Stem Cells The Ethical Controversy Research Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Mythology - Religion Type: Research Paper Paper: #87608673 Related Topics: Cystic Fibrosis, In Vitro Fertilization, Invitro Fertilization, Stem Cell Research
Excerpt from Research Paper :

Analysis of the Issues: The ethical concern for the rights and welfare of viable infants is certainly a legitimate concern, but the central ethical analysis that pertains to stem cell research revolves around the issue of defining human life appropriately. Objective criteria like anatomical development, cognitive awareness, and above all, sentience of any degree and in any form are all legitimate bases for the definition of life and for identifying the period of gestation corresponding to the earliest conceivable safeguards necessary to prevent suffering.

On the other hand, purely subjective doctrinal claims without objective criteria of any kind are wholly inappropriate bases for defining scientific concepts like when life begins. The fact that human development varies among individuals and that it may be impossible to know exactly where sentience and other elements of "humanness" first begin in the fetus does not mean that it is impossible to identify periods of fetal development that undoubtedly precede any form of consciousness. Therefore, the protection of the fetus during the so-called "grey area" where it is impossible to rule out consciousness and sentience of any kind is justifiable under objective moral principles.

It is not justifiable to apply those same types of moral concerns to (literally) a few completely undifferentiated tissue cells in a Petri dish simply because they happen to be human tissue. This is even more obvious when one considers that similar logic would justify protecting semen and the initiation of rescue attempts for approximately 50% of all pregnancies that terminate in spontaneous abortion normally mistaken as heavy menstrual bleeding (Sagan 1997).

That is not to suggest that individuals may not accept religious definitions as the bases for their private choices and conduct. A belief that human life is particularly special because God created us in his image is a perfectly acceptable philosophical perspective with respect to one's own life; it is not an acceptable philosophical perspective with respect to imposing that religious belief on others who may not share those particular beliefs.

Forced obedience to specific religious dogma was one of the most oppressive aspects of medieval society and continued well into the beginning of the industrial age in Britain; in fact, it was one of the primary motivations for the colonial desire for independence in the New World. That concept is featured prominently in the arguments in the federalist papers memorializing the ratification process that culminated in the U.S. Constitution in 1789. The First Amendment specifically prohibits government from establishing a national religion and the Fourteenth Amendment ensures that the


Therapeutic applications of stem cell science will eliminate the need for organ recipient lists and save the lives of thousands of patients every year who die before receiving a donation, in addition to eliminating the need for anti-rejection drugs. Similarly, many deadly cancers that have defied most conventional efforts at effective treatment are likely treatable through stem cell-related medical applications. Stem cell science also holds the key to treating numerous congenital diseases that seriously undermine human health and happiness as well as realistic hope for victims of traumatic spinal injuries and other life- altering physical injuries. Present U.S. law restricting the use of stem cells for valuable medical research is, in principle, a violation of the concept of separation of church and state guaranteed by the First Amendment to the Constitution because it gives preferential treatment to the views of certain religions over others and contradicts the philosophical values of people with no specific religious orientation.

It violates the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment because it denies people who do not subscribe to Christian beliefs about the sanctity and nature of human life and about what human "life" is and is not. More importantly, it does so at the expense of the health and welfare of many millions.


Dershowitz, a.(2002) Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age.

Boston: Little Brown, 2002

Healy, B. On Health: The Other Stem Cells; U.S. News & World Report (Jun. 14/04), p. 77.

Hellemans, a., Bunch, B. (1998) the Timetables of Science. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Kinsley, M. Commentary: Why Science Can't Save the GOP; Time Magazine (Dec. 10/07), p. 36.

Krbling, M., Katz, R.L., Khanna, a. (2002) Hepatocytes and Epithelial

Cells of Donor Origin in Recipients of Peripheral-Blood Stem Cells.

New England Journal of Medicine 346, 10: 738-746. Pollack, a. After Stem-Cell Breakthrough the Real Work Begins. The New York Times, Nov. 27/07 (p. F1) Sagan, C. (1997) Billions and Billions: Thoughts on Life and Death at the Brink of the Millennium. New York: Random House

Sagan, C., Druyen, a. (1998) the Question of Abortion: A Search for Answers. Accessed July 23, 2008 at (

Saunders, J. Science & Technology: The First Clone. U.S. News & World Report; Dec. 3/01 (pp. 50-63).

Thomson, J. (1998) Embryonic Stem Cell Lines…

Sources Used in Documents:


Dershowitz, a.(2002) Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age.

Boston: Little Brown, 2002

Healy, B. On Health: The Other Stem Cells; U.S. News & World Report (Jun. 14/04), p. 77.

Hellemans, a., Bunch, B. (1998) the Timetables of Science. New York: Simon & Schuster.

Cite this Document:

"Stem Cells The Ethical Controversy" (2008, July 24) Retrieved September 21, 2021, from

"Stem Cells The Ethical Controversy" 24 July 2008. Web.21 September. 2021. <>

"Stem Cells The Ethical Controversy", 24 July 2008, Accessed.21 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
Stem Cell Research Controversy in
Words: 696 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 67947898

They also present several important ethical concerns that were never issues before the computer age, such as plagiarism and even communications intended to cheat during in-class exams (Li & Irby, 2008). Likewise, the use of computers for distance learning also raises issues of the relative quality of various academic programs since online programs are much less capable of being monitored and evaluated for quality and academic integrity than traditional

Stem Cell Research Controversy One
Words: 681 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 10706598

In the case of embryonic stem cell research, it would be the responsibility of legislators to identify the specific types of potential harms that would justify limitations on research or on research funding available through public funds. Given the uncontested fact that embryonic stem cell research applications have the potential to eliminate the need for organ transplantation, to regenerate limbs lost in traumatic amputations, to restore movement in cases of

Stem Cell Research Embryonic Stem
Words: 1159 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 98930137

" He argues that it is wrong to use these embryos even though they will just be discarded and wasted anyway. For this reason, people with grave diseases and disabilities argue that Bush needs to change his stance. CONCLUSION Stem cell research is incredibly important and should be fully examined so that we can do as much as possible to find cures and alleviate human suffering (Feinstein, 2004). It is important that

Stem Cell Transplants Treat Alzheimers and Parkinsons Disease
Words: 1386 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health Paper #: 32127824

Abstract Alzheimer’s disease is a type of dementia, while Parkinson’s disease is known as a debilitating neurodegenerative disease that affects significantly more men than women. The two disorders have some similar symptoms but are also very different. With regards to treatment, no standard intervention has been developed for the treatment of Alzheimer’s disorder. The only existing drugs are those that address some of the symptoms. Likewise, there is no standard therapy

Stem Cell Research Should Have More Government
Words: 2639 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 86899350

Stem Cell Research Should Have More Government Funding The topic argument "Stem cell research government funding." For paper, construct argument defending a claim policy. Remember argument based a claim policy, writer seeks solve a problem establish a problem exists, part argument entail claims fact Stem cell research should have more government funding A stem cell can be defined as type of cell that can be found in many body tissues. Stem cells can

Stem Cell Research -- Ethical
Words: 2928 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 1705529

but, Cuomo continued, Bush's position "…remains a minority view" (Hurlbut, 822). Christine Todd Whitman, who served Bush as administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency in Bush's first term (she served from January 2001 to May 2003), and was the first female governor of New Jersey, supported embryonic stem cell research. Whitman noted in her book that right after Bush was re-elected in 2004, Christian conservative organizer Phil Burress was heard