Columbus Carpentry

1

Culture and organizational structure could be playing a significant role in the turnover problem at Columbus Custom Carpentry (CCC). Although a problem of culture is not explicitly stated by any of the stakeholders in the CCC case study, many of the problems described can be traced back to the companys lack of a strong organizational culture.

Culture refers to the shared values, beliefs, attitudes, and practices of the organization. The company's culture may be contributing to the problem if it doesn't align with employees' expectations or if it's not conducive to employee satisfaction and engagement. For example, if the company culture doesn't prioritize work-life balance or doesn't recognize employees' contributions and achievements, employees may feel undervalued and be more likely to leave. This is certainly the case with those in the crating department as well as those on the production line who have left or who have been tempted to leave because they feel their craftsmanship skills have been subbed out for a jig that only requires low-skilled workers. The very fact that culture is not on anyones lips could suggest that culture is a significant problem. It is when no one is speaking about it that the biggest problems seem to go unnoticed or unaddressed.

Organizational structure also plays a critical role in shaping employee behavior and attitudes. The company's structure may be contributing to the turnover problem if it doesn't provide clear communication channels, opportunities for career growth, or a sense of autonomy and control over work. For instance, if employees feel that they don't have a clear understanding of their job responsibilities, or if they are micromanaged, they may become disengaged and look for other job opportunities. At CCC, the only workers who feel somewhat autonomous are those driving the forklifts and this is only because their supervisor is too busy with orders to stand over them and look over their shoulders the way supervisors in all the other departments do.

However, there are other issues as well, and compensation is a big way. Clearly, pay is also a problem among craters especially. They have one of the most difficult jobs at the company, yet they are paid least. This, in fact, is where turnover is highest, too. Those who are newest do not want to stick around long doing this difficult work, which is why they try to move out as quickly as possible. Low pay can contribute to low morale and a lack of motivation among workers, as they may not feel valued or appreciated by the company. This can lead to decreased productivity and quality of work, which can ultimately impact the company's bottom line.

Another contributing factor to the high turnover rate may be the stress that management experiences in most departments. The managers in the case study all express a sense of feeling overwhelmed by problems that are outside their control. They feel a tremendous amount of pressure due to the companys constraints: CCC wants to keep costs low, but it also has to meet customer demand for unique products that big box stores cannot provide. Thus, they are pushed and pulled to do two things at once, and there is little consistency or coordination among the various departments. Bottlenecks occur, damage is done to products, and this impacts sales, which affects everyone. Moreover, this stress may be due to high workload, tight deadlines, or pressure from senior leadership to meet certain targets or goals that are never given clearly defined pathways. This pressure can trickle down to the workers, creating a tense work environment that can lead to burnout and dissatisfaction.

Additionally, when management is stressed, they may not be able to provide adequate support or guidance to their team members, which can lead to confusion and frustration among workers. This can ultimately lead to a breakdown in communication and a lack of trust between management and employees, which can contribute to the high turnover rate. Turnover tends to be the result of many factors contributing to an overall sense of job dissatisfaction. When workers are not satisfied, they go elsewhere. Those in crating, for instance, might like the normal 9-5 shift, but they do not like the pay or the pressure.

2

It used to be the case that the assembly technicians were paid fairly based on their skill level and experience. They required specialized knowledge and training to assemble the products efficiently, and their job also involved a higher degree of physical labor. But now the jig makes the job easier and low-skilled individuals can do the work without knowing anything about the craft. That is why some of the craftsmen are leaving. If the production line is going to be run by low-skilled workers then a comparable wage should be paid them. It does not make sense from a fiscal perspective to pay low-skilled workers to do a job that requires few skills. When the job required craftsmen it made more sense to pay them a craftsmans wage. Craftsmen expect to be compensated at the level of their skill.

At the same time, the argument could be made that the job offers some security to craftsmen, who otherwise have to depend on a trong housing market in order to ensure that they have consistent work. CCC could argue that job security acts as a benefit that could justify a lower wage even for craftsmen at the company....

…means that employees are compensated based on their individual performance rather than just their position or length of service. This can be achieved through a system of performance evaluations and merit-based pay increases or bonuses.

To implement this system, the company would need to establish clear performance metrics for each role and communicate them effectively to all employees. Regular performance evaluations should be conducted to assess how well employees are meeting these metrics and to provide feedback on areas for improvement.

Managers should be trained on how to conduct effective performance evaluations and provide constructive feedback. They should also be held accountable for ensuring that their teams are meeting performance goals and receive appropriate recognition or consequences based on their teams performance.

Finally, the company should establish a fair and transparent pay structure that rewards employees for their individual performance. This may involve setting minimum and maximum pay levels for each position and linking pay increases to performance evaluations. The company should also regularly review and adjust the pay structure to ensure that it remains competitive and fair.

Provide Stress Management Resources for Management

To reduce stress and prevent it from being passed on to workers, Columbus Custom Carpentry could provide stress management resources for management. This could involve providing training on stress management techniques, offering employee assistance programs, and creating a supportive work environment. Resources such as "Stress Management for Dummies" by Allen Elkin and "The Stress Solution" by Rangan Chatterjee would support this plan of action.

Stress management resources for management are important because high levels of stress can have negative effects on both the individual and the organization. Stressed-out managers may struggle to make good decisions, communicate effectively, and manage their teams in a productive and positive way. This can lead to increased turnover, decreased productivity, and a toxic work environment.

By providing stress management resources, Columbus Custom Carpentry can help managers to better cope with stress and build resilience. This can include providing training on stress management techniques such as mindfulness, meditation, and relaxation exercises. Employee assistance programs can also be offered, which provide confidential counseling and support services for employees who are experiencing stress or other personal problems.

Creating a supportive work environment is also crucial for managing stress levels. This could involve promoting work-life balance by offering flexible schedules or remote work options, encouraging breaks and time off, and recognizing the importance of self-care. Managers could also work to create a positive and collaborative culture by fostering open communication, teamwork, and recognition for a job well done.

Overall, the recommended actions would require a significant investment of time and resources, but they would be essential to improving employee satisfaction, reducing turnover, and ensuring that Columbus Custom Carpentry remains competitive in the…