To the Editor:
Recently, there has been a crisis of confidence in the ability of the criminal justice system and the police system to act fairly toward persona of all races, religions, and ethnicities. This is also true of persons with disabilities. Particularly of suspects of persons with mental illnesses, including schizophrenia, autism, and developmental disabilities, it can be very difficult for untrained officers to distinguish between criminality and mental illness.
Ethical criminal justice leaders must be aware of the need not simply to be tough on crime but also to act with compassion, fairness, and justice to all persons, including suspects. According to the Treatment Advocacy Center (2018), suspects...
It is critical that criminal justice leaders are given the tools to identify the signs of non-threatening mental illness so officers do not confuse them with aggression, and so they have the ability to deescalate potentially dangerous situations.Admitting there is a problem is the first step. In fact, law enforcement officers may not always be the most appropriate personnel to deal with dangerous situations such as suicides or with persons acting in strange but non-aggressive ways. Learning from instructive examples in law enforcement across the nation may be useful. New York...
…individuals who are suffering from mental illness, and protecting those individuals just as they protect other members of the community. Unfortunately, because of the difficulties officers grapple with every day, they may be inclined to suspect the worst whenever they spot someone who may be talking or acting strangely. But this is not always helpful when treating the mentally ill.Finally, officers should be able to spot mental illnesses in themselves and other officers, when they are suffering from burnout or anger issues due to the pressures of the job. A final aspect of ethical leadership is ensuring there is appropriate counseling and treatment for police officers themselves who…
References
People with untreated mental illness16 times more likely to be killed by law enforcement.
(2018). Treatment Advocacy Center. https://www.treatmentadvocacycenter.org/key-issues/criminalization-of-mental-illness/2976-people-with-untreated-mental-illness-16-times-more-likely-to-be-killed-by-law-enforcement-
Shivram, D. (2021). Mental health response teams yield better outcomes than police in NYC,data shows NPR. https://www.npr.org/2021/07/23/1019704823/police-mental-health-crisis-calls-new-york-city
Mental Illness and Child Abuse The physical abuse of children was 'rediscovered' by physicians over fifty years ago. Since then, some observers have expressed concern at the continuing 'medicalisation' of what they consider to be essentially a social problem (Parton, 1985). A widely-held view emerged from the ensuing debate that child physical abuse and neglect occurred through an interaction between parents, children and their social environment. The model described parents with
When one throws the element of ethnicity into the mix, the process of diagnosis becomes even more difficult. Let us take, for instance the effect of religion on the diagnosis of a mental illness. In some religions it is considered to be "normal" to experience visions, see ghosts, and talk to the dead. However, from a strict clinical standpoint, these things do not exist and therefore indicate a break from
Edwards challenges the extreme on the other end as well, i.e. that total wellness sis the only possible state of being labeled healthy. The scholar sites the World Health Organization's definition of wellness as complete mental and physical wellness as far too broad and encompassing and illegitimates the reality of human existence. (16. Edwards, CC2010, pp. 0090) Edwards ultimately argues that the challenges faced by both those who believe
Mental Illness The foremost question relating to mental illness concerns about its very existence - whether mental illness actually exists or not? According to Thomas Szasz, mental illness is a mere myth (Szasz, 1960) and does not exist, as illness can be defined only in terms of physical pathology and most mental disorders have no such demonstrable pathology. In a similar viewpoint, it was argued that biology was not relevant to
Null Hypothesis 2: The mentally ill are not particularly at risk of substance abuse or criminal activity. 4) Independent and Dependent Variables Independent variables that might influence the study focused on the mentally ill include other influencing factors such as support from family, friends, age, and the use of psychotropic drugs. Independent variables that can influence the study includes attitudes and stigmatization by professionals at institutions that house mentally ill inmates. This can
However many people displaying psychiatric symptoms were over represented in jail and there is no tangible evidence to prove that it is their mental illness that got them to jail. Indeed unless it can be shown that factors unique to serious mental illness are specifically associated with behavior leading to arrest and incarceration, the criminalization hypothesis ought to be reconsidered. It should put into consideration more powerful risk factors for
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now