¶ … Forensic Sciences in the USA and the United Kingdom
Over the last two decades, the forensic science has assisted in producing valuable evidence that has contributed to a successful conviction and prosecution of criminals and exoneration of innocent citizens. Typically, an advanced in forensic science and DNA technology have been a great assistance for law enforcement agency for an identification and prosecution of criminals. In the United States and the UK, many cases that have been formally unsolved have now been solved based on the great assistance of the forensic science investigators. (National Research Council, 2009). Forensics or forensic science is a field of investigation drawing different scientific disciplines in law, criminal and civil services. This practice requires an application of scientific knowledge, quantitative, qualitative and empirical skills to collect and analyze data that will assist in presenting evidence in a tribunal or court of law. However, the method the evidence is collected and analyzed requires using an advanced in technology and scientific knowledge to test and testifying the results. (Mallett, & Evison, 2013). While the United Kingdom and the United States use the same technology and scientific evidence to carry out the forensic investigation, nevertheless, there are still some differences between the UK and the United States forensic science.
The objective of this study is to carry out a comparison of forensic sciences in the USA and the United Kingdom
Comparison of Forensic sciences in the USA and the United Kingdom
The application of the forensic science in the United States consists of a diverse network of local, state, federal law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, private forensic laboratories, law enforcement identification units and crime laboratories, quality system providers and defense attorneys. While the application of the forensic science is more decentralized in the United States, however, the UK forensic DNA systems is more centralized. Goulka, et al. (2010) argue that the UK criminal justice has capitalized on the DNA forensic evidence than the U.S. forensic criminal systems. It is claimed that the UK forensic DNA analysis is less expensive and deliver results quickly than the U.S. DNA systems. Thus, the United States DNA forensic analysis is more relatively more expensive, rigid, and plagued with the bureaucratic system. However, the UK forensic DNA system is more cost-effective and assists in solving a large number of serious
(2010) compares forensic systems of the United States and the UK by stating that the UK has a single DNA database managed by the UK Home office, which is a semi-independent arm of government. On the other hand, the U.S. government authorizes the DNA database systems from the DNA Identification Act, which established the CODIS (Combined DNA Index System), and managed by the FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigation). A major difference between the UK and USA forensic science is that privatize and private forensic labs deliver forensic services to police forces in the UK to solve the case problems. Typically, the NFFA (National Forensic Framework Agreement) plays a major role in the forensic services, and assists in providing services to police forces in England. Key private organizations that deliver forensic services in the UK include LGC Forensics, Forensic Science Service, Key Forensic Services, and Orchid Cellmark. Smaller private forensic labs also assist in delivering the forensic services to police forces in the UK.
Contrarily, the private forensic labs play limited roles in the United States because the public labs predominantly deliver forensic services. However, a number forensic firms are allowed to handle the specialized DNA analyses, exigent requests, and excess demand. Moreover, private forensic laboratories are also allowed to conduct the DNA typing for sample categories, which are uploaded and managed by CODIS since the CODIS remains an exclusive purview of the FBI and public-sector laboratories.
Another difference between the UK and USA forensic service is the area of funding. In the UK, the central government is responsible for the funding of forensic science expansion, However, police forces pay for the forensic services from their budgets. On the other hand, the federal government is responsible for the funding of the forensic services in the United States. For example, the federal government provides the grants annually to more than 200 public laboratories and outsourcing works to other private or public labs across the country. Butler, (2015) argue that the U.S. NIJ (National Institute of Justice) is responsible for the funding of the forensic services. For example, the NIJ has awarded research grants totaled $125 million for the advanced of the forensic science annually. Between 2009 and 2014, the NIJ had issued 23 funding solicitations resulted in funding 269 research projects. By April 2015, the NIJ has produced 255 publications and 77 final technical reports. With reference to the forensic research, the NIJ has approved $48 million for over 100 projects for topics that include human DNA quantitation, alternative genetic markers, non-human DNA, mitochondrial DNA, mitochondrial DNA and sperm separation and detection. While the funding for the advancement of forensic science…
Therefore, the ability to determine facts in a case from very small particles of matter has proven to be of invaluable assistance in criminal investigation and procedure; for example, forensic analysis has been used successfully in many paternity cases. 3. Myths and realities There many misconceptions surrounding forensic science and especially CSI or Crime Scene Investigation. This is mainly due to the way that CSI has been portrayed in film and
Forensic Science Since its introduction in the 8th century by Chinese authorities who used fingerprints to identify the authenticity of clay sculptures and documents (Forensic science history, 2016), modern forensic science has experienced a number of trends that have fundamentally changed the manner in which practitioners use technology to investigate crime scenes to provide courts of competent jurisdiction with the information they need to formulate decisions concerning guilt and innocence.
Essay Topic Examples 1. The Evolution and Impact of DNA Analysis in Forensic Science This essay will explore the revolutionary introduction of DNA analysis in forensic investigations. It will trace the origins of DNA fingerprinting, delve into the technical advancements that have made DNA evidence a linchpin in legal outcomes, and discuss the societal and ethical implications of such powerful technology. This topic will also highlight the role of DNA analysis in
Response to Reketer Barber The popularity of shows like CSI has led to widespread misperceptions about the quality and nature of forensic science. As you point out, the CSI effect could lead to wrongful acquittals, but it is equally possible that jurors might wrongfully convict based on perceptions of the strength of forensic evidence admitted into the trial. As Gaensslen & Larsen (2019) “jurors bring expectations to the jury room that
Forensic Science and Police Work Forensic science has been playing a very crucial role in crime-solving activities of the investigative agencies for last many years. Its popularity has grown tremendously even though it cannot be trusted to formally indict someone. This is because while forensic evidence is considered important, there are certain specific problems attached with it, which can significantly limit the credibility of the results obtained from forensic examination. Forensic evidence
Picture a place where criminals could roam freely, detectives, and police officers went about gathering evidence the same way that they do now, except the one main difference is that they do not use science. Without the use of scientific analysis, you would not have a lot of useful evidence that you could use to convict someone of a crime. Criminals could get away with everything from common theft to
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now