The American Criminal Justice System: Reform and Racial Profiling
This essay examines the American criminal justice system from its colonial-era origins to its present form, tracing how law enforcement, courts, and prisons have evolved over time. It defines the system's three core components and analyzes persistent problems, including racial profiling, disproportionate incarceration of Black and Latino Americans, the stop-and-frisk program, and the three-strikes sentencing law. The essay also investigates the rise of private prisons and how profit motives may drive harsher sentencing and prison overcrowding. It concludes by arguing that meaningful reform requires ending racial profiling, eliminating punitive excess, and prioritizing rehabilitation over incarceration.
- Introduction: Historical overview and thesis on criminal justice reform
- Defining the Criminal Justice System: Three-part structure of U.S. criminal justice and prison origins
- Racial Profiling in American Law Enforcement: Disproportionate policing of Black and Latino Americans
- Current Trends in the American Criminal Justice System: Death penalty retention, harsh sentencing, and overcrowding
- Fairness or Profit? The Rise of Private Prisons: How privatization drives incarceration rates and overcrowding
- Conclusion: Call for rehabilitative reform and end to racial profiling
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses direct quotations from credible sources to support each major claim, grounding abstract arguments in concrete evidence from researchers and journalists.
- Moves logically from definition to historical context to contemporary criticism, building a coherent argument across clearly demarcated sections.
- Grounds systemic critique in individual human stories, such as the account of Rufus and Devin Scales, making structural problems tangible to the reader.
- Connects discrete issues — racial profiling, private prisons, overcrowding, and recidivism — into a unified analysis of systemic dysfunction.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper effectively uses the technique of causal chaining: it traces how one systemic feature (privatization of prisons) creates incentives that travel upstream through politicians, judges, and police officers, producing measurable outcomes like higher arrest rates, longer sentences, and overcrowding. This kind of multi-stage causal reasoning is typical of strong undergraduate policy analysis.
Structure breakdown
The essay follows a classical five-part structure: an introduction establishing historical scope, a definitions section providing conceptual grounding, two analytical body sections (racial profiling and current trends), a critical policy section on prison privatization, and a conclusion advocating specific reforms. Each section builds directly on the last, keeping the argument cumulative rather than episodic.
Introduction
The criminal justice system in the United States has existed since the colonial era. Although the colonial era brought a European form of justice, the United States would later create its own criminal justice system that includes a prison and court system. None of what the criminal justice system is today was conceived or implemented at one time. Rather, it exists as a collection of progressive developments that culminated in what American law enforcement is today. Although America has improved its law enforcement methods, there are problems that have led to a desire for reform.
The American criminal justice system has roots going as far back as the 18th century. What began as a rebellion against England became a fight for independence and a chance at true freedom; this freedom brought with it a responsibility to serve and protect.
This essay will show how the American criminal justice system has changed from its beginnings in the colonial era to its current manifestation. It will offer a brief analysis of the various components of the system — from the courts to the prisons and police officers — and examine how these components may have contributed to the racial profiling and profiteering witnessed in today's criminal justice system.
Defining the Criminal Justice System
The criminal justice system can be defined as follows: "The criminal justice system consists of three main parts: (1) law enforcement (police, sheriffs, marshals); (2) adjudication (courts, which include judges, prosecutors, and defense lawyers); and (3) corrections (prison officials, probation officers, and parole officers)" (US Legal, 2017).
Aside from these three main components, criminal justice agencies exist to help the public and criminal offenders through rehabilitation and additional services. These agencies were not part of the American criminal justice system during the country's earlier phase, when there were no prisons or formal police forces. The system was originally modeled on law enforcement practices in England and France.
The current form of the criminal justice system in the United States involves a police force, a court and prison system, and rehabilitation measures. "Normally, the first contact an offender has with the criminal justice system is through police, who investigate suspected wrongdoing and make an arrest. Next is the court, where disputes are settled and justice is administered" (US Legal, 2017). The prison system is where the most significant changes occurred. Although it was not widely adopted until the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the American prison system was the first to offer courts the option of imprisoning criminals at both the state and federal level. Federal prisons provided the option of incarcerating criminals who committed crimes against the federal government or crimes affecting the country as a whole. The main problem, however, lies in the state and local prisons, where overpopulation and overcrowding remain persistent concerns.
Two competing prison models emerged in the early 19th century. "Most states followed a New York prison model called the Auburn plan. It was named after the Auburn Prison, opened in 1821 as a maximum-security facility. Inmates were locked in separate cells at night but worked in groups during the day" (Bettman/Corbis, 2017). Americans were among the first to implement a true prison system, and the system has continued to change every couple of decades. These changes came as a result of internal government shifts — such as those brought on by the Civil Rights Movement — as well as privatization efforts. The prison system became the primary means of rehabilitating criminals in the United States, while the court system and police officers aimed to curb criminal activity through arrest and incarceration.
This trajectory has led to voices of dissent over American law enforcement. One prominent criticism is the disproportionate incarceration of Black Americans compared to white Americans — a hot-button topic that has fueled calls for criminal justice reform. Along with racial profiling, harsher sentences have created ongoing difficulties for Black Americans in obtaining employment and avoiding subsequent arrests.
Works Cited
Bettman/Corbis. (2017). The Early Years of American Law — Colonial Freedom, Britain's Push for Greater Control, A New Start, A New Criminal Court System. JRank Articles. Retrieved from http://law.jrank.org/pages/11900/Early-Years-American-Law.html
Currie, E. (2013). Crime and punishment in America. Macmillan.
Finley, L. L. (2016). Crime and punishment in America: An encyclopedia of trends and controversies in the justice system. ABC-CLIO.
LaFraniere, S., & Lehren, A. W. (2015, October 24). The disproportionate risks of driving while Black. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/25/us/racial-disparity-traffic-stops-driving-black.html
Natarajan, R. (2014, December 14). Racial profiling has destroyed public trust in police. Cops are exploiting our weak laws against it. The Washington Post. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2014/12/15/racial-profiling-has-destroyed-public-trust-in-police-cops-are-exploiting-our-weak-laws-against-it/
US Legal. (2017). Criminal justice system law and legal definition. USLegal, Inc. Retrieved from https://definitions.uslegal.com/c/criminal-justice-system/
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.