Discussion Board Forum : Ethnography and Historical Research: Reply to Jacob and Laura
Original post:
Fieldwork, regarded as the core of organizational ethnography, profoundly enriches our understanding of the subtle dynamics at play within organizations. With its hallmark feature of immersive engagement, this approach allows researchers to dive deeply into the heart of an organization. They involve themselves in the organization's daily routines, interactions, and traditions, becoming a fly on the wall within the living, breathing organism of the workplace. By embedding themselves in this manner, researchers can unearth rich, qualitative data that might remain hidden or inaccessible through more traditional, detached methods such as surveys (Ct-Boileau et al., 2020).
The depth of knowledge gleaned from such an immersive approach is invaluable, illuminating an organization's cultural underpinnings, processes, and inherent complexities with unparalleled detail and authenticity. This approach aligns with the wisdom in Proverbs 18:15, "An intelligent heart acquires knowledge, and the ear of the wise seeks knowledge" (English Standard Version Bible, 2001). Through such immersive research, a nuanced understanding is fostered, generating insights beyond surface-level phenomena and allowing researchers to grasp the complexities of organizational life. As we navigate through the digital age, the landscape of organizational ethnography has been significantly enriched by integrating digital technologies. Emerging only in the last five years, digital ethnography has presented a paradigm shift in approaching ethnographic research (Oreg & Babis, 2023). Digital ethnography extends the reach of the ethnographer, enabling researchers to examine virtual workplaces, which have become increasingly prevalent due to the burgeoning culture of remote work arrangements.
The advent of digital ethnography has unlocked new opportunities for data collection. It empowers researchers with the ability to analyze digital communications, an often underappreciated but rich source of data. Furthermore, it enables researchers to use online platforms for participant observation, expanding the scope of ethnographic fieldwork to include the digital sphere. Simultaneously, organizational ethnography has increasingly emphasized reflexive methodologies (O'Reilly, 2011). Reflexivity encourages researchers to engage in a critical self-examination of their role within the fieldwork process. It prompts them to acknowledge their influence on the research process and adopt an interpretive stance incorporating this self-awareness, thereby enriching the depth and authenticity of their findings. These advancements have far-reaching implications for public administration. Digital ethnography allows public administrators to comprehensively assess remote working structures within government organizations. These insights can inform policies on work arrangements and digital infrastructure, enabling public organizations to adapt and thrive in the digital age.
Reflexive methodologies, in contrast to more traditional approaches, offer a more granular and context-sensitive understanding of the relationships between public administrators and their constituents. This method prompts researchers to continuously introspection and critically examine their influence on the research process and its impact on them. This reflexivity creates a feedback loop that can help to expose any areas of bias, preconceptions, or misunderstanding that may unwittingly skew data interpretation or conclusions. The intention is to challenge one's assumptions, cultivate a more holistic understanding of the phenomena under investigation, and ultimately strive for greater authenticity and validity in the research findings.
Adopting a reflexive approach in public administration can greatly augment service delivery and foster community engagement. An example is the recognition that public administrators' biases or preconceptions can impact their interactions with constituents. By acknowledging this, administrators can develop policies and programs that are more equitable and responsive. Individuals can identify potential gaps in comprehension or distorted perceptions of a given scenario. The insights possess the potential to provide direct guidance for enhancing the delivery of public services, thereby rendering them more responsive to the actual requirements and circumstances of the respective communities they cater to. Nevertheless, implementing these novel methodologies is not devoid of intricacies and obstacles. Using reflexive methodologies with digital ethnography presents a significant obstacle in safeguarding privacy and confidentiality within digital domains. The widespread prevalence of digital communication channels and the simplicity with which data can be exchanged and distributed magnify the likelihood of confidentiality violations. Public administrators must confront the challenge of safeguarding confidential data while conducting genuine and comprehensive research.
The challenge highlights the significance of rigorous ethical protocols in the realm of public administration, where the establishment of public confidence is of utmost importance. Ethical considerations are not limited to adherence to regulations but embody the core principles of public service. The passag of Romans 13:1-7 emphasizes the obligation of individuals in positions of power to administer their duties with fairness and honesty while prioritizing the publics welfare. The present excerpt establishes a scriptural basis for the moral obligations of public officials, underscoring their obligation to act most advantageously for the populace they are tasked with serving. The convergence of reflexive methodologies and digital ethnography holds significant potential and intricate difficulties for the field of public administration. Public administrators can serve their communities effectively and justly by balancing innovative methodologies' potential benefits with a steadfast commitment to ethical principles. This requires navigating the complexities that arise from such methodologies.
To conclude, it is undeniable that fieldwork plays a pivotal role in organizational ethnography by enabling the dissection of the intricacies of organizational dynamics. Given the dynamic nature of the...
…recognition that public administrators' biases or preconceptions can impact their interactions with constituents. By acknowledging this, administrators can develop policies and programs that are more equitable and responsive. Individuals can identify potential gaps in comprehension or distorted perceptions of a given scenario. The insights possess the potential to provide direct guidance for enhancing the delivery of public services, thereby rendering them more responsive to the actual requirements and circumstances of the respective communities they cater to. Nevertheless, implementing these novel methodologies is not devoid of intricacies and obstacles. Using reflexive methodologies with digital ethnography presents a significant obstacle in safeguarding privacy and confidentiality within digital domains. The widespread prevalence of digital communication channels and the simplicity with which data can be exchanged and distributed magnify the likelihood of confidentiality violations. Public administrators must confront the challenge of safeguarding confidential data while conducting genuine and comprehensive research.The challenge highlights the significance of rigorous ethical protocols in the realm of public administration, where the establishment of public confidence is of utmost importance. Ethical considerations are not limited to adherence to regulations but embody the core principles of public service. The passage of Romans 13:1-7 emphasizes the obligation of individuals in positions of power to administer their duties with fairness and honesty while prioritizing the publics welfare. The present excerpt establishes a scriptural basis for the moral obligations of public officials, underscoring their obligation to act most advantageously for the populace they are tasked with serving. The convergence of reflexive methodologies and digital ethnography holds significant potential and intricate difficulties for the field of public administration. Public administrators can serve their communities effectively and justly by balancing innovative methodologies' potential benefits with a steadfast commitment to ethical principles. This requires navigating the complexities that arise from such methodologies.
To conclude, it is undeniable that fieldwork plays a pivotal role in organizational ethnography by enabling the dissection of the intricacies of organizational dynamics. Given the dynamic nature of the field, characterized by the adoption of novel methodologies and technologies, public administrators must remain current with these advancements. By utilizing these technological advancements, individuals can augment their comprehension of organizational culture, formulate more knowledgeable and efficacious policies, and ultimately furnish superior service to the populace. Remaining current with these developing methodologies improves public administration's efficiency and efficacy. The idea aligns with the biblical concept of stewardship, which emphasizes the responsible management of resources, encompassing knowledge and technology, to optimize their utility for advancing the common good. Organizational ethnography enhances our comprehension of organizational dynamics, enabling us to devise practical strategies…
References
Côté-Boileau, E., Gaboury, I., Breton, M., & Denis, J. (2020). Organizational ethnographic case studies: Toward a new generative in-depth qualitative methodology for health care research? International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 19. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406920926904 Links to an external site.
English Standard Version Bible. (2001). ESV Online. https://esv.literalword.com/ Links to an external site.
O’Reilly, K. (2011). Ethnographic Methods. Routledge.
Oreg, A., & Babis, D. (2023). Digital ethnography in third sector research. International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 34, 12-19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11266-021-00397-9 Links to an external site.
Reply to Jacob:Your discussion concerning digital ethnography was especially interesting since an increasing number of human interactions are taking place in online environments. Likewise, digital ethnography provides social science researchers with significant potential for investigating the experiences and practices within organizations of all sizes and types (Jensen et al., 2020). In addition, the goals of digital ethnography are aligned with other types of ethnography research since it also provides a rigorous research approach that yields unique and contextually rich knowledge, exceeding the conventional limitations of digital research methods.
Further, you make a good point that while traditional ethnographies have contributed to the understanding of social, cultural, and motivational aspects of teaching and learning in offline settings, digital ethnography opens new avenues for exploring these dynamics within the digital space (Jensen et al., 2020). Finally, your selected biblical passages were highly relevant and inspiring. In sum, gaining fresh ethnographic insights into organizations is congruent with Proverbs 27:23 (NIV) which counsels, “Know well the condition of your flocks, and give attention to your herds.”ReferencesJensen, L. X., Bearman, M., Boud, D., & Konradsen, F. (2022). Digital ethnography in higher education teaching and learning—a methodological review. Higher Education, 84(5), 1143–1162.
Original post:In conducting fieldwork, researchers can learn about the organization's principles and norms by observing how people interact with one another and their surroundings. Fieldwork helps researchers better understand the dynamics of an organization, including its structure, hierarchy, and decision-making procedures. In organizational ethnography, fieldwork plays a crucial role. Fieldwork is crucial for gathering information and formulating hypotheses. In ethnography, data is collected by human observation and interaction in a local setting, using the researcher as the primary data collector. Ethnographic methods are diverse, and a range of approaches can be adopted, but it is the depth of fieldwork and the continuous process of engaging with participants and their natural environments that is central and adds strength to the findings of ethnographic studies (Jones & Smith, 2017). Participant observation requires the researcher to be an insider in the field of inquiry, often an experienced practitioner, and being reflexive and cognizant of pre-conceived perceptions about practice is essential to ensure the validity of the findings (Jones & Smith, 2017). Identifying the community and establishing a baseline profile covering a range of economic and sociocultural variables is the next step in collecting field data. Researchers observe and interview community members in their natural setting, which helps build knowledge of a community by observing its members and interacting with them. By filling gaps in our knowledge of a community whose beliefs and behavior affect federal programs, ethnography can improve federal programs and policies. After identifying the community and establishing a baseline profile that covers a range of economic and sociocultural variables, field data collection begins. By filling knowledge gaps about a community whose beliefs and behavior affect federal programs, ethnography contributes to improving federal programs and policies.
The fieldwork part of organizational ethnography involves conducting research in the natural environment of the organization being studied. Research allows researchers to see and interact with individuals and groups within an organization, gaining a deeper understanding of their behaviors, attitudes, and beliefs. Researchers can also collect rich and detailed data through fieldwork methods such as participant observation, interviews, and document analysis. A comprehensive understanding of the organization's culture, practices, and dynamics can be developed using this data. During fieldwork, researchers can immerse themselves in the organization, observing, recording, and examining its culture. Fieldwork provides researchers with a better understanding of the organization's background, principles, and activities. By using this technique, researchers can uncover hidden meanings and widespread understandings that are not immediately apparent. An organization's rules and values might be revealed by observing how people interact with one another. Fieldwork allows researchers to gain insight into the organization's decisions and procedures. Conducting fieldwork allows researchers to examine how choices are formed and how people react to different situations. Additionally, they can gain insight into the company's management style and organizational design. Through fieldwork, researchers can learn more about the organization's external environment, including its competitors, clients, and suppliers. During fieldwork, researchers can observe how people interact with one another and their surroundings in order to build theories about how different variables may affect an organization's success. Last but not least, fieldwork is a crucial tool for involving stakeholders. Researchers can interact with stakeholders on the ground and learn about their viewpoints. This can aid researchers in gaining a new perspective on the organization and in identifying areas that could want improvement.
In conclusion, Fieldwork is an essential aspect of organizational ethnography as it involves the direct observation and participation of the researcher in the organizational setting (Akemu & Abdelnour, 2020). It allows the researcher to gain an in-depth understanding of the organizational culture, practices, and processes (Akemu & Abdelnour, 2020). The importance of fieldwork in organizational ethnography can be summarized as follows:Fieldwork enables the researcher to collect rich and detailed data about the organizational setting, which can be used to develop authentic accounts of organizational life.
It allows the researcher to observe and interact with research participants in their natural setting, which can provide insights into their behaviors, attitudes, and beliefs.
Fieldwork can help the researcher to identify and capture marginalized voices that may be overlooked in other research methods.
It allows the researcher to develop a rapport with research participants, which can facilitate access to sensitive information and improve the quality of data collected.
Fieldwork can help the researcher to identify and address ethical concerns that may arise during the research process.
Fieldwork is a crucial aspect of organizational ethnography that enables the researcher to develop a deep understanding of the organizational setting and the people who inhabit it (Akemu & Abdelnour, 2020). The above paragraphs affect public administration because a career in public administration. To understand the dynamics and the people that they represent, one should observe and interact. Developing a deep understanding of the organizational setting and the people who inhabit it can help public administrators to identify the unique organizational culture of the agency and how it affects organizational performance. Administrators can also use this understanding to develop effective strategies to change the organizational culture if necessary (Wilkins & Ouchi, 1983). Despite the fact that local organizational culture may not always contribute to organizational efficiency, it is important to understand its properties when they do. A public administrator who understands the organizational culture and the people who inhabit it is better able to manage it to improve performance (Wilkins & Ouchi, 1983).
God has established a community in which we are expected to participate in good times and bad, regardless of our preferences. “Above all, keep loving one another earnestly, since love covers a multitude of sins”-1 Peter 4:8 (ESV).
References:Akemu, E. O., & Abdelnour, S. (2020). The physicality of the field: Exploring fieldwork in organizational ethnography. Human Studies, 43(3), 295-312.
Evans, M. J. (2009, January). Applied Ethnography and Park Management at Pipestone NationalMonument. In The George Wright Forum (Vol. 26, No. 3, pp. 80-84). George Wright Society.
Jones, M., & Smith, J. (2017). The system approach in organizational ethnography. Journal of Organizational Ethnography, 6(2), 156-179.
Kashid, A., Bhattacharya, S., & Bhagwat, A. (2015). Ethnography: A tool to understand organizational culture. International Journal of Business, Humanities and Technology, 5(2), 86-91.
Rashid, S., Iqbal, S., & Masud, T. (2019). Ethnography in medical education: A systematic review. Medical Teacher, 41(12), 1446-1454.
Sandberg, J., & Copes, R. (2013). The use of fieldwork in organizational ethnography. Journal of Organizational Ethnography, 2(3), 323-343.
Wilkins, A. L., & Ouchi, W. G. (1983). Efficient cultures: Exploring the relationship between culture and organizational performance. Administrative science quarterly, 468-481.
Reply to Laura:Your post helps underscore the overarching goals of organizational ethnographers to provide a voice for marginalized individuals and to identify opportunities for improvement. Indeed, rather than just an interesting academic exercise, fieldwork enables researchers to gain insights into decision-making processes, organizational design, and external factors that may have a profound effect on the organization's success. In addition, the post recognizes the centrality of fieldwork in involving stakeholders and gaining their perspectives, which can provide valuable insights and identify additional areas for improvement. In fact, the Bible encourages people to “think outside the box” when searching for elusive answers. In this regard, Romans 12:2 (ESV) emphasizes that the faithful should “not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect.” One minor issue that I felt needed highlighting was your observation that, “Despite the fact that local organizational culture may not always contribute to organizational efficiency, it is important to understand its properties when they do.” In reality, it is especially important to develop a comprehensive understanding of the properties of local organizational culture when it detracts from organizational performance (Kiaos, 2023).
ReferencesKiaos, T. (2023). An interpretative framework for analyzing managerial ideology, normative control, organizational culture and the self. Cogent Business & Management, 10(1), 1–17.
Organizational performance can be measured in terms of financial, output metrics, or market share performance. An organization is considered to achieve high performance if it is able to demonstrate growth in its all aspects of organizational performance metrics. The three key criteria to measure organizational performances in all industries are as follows: Financial performance (profits, return on assets) Product and market performances (sales, market share) Shareholder returns (total shareholder return, economic value added) An
Organizational Performance Management Emergency Medical Services & Pharmacies Long-Term Health Care Physicians' Offices Hospitals This paper written organizations. • Discuss influence regulatory accreditation standards performance-management systems. Organizational performance management The main purpose for the health care industry is to serve patients in the most effective, safe, and efficient manner. Each organization in this industry functions differently. However, there are some functions and regulations that the organizations will share. These regulations provide the organizations
Performance Appraisals Within most organizations, performance measurement is the process in which an organization establishes certain parameters regarding the level of expectations and output with internal staff, external vendors, systems, product quality, and overall ROI. The fundamental purpose of such measurements should be directly related to both improving business and be able to directly evaluate how resources (human or otherwise) are performing. To do so, and to provide outcome that is
Organization Performance Assessment Organizational performance assessment can be defined as a process of evaluating the performance of an organization against some well defined goals and targets. It lays much emphasis on the accomplishments of an organization in relation to its mission and the stated objectives. In the situation of a government department, the assessment would check the major mandates, ambitions, priority and the performance schedules and evaluates the advancements that have
According to Auteri, "The ratio of managers to specialists was extremely high. This situation was due in part to the former practice of rewarding employees by moving them to a higher level in the hierarchy, regardless of organizational requirements" (1994, p. 108), a human resource policy that has since been discontinued. Of particular interest were Auteri's observations concerning how Fiat's organizational culture, like all large organizations, requires time to
This lack of absorption of the HRD into the whole of the organization is clearly evident and poses severe impediments for the HR staff in their implemental role, leave alone any strategic contribution. Faced with an organizational climate that shows compartmentalization, '"Personnel do personnel work and training people do training work," HRD professionals find managing the professional boundaries a grave problem. (McCracken and Wallace, (2000)) In assessment, the summary of
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now