Political Context Of Educational Theory Term Paper

PAGES
3
WORDS
1123
Cite

¶ … educational theories in the light of political context. Hence the paper provides a springboard for insight into some essential interconnections between educational approaches and movements, motivational goals of the researchers and the varied opinions of the educationists and experts, through presenting alternative arguments. The Works Cited three sources in MLA format. The Political Context of Educational Theory: Alternative Arguments

Where all believe in the significance of education for the development of personality and for the welfare of the nation, many support the various important and blatant theories and educational movements. However, there is still a decent number that presents alternative arguments in their effort to prove that educational research (and related public funding) world-over is being used not only as a tool to inculcate sense of discipline and responsibility but also to gain political ends.

Following passages of the research paper will present arguments from various educationists and researchers thereby quoting examples cited by them in support of their alternative arguments.

In educational research society, large number of researchers and educationists are interconnected in some way or the other, usually forming groups with the ones sharing similar viewpoints on a certain theory or a movement in the field of education. Therefore, there always follows a chain of arguments.

For instance, when Dr. Strauss questioned the validity and adequacy of the reading research program as...

...

Stone, arguments that were countered again by Strauss in clarification of what he meant by what he said, refuting Stones claim as well as examples. Dr. Strauss considered the nature of reading research program by Lyon as inadequate for the masses. According to him, the program abandons "social and psychological components of reading" (Stone: 31-32). Moreover, he was of the view that without eradication of socioeconomic discrepancies existing in the United States, rate of illiteracy cannot be diminished, an angle that the schema of NICHD lacks, for the active experimentation that involves unnatural ways of gauging and drafting educational programs assists little to ameliorate the contemporary educational arena. Stone counteracts the opinion by Strauss, for the researcher advocates the Institute on its efforts to experiment with the recent findings believing in and presenting another view that even if experiments and innumerable studies conducted are impractical, paper work alone is insufficient for obtaining desired goals. Thereby asserting the notion that for a drastic positive change in educational policy, "rigorous experimentation" is strongly needed (Stone: 31-32). Dr. Strauss has refuted this opinion of experimentation needed urgently for the betterment of educational standards. Alternately, the neurologist clarified both his position and his opinion by giving examples of anthropological explorations (Strauss: 32-33) where experimental approach is not only irrelevant but is a waste of public funding linking it with educational reading which is an act wherein experimentation is flawed in comparison with descriptive form of research and practice, shedding light on the faulty "alphabetic principle," the basis for NICHD research program, which neglects the highly important functioning of symbols (Strauss: 32-33).
Furthermore, Stone refutes the opinion by Strauss while commenting on his article. He strongly disagrees with Strauss on the point that naturally available perfect conditions are the best means for enhancing reading and learning skills in children (Stone: 31-32). Alternately, Stone supports Lyon in employing synthetic approaches for the sound education…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Stone J.E. Comment on "An Open Letter to Reid Lyon." Volume 30, October 2001. Pages: 31-32. Available at http://aera.net/pubs/er/index.html (October 20, 2002)

Strauss S.L. "Methodology, Medical Metaphors and Mental Health: A Reply to J.E.

Stone." Volume 30, October 2001. Pages: 32-33. Available at http://aera.net/pubs/er/index.html (October 20, 2002)

Quigley M. "The Roots of the I.Q. Debate; Eugenics & Social Control." Public Eye
Magazine, Vol. IX, No. 1, 1995. Available at: http://www.publiceye.org (October 20, 2002)


Cite this Document:

"Political Context Of Educational Theory" (2002, October 21) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-context-of-educational-theory-137055

"Political Context Of Educational Theory" 21 October 2002. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-context-of-educational-theory-137055>

"Political Context Of Educational Theory", 21 October 2002, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/political-context-of-educational-theory-137055

Related Documents

Educational Theory: Dewey vs. Eliot The contrast between the contemporary educational theories of John Dewey and Charles W. Elliot cannot be subsumed under the dichotomies of 'right and wrong' so much as the two men's different sociological contexts, although the two men expressed contempt of one another during their respective lifetimes. Overall, Dewey stressed the idea of education through one's pursuit of a vocation and Charles W. Eliot's stressed the need

Nearing the end of the 1960s, the analytic or language philosophy became the central focus point which led to the isolation of the classroom setting and the problems that came with it (Greene, 2000). Most of the educational philosophers of the time were inclined towards restricting themselves to the official aspects and problems like the sovereignty of the system without any influence from the society and the surrounding environment and

This theory therefore supports the idea of "… education as a force to enhance personal grow and development & #8230; stress self-actualization; freedom and responsibility & #8230;" ( Popovic) On the other hand, the critical/emancipatory approach as found in the writings of Paulo Freire and Ira Shor, while similar to the above, has the important difference of emphasizing the social, political and cultural context. From this point-of-view the emphasis is

EDSE 600: History and Philosophy of Education / / 3.0 credits The class entitled, History and Philosophy of Education, focused on the origin of education and the "philosophical influences of modern educational theory and practice. Study of: philosophical developments in the Renaissance, Reformation, and revolutionary periods; social, cultural and ideological forces which have shaped educational policies in the United States; current debates on meeting the wide range of educational and social-emotional

This view is reflected in increasing calls for financial equity among schools, desegregation, mainstreaming, and standardized testing for teachers and students alike; it has been maintained that by providing the same education to all students, schools can equalize social opportunity (Bowman, 1994). This latter position is typically followed up with the use of a particular curriculum designed to support the approach. In this regard, Bowman suggests that, "Knowledge is thought

Political Issues in Higher Education and Leadership The present world is dynamic in various perspectives related to economic development, political stability and international affairs. As 21st century has paved ways for globalization, the trade barriers are eliminated. This development is paving ways for promotion of international culture and national identities are at stake. With increased globalization and free movement of people from one part of the world to the other, the