Verified Document

IR Journal Who Started The Research Proposal

6. First off, we should discuss the differences between system level theories and state level theories. What are the benefits to studying international relations at the state level? What are the drawbacks?

In its most basic formulation, state level theories of international politics refer to those ideas which place the country at the core of political actions and decisions. Examples of this sense include the previously discussed realism and transnationalism schools of thought, which argue that the state places itself based on its particular interests. The relevant example of system level theories refers to the class system theories, and they are characterized by the fact that decisions and actions in international politics are not established based on national interests, but relative to the desires and power of specific groups -- generally those which possess large accumulations of capitals.

The analysis of international politics through the lenses of state level theories pin points to the existence of numerous benefits as well as limitations. The following lines succinctly reveal these advantages and disadvantages.

Benefits of state level theories:

It offers a universal look at what the country's position is in ensemble

It allows comparisons across countries

It simplifies the process of historic studies

Limitations of state level theories:

The centralized approach may not represent a faithful depiction of the feelings and interests of all citizens, but just the decisions of the political leaders

The action of the country may have been decided by a biased individual who was seeking his own interest rather than the well-being of the country

State level theories allow for the creation of stereotypes and could easily include untrue generalizations

7. How do individual level theories differ from both the state and system level theories? What are the benefits to studying international relations at the individual level as opposed to the system and state level?

The most relevant example of individual level theories is that of the feminist studies into the forces which drive and characterize international relations. This approach is extremely criticized for its shortages relative to the state and system level approaches. For once, there is the most important difference given by the actual focal point of the study. While the latter reveal the interests, decisions and actions of a wide group of people, the individual level studies only focus on the person. The second difference is given by the loss of credibility and relevance manifested by the individual level theories. Finally, the third difference is given by the character of the final report in the meaning that the system and state level theories are based on more technical and factual information, whereas individual level studies tend to be more subjective, as they are based on the forces which influence the individual at the center of the respective study. This means that the individual level study can be approached as an interesting piece of information, but not entirely relevant and useful in a strict context.

Regardless of these differences, and mainly limitations of individual level theories of international relations, fact remains that this approach generates a series of advantages, including the following two ones:

It reveals individual forces which could easily be overlooked in state and system level approaches, but which are relevant to a specific category of citizens

It gives the sense that it speaks directly to the individual; this basically...

Discuss some of the criticisms of peace studies theory. Do you believe that today's world makes this type of theory "unrealistic"?
The core element of peace studies is that they strive to identify means of preventing conflicts from emerging. If however conflicts have indeed commenced, peace studies strive to find ways to resolve them through the implementation of the most peaceful means possible and with the assurance that both, or all, parties involved get out of the conflict feeling like winners. Personally, not only that today's global context makes this concept unrealistic, but human nature in its essence, history and man make it unrealistic -- it is a utopia.

Literary criticisms of peace studies is generally scarce and the explanation in this sense is simple -- peace studies have initially been recognized as utopian and the academicians and other scholars recognized the futility of wasting their time criticizing a concept that is in its essence unrealistic. Nevertheless, some arguments against peace studies state the following:

Peace studies seldom offer technical information on how conflicts could be resolved for the benefit of all parties, but simply argue this necessity

When they do promote suggestion for conflict resolutions, they make use of political and economic arguments, but these historians are not specialized in economic or politics, meaning as such that the relevance of their solutions is limited, if at all existent

They produce graduate students with degrees in an unrealistic field of study

The promote interstate tensions as they generally present the most powerful countries, today the United States of America, as the party holding most of the responsibility and blame for the emerged conflicts

Peace studies are "incoherent, incapable of being a serious topic of study, and loaded with political bias" (Sayre, 2003).

Sources used in this document:
References:

Camestaro, N.A., Realism and Transnationalism: Competing Visions International Security, Boston University, Retrieved from http://www.bu.edu/law/central/jd/organizations/journals/international/volume25n1/documents/113-162.pdf on October 5, 2009

Hobson, J.M., the State and International Relations, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0521643910

Kemos, a., the Influence of Thucydides in the Modern World, Hellenic Resources Network, http://www.hri.org/por/thucydides.html last accessed on October 5, 2009

Sayre, B., 2003, Peace Studies' War Against America, Canadian Center for Teaching Peace, http://www.peace.ca/peacestudiescriticism.htm last accessed on October 5, 2009
Why did the U.S.A. And USSR become Rivals in the Period 1945 to 1949? Greenfield History Site, http://www.johndclare.net/cold_war1_answer.htm last accessed on October 5, 2009
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Vietnam War Explained Through the
Words: 1569 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

This ability to use the bipolar system to its advantage helped North Vietnam to win its war for independence and to take over South Vietnam in 1975. Realism not only fully explains the actions of each state in this conflict, but it also predicted the outbreak of war as soon as ideology became the focus of the debate on Vietnam. In Conclusion, the Vietnam War was an excellent example of

Senkaku Islands
Words: 2236 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

International Relations The Senkaku Islands in the South China Sea have become a warm zone, with China and Japan in particular engaged in military exercises in the region. The United States is another major player, offering full support to Japan including sending military vessels to the disputed area and threatening response should China try to seize the islands from Japan (McCurry & Branigan, 2014). The Senkaku Islands are presently uninhabited, but

Urban Outfitters Case Study Urban Outfitters Has
Words: 1592 Length: 4 Document Type: Case Study

Urban Outfitters Case Study Urban Outfitters has defined a highly differentiated and unique shopping experience, supported by the eclectic and highly varied store layouts and merchandise strategy. This approach to retailing appeals to the individuality and uniqueness every consumer also sees in themselves, allowing the consumers to define themselves by what they like. INA actuality, Urban Outfitters is more aligned to key marketing concepts and strategies than its much larger and

Managing Diversity Matters a Study on Qantas
Words: 3911 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Managing Diversity Matters A Study on QANTAS Women Representation at QANTAS QANTAS' Focus on Diverse Needs of Customers QANTAS Ideology Regarding Recruitment of Youth Challenges Faced By QANTAS In today's challenging global scenario where competition is rising every day, it is necessary for Multinational organizations to address the basic need of today's business world: diversity. Customers, employees, strategic alliances, competitors, industry norms etc.; they are all subject to changes every day. This is the reason

Gillette Company's Global Strategy Today,
Words: 8412 Length: 31 Document Type: Term Paper

His ideas are not important for their uniqueness (though they are singular), but because of the essential similarities between his conservative business utopia and other versions of collectivism" (Gilbert, p. 12). This biographer reports that King Camp Gillette was born in January 1855, the fifth of seven children, to George Wolcott Gillette and Fanny Camp Gillette, in Fond du Lac, Wisconsin; when King was four years old, the family

Immigration and Crime in DENMARK& 8230;
Words: 2354 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Proposal

Questia.com/PM.qst?a=o&d=5001784438>. This work is a consummate discussion of the strain that immigration has placed on the public and social systems of Denmark, as another example of the strain and stress pulling public opinion in favor of anti-immigration. Kirkwood, R. Cort. "The Gathering Storm: Islamic Violence in France, Fostered by French Anti-Christian Political and Cultural Elites, Gives a Glimpse of What Our Own Elites Are Bringing upon Us Via Uncontrolled Immigration." The New

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now