Public Health Ethics Case Study

PAGES
3
WORDS
1092
Cite

¶ … Mary have the right to reveal this information to others? Please justify your answer based on what you know about public health and ethics. Health information management ethics do not allow Mary to reveal the information. Medical records are used to aid decision making in clinical health circles. They are used for a range of other processes including service coordination, efficacy of health care, evaluation, legal security, research, accreditation supplications, policy making, regulation, education and a range of others. It is important to maintain the confidentiality of the information shared by patients with health officers; trust is to be maintained with the patients (Harman, Flite, & Bond, 2012). If such practice is not observed, patients will be wary of sharing information. Consequently, the quality of health care would be compromised (Bord, Burke, & Dudzinski, 2013). Privacy has a range of other benefits apart from the direct health service provision advantages. There is societal value derived from maintaining confidentiality too. It is easier to conduct research when confidentiality is upheld. People's dignity is also a consideration (Nass, Levit, & Gostin, 2009).

Sharing medical health information of patients is permitted only under authorised permission. Health care providers have an obligation to maintain confidentiality of the patient's health information from unauthorised access. Such information can only be shared among members of the healthcare team for finding the best approaches to handle the patient's situation and for future planning, among other purposes (Bord, Burke, & Dudzinski, 2013). Further, there is a requirement in medical practice that patient information can only be shared after the patient...

...

However, physicians can still access such information for purposes of intervention in treatment, or even for administrative reasons. The patient also has a right to access information about their health status. They can also change such information as they deem appropriate in consonance with factual data (Harman, Flite, & Bond, 2012).
In the situation regarding Mary's friend Patricia and her fiance Ron, would Mary be more justified in revealing patient information than in the situation regarding the next-door neighbor? Why or why not? What if Patricia was her sister?

Revelation of health information belonging to Ron can be justified because such request came from a person close to both Patricia and Ron. Mary's mother is the one that requested for Ruth's information. Sheer curiosity by the public is not a justifiable ground for revealing patient health information. Trust between a patient and a healthcare providers is a critical factor. This practice is maintained with the goal of enhancing patient welfare. Moreover, maintaining public confidence has a wider benefit in the general public. It is an important ingredient in the maintenance of public health. In modern medicine, though, there is no absoluteness guaranteed in such confidentiality. Such idealism may, sometimes have to be broken. The General Medical Council's professional code of conduct spells such exceptions (Blightman, Griffiths, & Danbury, 2014)

• Consensual disclosures

• Legally mandated disclosures

• Disclosure due to public interest (Blightman, Griffiths, & Danbury, 2014)

Public interest disclosures

The…

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

Blightman, K., Griffiths, S., & Danbury, C. (2014). Patient confidentiality: when can a breach be justified? Oxford Journals.

Bord, J. D., Burke, W., & Dudzinski, D. (2013). Confidentiality. Ethics in Medicine.

Harman, L., Flite, C., & Bond, K. (2012). Electronic Health Records: Privacy, Confidentiality, and Security. AMA Journal of Ethics, 712-719.

Nass, S., Levit, L., & Gostin, L. (2009). Beyond the HIPAA Privacy Rule: Enhancing Privacy, Improving Health Through Research. Washington: National Academies Press.


Cite this Document:

"Public Health Ethics" (2017, January 19) Retrieved April 24, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/public-health-ethics-2164018

"Public Health Ethics" 19 January 2017. Web.24 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/public-health-ethics-2164018>

"Public Health Ethics", 19 January 2017, Accessed.24 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/public-health-ethics-2164018

Related Documents

Some of the tools and knowledge that ethical training can provide managers include the five main sources of ethical standards for their profession: (a) the utilitarian approach, (b) the rights approach, (c) the fairness or justice approach, (d) the common good approach, and (e) the virtue approach; when managers are confronted with ethical dilemmas, the integration of these analytical frameworks can facilitate ethical-decision making (Kanekar & Bitto, 2012). Likewise,

Public Health Ethics
PAGES 9 WORDS 2510

Public Health The rate of Caesarian sections has skyrocketed in recent decades in the United States, placing it far ahead of other industrialized nations. Historical overview of C-section rates in the U.S. Breakdown of C-section rates by race and access to insurance Why is this a public health issue? Higher morbidity and mortality rate for C-sections. Poor and minority women (and their families) affected at greater rates. One of the costs driving up healthcare in the United

" The far-reaching results of Koch's methods then could be applied to many fields of medical research rather than just to the diseases he investigated. This broad application and research then is what makes Koch's findings so significant. Two specific principles from the code of public health ethics can be seen as embodied in Koch's work: The first is that the fundamental causes of disease are addressed and researched, rather then

Public Health Practice
PAGES 6 WORDS 1932

Health Care There are many things that have led to the renaissance of public health in the past 20 years. However, the most important ones include eradication of infectious diseases through vaccination, increased awareness, better hygiene control, better primary care facilities and more stress on epidemiology. It has been stated that humans have a right to public health (Principles of the Ethical Practice of Public Health, 2002) Keeping this in mind, public

"Potential barriers to resource sharing include institutional separation, ignorance of each field's history and unique challenges, constrained resources and different timelines" (Mamotte et al. 2009). Ultimately, I do not believe it matters if the research studies are exactly 'like Tuskegee.' A fundamental difference between the two is that the African population might not be treated with the full resources of Western medicine had they not participated in the trials, while

This is a contractual obligation, as money has been received for a certain service. This is closely related to the third obligation in the model, which is "duty to the organization." The press has an obligation to provide the public with a wide variety of viewpoints in order to ensure public debate and accurate information. If a certain piece of information is withheld from the public as a result of