Verified Document

Assessing Employee Performance At MFS Case Study

Case Study: Massachusetts Financial Services (MFS) Anti-Star System

The majority of financial service sector industry players embrace a highly competitive, compensation-driven culture in which there is an atmosphere of every person fighting for what is seen as a finite pie. However, the Massachusetts Financial Services (MFS) anti-star system, according to the case study Massachusetts Financial Services (Hall & Lim, 2004), was nothing like this traditional system. MFS prided itself on inventing the mutual fund. However, since creating what is now an industry standard financial product, the company was struggling to maintain motivation in its employees while using a very unique evaluation system to maintain a congenial team-based culture, rather than a competitive one.

Employee Characteristics

In the 1987, when Jeffrey Shames took the companys helm, a critical problem was that compensation was virtually level across the board, with only lower compensation for bottom-level performers. By not incentivizing top-level performers with higher compensation, MFS inevitably attracted less ambitious financial service sector employees. Although this did possibly contribute to a more collegial and team-oriented culture, it also may have discouraged more ambitious employees from joining MFS. On the other hand, some highly talented and competent people were attracted to MFS and its unique approach within in the industry.

One of the main reasons pay-driven employees leave the firm quickly is the fact they are in search of higher bonuses, while employees that want to work in a more pleasant atmosphere are more likely to stay at MFS. MFS, in other words, offers more intrinsic rewards than the typical firm in this industry sector. The firm rationalized that while it might be able...

Fund performance determined only 60% of competitive bonuses, versus subjective measurements like team and organizational contributions (Hall & Lim, 2004,...
…more meaningful fashion. Assessors could also be asked to back up their assessments with specific examples for every positive and negative characteristic they cited.

Transporting the MFS System

Part of the success of MFS is also due to the unique culture of the firm. A high level of trust was required in the assessment, and those doing the assessment. Without this, it is unlikely to be viewed with the same degree of acceptance. This is why requiring a more data-driven, formalized assessment of intrinsic characteristics of employees is likely demanded if the system will continue in the future.

Hedge fund management will be particularly difficult to assess, given that it is dependent upon risk-taking behavior and competitiveness not seen in mutual fund management, although it seems equally critical that the firm seize upon this growing opportunity to expand its revenue. Embracing a two-tiered assessment for hedge and mutual fund managers an maintaining the culture of the firm may not be feasible. A compromise may be necessary in instituting a new system which still incorporates subjective, team-focused elements with a…

Sources used in this document:

References

Hall, B. J. & Lim, J. P. (2004). Massachusetts Financial Services. Cambridge, MA: HarvardBusiness School.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Employee Performance and His or Her Motivation
Words: 1163 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Employee performance and his or her motivation is a key issue in an organization. The latter impacts the former: the more an employee is motivated, the better he is likely to perform. An important problem is that motivation is a complex undertaking: it is not always the financial package that is fundamental to an employee's performance. Studies have shown that employees are also motivated (quite often even more motivated) by other

Employee Performance Appraisal Planning Rudman,
Words: 2020 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

He could for example, provide a different chapter for each type of performance review currently used, and a list of organizations that likely use it. He can then outline the strengths and weaknesses of these reviews, before he provides an explanation of the fixes he would use to change the outcome and perceived lack of interest in performance management. Rudman also gives a very brief explanation of the complaints managers

Employees Performance Appraisals at the
Words: 4257 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

The initial recommendation comes from the employee's direct supervisor and is then discussed with the general director and the payroll manager. At the fourth stage, the performance review, the employee and his direct supervisor come once again face-to-face to discuss the outcome of the performance appraisal process. The employee is informed of the managerial decision regarding future remunerations, and a date for a new meeting is set. The new meeting

Measuring Customer Internal Business Process and Employee Performance...
Words: 1153 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Customer Satisfaction Importance of customer satisfaction The effect of customer satisfaction on a firm's profitability Why measure customer satisfaction How to measure customer satisfaction The affective measures of the degree of customer satisfaction Employee performance The need for measuring employee performance The contemporary business environment which is dynamic and highly competitive requires firms to have a high level of business intelligence. In this paper, we explore the concepts of customer satisfaction as other internal business processes such as

Human Resource Management -- Employee Performance Human
Words: 2186 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Human Resource Management -- Employee Performance Human resource management (HRM) has developed into a crucial component of the contemporary business organization and the professional business environment (Fyock, 2001; George & Jones, 2008; Robbins & Judge, 2009). Today, formal approaches, practices, and procedures dominate employee recruiting, hiring, training, supervision, appraisal, and advancement and only the smallest organizations still perform those functions in the informal ad-hoc manner that used to be common throughout

Effect of Training and Re-education on Employee Performance
Words: 2326 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

In the present day intensely competitive marketplace, businesses must incessantly enhance the level of quality of their products and services in order to gain competitive advantages. Corporations have to attain and capitalize on their resources in an efficacious manner. As a result, it is of the best interest for the corporations to improve the job performances of their staff by carrying out training and education as one of the fundamental

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now