Legal Issues In Family Law Essay

PAGES
6
WORDS
2033
Cite

Orthodox Jewish family consists of the mother, father, and four daughters whose home was raided by law enforcement officers on suspicion that the family was engaged in child pornography. Following the raid, naked pictures of young girls was found on one of the cell phones of the parents. Pursuant to a search warrant, the officers recovered computers, cameras, and cell phones and later called a case into ACS child protective services. The ACS caseworker obtained several photographs of the children while naked including one in which a 5-year-old girl sleeping in her bed with her underwear removed and legs spread apart. While the mother admitted to the ACS caseworker that she took that photograph, the case was referred to Kings County Family Court for legal direction and intervention. Family Law Legal Issues in the Case

As evident in the case, this is an example of a situation involving family law because of the legal issues that can be identified. An effective resolution of the issues in this case and development of a suitable intervention and/or treatment plan requires identifying legal issues in the case in relation to family law. The family law issues relating to this case emerge from a legal dilemma on whether the mother's actions were appropriate or crossed the boundaries of nudity and engaging children in sexually inappropriate behaviors. The family law issue that can be spotted in this case is child pornography since the actions of the mother are tantamount to engaging in pornography. According to HG Experts (n.d.), child pornography is any depiction of a child involved in sexually explicit conduct through visual representations like pictures, films and videos. In this case, the sexually explicit content not only implies actual sexual intercourse or acts but also entails lewd displays of the public area or genitals of a child/minor. In this case, the mother was involved in lewd exhibition of the 5-year-old genitals though she stated that the reason for taking the picture was to share it with her husband and sister. Despite her intentions, the lewd exhibition of her 5-year-old daughter's genitals is tantamount to engaging in child pornography based on existing laws.

Proposed Treatment Plan

Given that their actions constitute engagement in child pornography; these parents need to engage in a suitable treatment plan that will help them avoid these behaviors and any subsequent legal issues. As an ACS caseworker at Children's Village, I will develop a treatment plan for parents to comply with because their visual depictions of naked children for whatever reasons constitute involvement in child pornography and therefore violate family law. The goal of this treatment plan is to enable these parents avoid the risk of child sexual abuse and violation of family law. Additionally, this treatment plan will help in protecting the children from danger of abuse or neglect by their parents and other adults regardless of whether the actions undertaken by their parents are intentional or unintentional.

The first service of this treatment plan is educating...

...

During this process, these parents will not only be educated on family law issues but also enlightened on what are permissible child-rearing practices based on the laws and unlawful practices (Bloomberg & Bell, 2003). Once they are educated on the relevant legal provisions and laws relating to child sexual abuse and protection, the parents will be required to undertake counseling sessions. The counseling sessions will primarily focus on changing the behaviors of parents towards suitable child-rearing practices. The education and counseling are crucial in this treatment plan since they will help ensure that these parents are aware of laws relating to child rearing and work towards changing their behaviors to stop enhancing the risk of their daughters to sexual abuse and exploitation.
Case Study on Physical Abuse

As a guidance and counselor at P.S. 123, I have noticed that three children from a West African family that immigrated to the United States are fond of missing a substantial amount of school. One of the children recently came to school with a linear mark on her arm that appeared raised and black-blue, which raised concerns regarding their home life. It has been noted that the father is suspected of hitting kids as a form of corporal punishment. While the mother knows this, she is afraid of reporting the issue because she needs the husband's help in the home. Consequently, the issue has been referred to the New York County Family Court for legal intervention, which will entail identifying legal issues in the case and developing a suitable treatment or intervention plan.

Family Law Legal Issues in the Case

Corporal punishment of a child is legal in New York though relevant children services agencies can get involved in issues of legal child discipline. Despite being legal, the severity of the corporal punishment raises several concerns on whether it's abusive and violates family law. While parents in New York have the legal right to discipline their children through corporal punishment, New York FCT Law 1012 states that such discipline can be considered illegal if it impairs the physical, mental, and emotional state of the child (Gilmer, 2014). Additionally, corporal punishment of a child can be considered illegal if it endangers the wellbeing of the child by inflicting harm in an unreasonable manner. Based on this legal provision, the family law legal issue that can be spotted from this issue is child physical abuse, which is prohibited by federal, state and local family law (Schechter, 2013). In this case, the father is seemingly using excessive corporal punishment that physically harms the children and even affects their school attendance and endangers their physical, mental, and emotional wellbeing.

Proposed Treatment/Intervention Plan

Since the father's actions are tantamount to child physical abuse because of excessive corporal punishment when disciplining the children, a suitable intervention or…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Bloomberg, M.R. & Bell, W.C. (2003, July). Parents' Guide to New York State Child Abuse and Neglect Laws. Retrieved from New York State Government website: https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/acs/pdf/stateguide_english.pdf

Gilmer, G.M. (2014, February 18). Corporal Punishment in New York City: Discipline vs. Abuse. Retrieved December 20, 2016, from http://gilmerlegal.com/lawyer/2014/02/18/ACS-Cases/Corporal-Punishment-in-New-York-City-Discipline-vs.-Abuse_bl11810.htm

HG Experts. (n.d.). Child Pornography Law. Retrieved December 20, 2016, from https://www.hg.org/child-pornography.html

Schechter, S.P. (2013). New York family law (3rd ed.). Clifton Park, NY: Delmar, Cengage Learning.


Cite this Document:

"Legal Issues In Family Law" (2016, December 20) Retrieved April 18, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-issues-in-family-law-2163500

"Legal Issues In Family Law" 20 December 2016. Web.18 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-issues-in-family-law-2163500>

"Legal Issues In Family Law", 20 December 2016, Accessed.18 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-issues-in-family-law-2163500

Related Documents
Family Law
PAGES 6 WORDS 1845

Family Law and Gay and Lesbian Marriage What makes a marriage, in the eyes of society and the eyes of the law? As this paper is being written, President George W. Bush has called for a constitutional amendment upholding the idea that marriage is an institutional bond that can exist only between a man and a woman. Somewhat belying his claim that this idea is purely legal in its nature, however,

Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Act U v U [2002] HCA Over the years, the moral fibre of the society has continued to crumble. One of the most affected social units in the society is the family. Spouses exchange vows only to go back on their promise that 'till death do us part.' Children are often at the receiving end of such scenarios since family disintegration often has a negative impact

The second case involves a third grader who was seriously injured (became quadriplegic) when he ran into the street after school and was hit by a car. His family argued that they had not been made aware of early release, and sued Pleasantville Public Schools (Jerkins v. Anderson a-49-06) for negligently "failing to carry out its duty to provide reasonable supervision," the NSBA explains. The upshot of the 2007 case

Case # 2 -- Sperm Donation Bans The State Y law is likely to be adjudicated unconstitutional because it infringes on fundamental rights without sufficient justification to satisfy the appropriate level of judicial scrutiny (Friedman, 2005). It can be argued that the statute infringes on and burdens a fundamental right (i.e. The right to start a family); therefore, the statute would have to satisfy the highest level of strict scrutiny to

LEGAL ISSUE, STRUCTURE, and ANALYSIS A. LEGAL ISSUES-LIMITED PARTNERSHIP. According to Black's Law Dictionary (1991), a limited partnership is a "type of partnership of one or more general partners who manage business and who are personally liable for partnership debts, and one or more limited partners, who contribute capital and share in profits but who take no part in running business and incur no liability with respect to partnership obligations beyond contribution"

Human smuggling is a huge problem with an obvious domestic impact; the size of illegal immigrant population in the United States demonstrates how pervasive the problem is. However, it is not the size of the problem that is the most alarming; in an age of global terrorism, human smuggling provides a method for terrorists to enter a country undetected. The fact that so many non-terrorists use the same means