purpose of the justice system as primarily to punish convicts through confinement and forcing them to work. Those who

Restorative Justice and School
Words: 3171 Length: 7 Document Type: Literature Review

Restorative justice is something that has become more and more prominent within the criminal justice sphere. The use of the concept and practice has emerged in its own right within the juvenile justice realm. The efficacy of restorative justice when it comes to juvenile offenders is a very important topic because being able to top the patterns of crime, addition and deviance in general is something that should absolutely be

How Restorative Justice Can Mediate Anti-Social Behaviors
Words: 1759 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Social Disorganization Theory There are myriad examples in the literature of how the social disorganization theory links street crimes with ecological themes in certain tough neighborhoods. The sociological aspect of the theory -- wretched socioeconomic conditions and mean, gang-dominated streets offer more of an accounting for crime or delinquency than the individuals who commit crimes -- has been tested and referenced as valid by numerous scholars and researchers. The theory seems

Retributive, Rehabilitative, and Restorative Justice
Words: 773 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Correctional System: Three different approaches and philosophies to the problem of crime The three philosophical cornerstones of the corrections system are retribution, rehabilitation, and restoration. However, while most modern theorists of criminal justice believe that there must be some proportion of these elements in all forms of punishment, not all believe that they must be present to the same degree. This paper will advance the idea that ultimately the concepts of

Change About the Criminal Justice
Words: 2999 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

(d) Retribution serves towards a constructive purpose of -- as Braithwhite calls it -- 'restorative shame' rather than 'stigmatizing shame' In 1988, John Braithwaite published "Crime, shame, and Reintegration" where he introduced his idea of restorative shaming (Braithwaite, 1997). The conventional criminal justice stigmatizes the individual in that it not only makes him a pariah of society thereby making it harder to reform himself, but also crushes his esteem, causing others

Juvenile Justice System in the
Words: 750 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Some of the guidelines have, as Mears indicates, "…veered strongly toward retribution and incapacitation." To wit, politicians run for office on promises to get tough on crime, and hence they pass laws like "three strikes" and "zero tolerance" that do not allow for sentencing that is based on the offender's age, his background, and his previous record (Riestenberg, 2006). The solution that should be sought would be having the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now