Legal Brief The Author Preparing This Brief Essay

Length: 4 pages Subject: Film Type: Essay Paper: #41718847 Related Topics: Legal Briefs, A Clockwork Orange, Preparing, Stark Law
Excerpt from Essay :

Legal Brief

The author preparing this brief is asked to defend against the banning of a book on the grounds that it is obscene and thus it should be barred from sale and distribution in the public sphere. The laws and standards surrounding obscenity are vague, subjective and impossible to reliably and consistently enforce in a manner that is even-handed and objective. As such, the banning of a book, movie or other piece of art or literature should not happen unless the case is clear-cut and without question. While obscenity laws are well-intentioned, at least most of the time, they don't pass muster unless wielded for very narrow and well-established reasons.

Per Miller v. California, there are three standards of obscenity that must be surpassed for a work to be banned with good conscience and all three of them can be quickly dismissed and in short order over the course of this case. First, it has to be true that the "average person" would find the work, when viewed and summarized as a whole, is obscene and is rife with a "prurient interest." In other words, something full of sex and gratuitousness would generally tend to be obscene in many cases. While cases could (and some say "should") be made for things like child pornography (or virtual depictions of the same) and/or rape in general, even those two are not clearly cut. If it were, shows like Law and Order: SVU and many movies that have depictions of rape and/or sexual assault would not be aired on national television at all, let alone network television or even regular cable.

However, while the examples above give good context, another example (although not sexual) really drives home what it means to truly define with certitude what an "average" person might think. That example is the "Passion of the Christ" movie made by Mel Gibson, and there are a number of angles that one can take here. Many demonize the movie and its depictions because of the prior anti-Semitic rhetoric...

...

Others say that the Jews in the movie are depicted in a very poor fashion. Others still are very passionate about the movie and how it represents the death of Jesus Christ and they are vocal proponents of the movie. In short, there is not a clear-cut "average" response to the movie because there are several fairly common responses and reactions and none of them usurps the other entirely. The same can be applied to art and film that is sexual in nature. Some feel that the statue "David" is a work of art and a tribute to the human form while others may feel that his body should be covered. Regardless, even if an "average" response is ascertainable, foisting and forcing that on other people based on moral, religious or legal grounds is a very slippery slope. There is legal precedent to back this up. Namely, Jacobellius v. Ohio established that there is no legal definition of "pornography" and thus enforcing obscenity statutes cannot be enforced.

As for the second item that qualifies an item as obscene, that would be that there is a depiction of sexual conduct in an offensive way. This ties in and dovetails with the prior point and that is a definition of what "offensive" is. Some people feel use and talk about contraception is offensive on religious or moral grounds while others see it as a way to prevent unwanted pregnancies and/or spread of sexual transmitted diseases. Indeed, that is a basic example and there are other actions and behaviors that are described and depicted in books and movies that are a little more opaque. For example, the actress Helena Bonham-Carter had a line in the movie "Fight Club" in which she said "I haven't been (expletive) like that since preschool." While that line would surely offend a lot of people, the movie itself was quite popular and is rather highly rated in many circles as one of David Fincher's best works. One could point to Quentin Tarantino in any number of ways or the infamous scenes in Kubrick's "A Clockwork Orange" as other examples of this in action. Even if the presentation is tawdry and profane, a point is being…

Cite this Document:

"Legal Brief The Author Preparing This Brief" (2014, February 24) Retrieved June 17, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-brief-the-author-preparing-this-brief-183653

"Legal Brief The Author Preparing This Brief" 24 February 2014. Web.17 June. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-brief-the-author-preparing-this-brief-183653>

"Legal Brief The Author Preparing This Brief", 24 February 2014, Accessed.17 June. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/legal-brief-the-author-preparing-this-brief-183653

Related Documents
Legal Implications Expansion into Mexico
Words: 2514 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 58293532

Memorandum In Brief It is important to note, from the onset, that there are many commercial benefits that our company could reap by expanding internationally. Thus, the expansion into Mexico is not only timely, but also well considered. However, in engaging in the said expansion, the company ought to be aware of the pertinent aspects of both the U.S. and Mexican law. It is with this in mind that this memo highlights

Legal Issues in Hydraulic Fracturing
Words: 561 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 19783974

Pennsylvania Act 13? Compare it to Vermont's May 2012 legislation: http://www.leg.state.vt.us/docs/2012/Bills/Intro/H-464.pdf Compare these with the New York State decision on local control of fracking found in Doc Sharing at. The Pennsylvania Act 13 of 2012 provides tougher environmental standards, and authorizes local governments to assess an impact fee on fracking operations but is otherwise intended to facilitate the extraction of natural gas from unconventional sources. The Act's provisions include (a)

Gilbert Law's "Legal Writing, Research,
Words: 1593 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 21760968

After reading the Gilbert Law Summary on legal writing and research, a law student would be much better prepared to begin his or her educational career in research and analysis. As previously stated, the student should feel more adequate to tackle the research portion of any legal project, but the actual writing and analysis would need further development as only actual experience may provide. Honigsberg's introduction into the vast world

Ethical and Legal Issues Involved in E-Commerce
Words: 4942 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 40450759

Ethical and Legal Issues in Ecommerce A Concise Definition of ecommerce Motivation for E-Commerce Ethical and Legal Issues in E-Commerce Enforcement of Legal Directives and Contracts Collecting and Securing Consumer Information Lack of Uniform Laws Copyright and Patent Laws Violation Taxation Other Issues: In Brief Privacy and Security 'Extinction' of Some Small Businesses Electronic Deception Language Issues Declaration During the last one decade, the internet has experienced unprecedented growth. Thanks to this increase in online activity, consumers and businesses from all over the world are

Ethical and Legal Perspectives in
Words: 1275 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 34717617

A deposition is "conducted by parties to a legal action to obtain information that cannot as readily be learned through written records or general investigation. During a deposition, the lawyer for one side orally questions a witness on the opposing side. In addition to the defendants named in a lawsuit being deposed, others called to deposition can be fact witnesses" (Preparing for a deposition, 2011, World Law). Above all, preparation

Mris Legal and Scientific Review
Words: 5397 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 2692818

There are three types of stimuli used, which are: 1) Targets; 2) Irrelevant; and 3) Probes. These are used "in the form of words, pictures, or sounds..." which a computer presents for a second or even a partial second. Incoming stimulus, if it is worth noting, results in a P-300, which is an electrical brain response. The P-300 is part of a MERMER or a memory and encoding related multifaceted electroencephalographic response,