Verified Document

America's Road To Becoming A Term Paper

Ironically, while expansionism was based on ideas of racial superiority, so did the counter-arguments. For example, labor leader Samuel Gompers argued against the acquisition of colonies, for fear of being swarmed by "the Negritos, the Chinese, the Malays" and the other "semi-savage races" from coming to the United States? Similar racist arguments were put forth by William Graham Sumner, a prominent Social Darwinist. While Sumber agrees with the argument that Anglo Saxons are a superior race, he also believed that colonization would interfere with the progress of the lesser race and may even disrupt the development of the Anglo Saxon civilization. However, many prominent Americans also opposed American expansionism based on more lawful and humanitarian reasons. Republican Senator George F. Hoar, for example, argued that the acquisition of the Philippines based on Constitutional grounds. Hoar begins his argument by declaring that the Monroe Doctrine is no longer relevant, given the waning superiority of Europe. The senator stated that governing a people against their will was "expressly forbidden by the Constitution." Furthermore, he was critical of the warmongers in Congress, who proposed turning guns and cannons on another country, simply because "we think that our notion of government is better than the notion you have got yourselves."

The argument acquires more resonance upon...

Army Sergeant Leroy E. Hallock, a soldier stationed in the Philippines during the war, testified in Congress regarding the torture that soldiers were instructed to commit. According to the report of the proceedings, "if the soldiers wanted to get any information out of the natives, they gave them the water cure." Any town that was suspected of harboring militia or insurgents was burned.
Conclusion

In summary, American colonization of the Philippines was built on ideas of Anglo-Saxon superiority and the strengthening of the American market. However, as Hoar pointed out, these reasons for expansion violated those specified in the United States Constitution. Furthermore, the expansionism was carried out with vicious violations of human rights, resulting in great casualties among the Filipino people.

Perhaps the most eloquent argument against expansionism can be summed up in the words of Mark Twain, who noted the irony in the way Americans savaged the rights of the people they were supposed to "lift up" to civilization. Thus, the United States sent an army "ostensibly to help the native patriots put the finishing tough on their long and plucky struggle for independence, but really to take their land away from them and keep it."

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

America and the Ottoman Empire
Words: 5100 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

The Crusades The Crusades would shape Islamic attitudes toward the West for centuries, so much so that it was noted that George Bush should never have used the term with reference to the War on Terror because of the bad feelings involved. In the eleventh century, much of the Moslem world was under siege from the Seljuk Turks. The Moslems were in control of the Holy Lands, the seat of Christianity,

America Faced Several Difficult Challenges in Its
Words: 603 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

America faced several difficult challenges in its quest to improve its infrastructure during the years leading up to 1860. First of all America was a very young country which consisted of 16 states with sparse populations spread out over large areas of land. The landscape in America during this time period made travel difficult and very expensive, the roads consisted mainly of post roads, which were little more that

How the Railroad Industrialized America a Track That Unified a Nation...
Words: 2968 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

railroad industrialized America, a Track That Unified a Nation How the railroad industrialized America In the nineteenth century, the railroad system of the United States of America came to life. The systems' sole purpose was to transport people and goods across the country. Railroad system in the country began on the East and moved westwards. The move to the west resulted in development of towns, which further made the system branch

Travelling America: The Diaries of John Steinbeck
Words: 1935 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Travelling America: The Diaries of John Steinbeck and Jean Baudrillard America has long been considered the "land of opportunity," which makes it in turn, an opportune place to travel and explore. Though vast in geography and rich in culture, America has often offered its travelers a similar experience, as these travelers so often find themselves visiting similar places and hearing similar tales of the past and the present. Additionally, travelling

Collapse of the Big Three America Was
Words: 3475 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Paper

Collapse of the Big Three America was once the leader and pioneer in the auto industry, a title that the country had for decades and a title that was so dear to America's heart that it was unfathomable to think that title might ever be lost. It's commonly misconstrued that America invented the automobile, when in reality that honor goes to German Karl Benz in 1885 (Rozema, 2010). "Americans did, however,

Glory Road Movie the Story
Words: 3828 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Even though Glory Road took place in the American South, its themes are prevalent throughout sports and through many different time periods. Current literature touches on many of the themes of the movie. A recent study of college students by Harrison and Lawrence looks at the perception regarding what seems to be the now dominating role of blacks in American sports today (Harrison & Lawrence, 2004). While this seems to contradict the theme of Glory Road,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now