Ethical Problem Or Dilemma The Thesis

Length: 3 pages Sources: 2 Subject: Children Type: Thesis Paper: #77210268 Related Topics: Plastic Surgery, Ethical Dilemma, Ethical Dilemmas, Problem Solution
Excerpt from Thesis :

But "few states with mandatory insurance for IVF still require couples to undergo three cycles of ovulation induction and artificial insemination before IVF" thus encouraging the use of a technology more likely to result in multiple births (Roan, 2007, p.4).

When contemplating the use of fertility drugs or IVF, the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology advocates discussing the possibility of selective reduction and the patient's comfort level with this practice before any procedures are performed. However, its guidelines, are not binding. For example, "the U.S. fertility industry has guidelines on how many embryos doctors can implant, with the number varying by age and other factors. The guidelines call for no more than one or two for a generally healthy woman under 35, and no more than three to five, depending on the embryos' maturity, for women over 40" (Watkins & Neergaard 2008). Eight embryos would be "well beyond" these suggestions, and clinics that clearly violate suggested policies can removed from the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology, which in turn affects whether insurance covers their services. "But the guidelines do not have the force of law" (Watkins & Neergard 2008)


Given the increasing costs of healthcare, a more utilitarian calculus of the use of that technology must be introduced -- relying upon the individual ethics of doctors is not enough. To reduce the costs and risks of fertility drugs and multiple births, what are now only suggested guidelines by the American Medical Association (AMA) must become mandatory. Doctors who violate those guidelines should lose the ability to practice their profession. A cost-benefit analysis of allowing patients to exercise their choice must weigh patient autonomy with the dangers high-risk pregnancies cause to society. Infants with severe health problems, high costs, and other dangers outweigh privacy concerns. If the AMA does not act, then legislative authorities must step in.

Single or competing theories


On a situational basis, one must look at the specific consequences of reproductive technology, specifically fertility drugs, from a health policy perspective, not privacy laws in the abstract.

Public-policy implications

If doctors will not regulate their profession's use of fertility drugs, the government may need to intervene -- however, there is the uncomfortable specter of such laws being challenged by the U.S. Supreme Court in terms of the questions they pose about private reproductive decisions. Demanding more comprehensive coverage by healthcare insurance companies for IVF technology, to reduce use of fertility drugs; mandating preliminary psychiatric screening of individuals seeking treatment; and other limits could be placed upon the technology within the guidelines of past legal precedents.

Normative conclusions

Assisted reproductive technology has a high risk of generating multiple pregnancies, and a high cost for society in terms of the education and medical support of children of multiple births. Thus greater regulation of such technology, such as fertility drugs, must be mandated, ideally by the medically profession itself, or by the U.S. Congress.

Works Cited

Caplan, Arthur. "Ethics and octuplets." The Philadelphia Inquirer. February 6, 2009.

June 13, 2009.

"Extreme multiple births carry tremendous risks." CNN. January 28, 2009. June 13, 2009.

Roan, Shari. "Multiple births, multiple risks." L.A. Times. June 25, 2007. June 13, 2009.

Watkins, Thomas & Lauran Neergaard. "6 kids plus 8 babies: what was the doctor thinking?"

AP Wire. MSNBC. January 28, 2009, June 13, 2009.

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Caplan, Arthur. "Ethics and octuplets." The Philadelphia Inquirer. February 6, 2009.

June 13, 2009.

"Extreme multiple births carry tremendous risks." CNN. January 28, 2009. June 13, 2009.

Cite this Document:

"Ethical Problem Or Dilemma The" (2009, June 13) Retrieved May 17, 2021, from

"Ethical Problem Or Dilemma The" 13 June 2009. Web.17 May. 2021. <>

"Ethical Problem Or Dilemma The", 13 June 2009, Accessed.17 May. 2021,

Related Documents
Ethical Legal Dilemma in Advanced Practice Nursing Case Study
Words: 2822 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 9474142

Ethical-Legal Dillema in Advanced Nursing Practice Ethical-Legal Dilemma involving a Patient in Emergency Department (ED) The case study discussed in this paper presents ethical-legal principles in nursing which protects patient's privacy, confidentiality and security. Nurses have a professional obligation to protect the privacy of patients. Nursing Law and confidentiality define privacy as the right of patients to have their personal, identifiable medical information kept discrete and only accessible to the physician of

Ethical Problems in Business Principle: Ethics May
Words: 1450 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 10747727

Ethical Problems in Business PRINCIPLE: Ethics may be termed as the inner guiding moral principles, values and beliefs people use to indicate and identify what is acceptable and appropriate behavior whilst straying away from the opposite (Jones, 2007). However each individual may perceive different behaviors as acceptable and appropriate depending on the individual's own self-interests, attitudes, beliefs and values. To dig further into the aspects of business ethics, it is primarily a notion for

Ethical/Unethical Dilemma the New Leader
Words: 686 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 95989743

But the main question being asked by the people interested in this issue is if the fortunes play any significant role to the employees in Wuhan. This is quite unfair and unethical since the employees are the ones who make it possible for the products to be available in the market for Apples customers so they should enjoy the benefits the company gets. The financial strength of Apple is not

Ethical/Unethical Dilemma Ethical Dilemma Ethical
Words: 689 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 79430763

The core of the problem that is tied to use of child labor by its suppliers is price. Incase apple tries to police the suppliers they might shift the problem to another part of the firm or even create more problems. This therefore means that Apple should give severe penalties and punishments in combination with general hands off approach to compliance auditing regarding to issues outside the quality of

Ethical Problem: False Advertising False
Words: 2271 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Business - Advertising Paper #: 96092936

" Another member of these matchmaking sites argued that it is illogical for any of these companies to spend several hour of their employee's time to lure someone into paying $30 membership fee [Santo, 2005]. It is indeed a sorry state of affair because false advertising does more than just rob people of their money; it also gives unfair advantage over competitors and simply betrays the trust of millions of people

Ethical Problems One of the
Words: 391 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Education - Computers Paper #: 69871983

It would be helpful if my supervisors and the owner could see that Microsoft and other big corporations are not necessarily overcharging for their products, by taking into account all the work that goes into software or music production. They might be able to read about the production process to see how many stages a product goes through before reaching market. At the same time it would also be helpful if