LASD Data Manipulation: Flawed Statistics and Public Policy
This paper analyzes a Los Angeles Times article by Maya Lau reporting on the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department's use of flawed and misrepresented data. Drawing on the Huntsman report from the Office of Inspector General, the paper examines how biased data collection methods, inconsistent software systems, and duplicate entries produced inaccurate statistics on inmate assaults, use of force, and in-custody deaths. The analysis considers sampling methods, data validity, hypothesis testing, and the ethical implications of manipulating research findings. It argues that unethical statistical practices can directly distort public policy, with potentially serious consequences for law enforcement accountability and public safety.
- Introduction: Overview of Lau article and its central argument
- Data Collection Methods and Sources: Huntsman report as primary source; software inconsistencies
- Sampling, Data Types, and Reporting: Inmate and officer sampling; quantitative vs. qualitative data
- Visual Representation and Descriptive Statistics: Graphs, central tendency, and variance in LASD reporting
- Research Questions, Hypotheses, and Conclusions: Police brutality hypotheses and misconduct frequency findings
- Ethics of Data and Policy Implications: Ethical failures and their consequences for public policy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Applies specific research methodology concepts — sampling, central tendency, null hypothesis, and validity — directly to a real news article and its primary source, grounding abstract concepts in a concrete case.
- Distinguishes clearly between the secondary source (Lau's article), the primary source (Huntsman report), and the subject being studied (LASD practices), maintaining analytical clarity throughout.
- Connects methodological failures to real-world consequences, showing how flawed data collection can distort public policy on police accountability.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates source-layer analysis — the ability to disaggregate a news article, its primary source report, and the institutional data being critiqued. Rather than treating Lau's article as the sole subject, the writer traces the chain of evidence back to the Huntsman report and then to the Sheriff's Department's own raw data, evaluating research quality at each level.
Structure breakdown
The paper moves logically from source identification and data collection methods, through sampling and reporting practices, to descriptive statistics and visual presentation, and finally to hypothesis framing and ethical implications. Each section maps one or more standard research methodology concepts onto the case study, creating a structured critique that doubles as an applied methodology exercise.
Introduction
The article "Watchdog Says L.A. Sheriff's Department Collects Flawed Data, Reports Inaccurate Statistics" appears in the August 8, 2017 edition of the Los Angeles Times. In the article, reporter Maya Lau demonstrates how the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department misuses statistics. The article illustrates how biases can guide not only the collection of data and the methodology used to test hypotheses, but also how biases can lead to actual changes in public policy with potentially detrimental or disastrous outcomes.
Data Collection Methods and Sources
The Lau article is based on the primary source — the Huntsman report compiled by the Office of Inspector General of Los Angeles County. Data was collected using multiple methods, as the report details the various raw data measures presumably used and collected by the Sheriff's Department. Specifically, data was collected using different types of software that did not necessarily integrate with one another, according to both Huntsman and Lau. Duplicate entries or multiple events would be counted as one, leading to egregious errors in the final figures.
References
Huntsman, Max. "Reform and Oversight Efforts." Office of Inspector General County. Retrieved from: https://oig.lacounty.gov/Portals/OIG/Reports/April%202017%20Reform%20and%20Oversight%20Efforts.pdf?ver=2017-04-05-123559-210
Lau, Maya. "Watchdog Says L.A. Sheriff's Department Collects Flawed Data, Reports Inaccurate Statistics." Los Angeles Times. 8 Aug. 2017. Retrieved from: http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-sheriff-statistics-20170808-story.html
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.