Death Penalty Ethics And Effectiveness Thesis

Length: 10 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Criminal Justice Type: Thesis Paper: #13477407 Related Topics: Death Penalty, Capital Punishment, Life After Death, Unconditional Love
Excerpt from Thesis :

However, sociologists argue that the retributive justice theory suffers due to the lack of appreciation of circumstantial causes involved in the commission of crime. By counting 'free will' as the only factor involved in a crime the deontological thinking lacks in the comprehensive analysis of criminal behavior. For instance the disproportionate number of crimes by the economically disadvantaged African-Americans when compared to Caucasians is a clear instance for external factors that could influence the behavior of a person. In the words of philosopher Thomas. a. Mappes, "Pure retributive thinking seems to presuppose a radical sense of human freedom and its correlate, a radical sense of personal responsibility and accountability for one's actions." [Laurence]

Moral Evaluation

A moral community is based on the principle where each and every member of the community has equal rights to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." [Kenneth Cauthen] Under these circumstances if one person willfully affects the right of the other person to live it is a serious breach of the moral justice principle and undermines the moral structure of the society. Retribution is in order for such acts of violation of basic human rights. However, if we view from a purely spiritualistic standpoint that has unconditional love as its very basis the concept of 'an eye for an eye' and retributive justice does not hold. Atleast in the case of self-defense the commission of murder can be justified but since the crime has already been committed and also incarceration and total isolation from society would be effective in protecting the society from future criminal activities a moral evaluation of death penalty disapproves it. [Kenneth Cauthen]

Capital Punishment High cost and poor deterrence effect

Besides the ethical and moral standpoints of capital punishment, the financial implications of death penalty should also be briefly discussed. Audit reports indicate that capital punishment system is a huge financial burden on the states. For example, it is estimated that for every execution that takes place in the State of California the taxpayers spend roughly $250 million. The capital punishment system costs the state an overall burden of $114 million beyond the costs of keeping prisoners jailed up on a lifetime sentence. Similarly, in Texas, the state with the highest number of executions it is estimated that a capital punishment case costs an average of $2.3 million which is more than thrice the estimated cost of incarcerating a criminal in a high security setting for 40 years. [DPIC 2010]

At a time when our prisons are facing huge funding shortage it is a practical approach to rethink our stand on death penalty. A recent DPIC survey of Police Chiefs also stands to support this standpoint. The police chiefs responding to the 2009 DPIC survey rated death penalty as the least significant way to reduce violent crimes. The police Officers also opined that death penalty was the least efficient method of utilizing taxpayers money. [DPIC, 2010] Going by the violent crime rates there is a bit of an up and down trend in the last five years. The U.S. national violent crime rates stood at 1,382,012 violent crimes in 2008 which is 1.6% above the corresponding rates for 2004 and a 1.9% decrease compared to the 2007 rates. [FBI, 2008] Statistics also suggest that Canada's violent crime rates decreased...

...

[Dave] a recent survey of the presidents of the criminological Societies revealed that 88% of them did not agree that capital punishment helps to reduce crime rates. Data from the FBI survey also seems to validate this point. The northeastern states, which accounted for only 1% of all executions, also had the lowest crime rates across the country. (4.2 per 100,000) the national average rate 5.4 per 100,000[DPIC, 2010] Comparatively Canada's Homicide rate is slightly less than 2%, which is significantly lesser than that of the U.S. homicide rates. These factors clearly suggest that capital punishment is not a successful crime deterrent.

Conclusion

Capital punishment is an important and controversial issue in our judicial system. An analysis of the various supporting theories for capital punishment reveals that the utilitarian theory is the only one that offers enough justification. For instance, executing a terrorist would imply safety for the society at large and in such a case death penalty stands perfectly justified. (Utilitarian thinking) However, in the cases of other criminal subjects there is no conclusive evidence as to the deterrent effect of capital punishment. A serious consideration of alternative punitive measures is in order. On the contrary abolitionist countries such as Canada and Germany have shown significant drop in crime rates. Canada's success in homicide control without capital punishment clearly endorses this approach to crime control. Also, the deontological argument of retributive justice cannot be applicable in a collective social context. Thus we can conclude that capital punishment may be reserved only in cases of barbaric violence (terror acts and serial killers) that pose a serious risk to national and public safety. In all other cases there are no grounds to justify capital punishment and alternative methods of corrective behavior and recidivism control should be vigorously pursued.

Bibliography

1) Amnesty International (2009)' More Executions in Japan as other countries Reject the Death penalty', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Available at, http://www.amnesty.org/en/news-and-updates/news/more-executions-japan-other-countries-reject-death-penalty-20090731

2) Amnesty International, 'The Death Penalty in Canada: Twenty Years of Abolition', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at, http://www.amnesty.ca/deathpenalty/canada.php

3) Bureau of Justice Statistics (2009), 'Executions: Key Facts at a Glance', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Available at, http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/glance/tables/exetab.htm

4) B.A Robinson (1995), ' Capital Punishment: Death Penalty Data', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Updated Dec 07, 2009, Available at, http://www.religioustolerance.org/execut3.htm

5) CBC News (Mar 17, 2009), 'Capital Punishment in Canada', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at, http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2009/03/16/f-death-penalty.html

6) Dave (2009), 'Anti Death Penalty Information', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at, http://davecoop.net/adp.htm

7) DPIC, (2009), 'Facts about Death Penalty', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Updated Feb 17th 2010, Available at, http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/FactSheet.pdf

8) DPIC, ' the Federal Death Penalty', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/federal-death-penalty

9) FBI (2008), 'Violent Crime', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at, http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2008/offenses/violent_crime/index.html

10) Jeff Strayer, 'Utilitarianism and Retributivism on the Death Penalty', Accessed Feb 20th 2010,Available at, http://users.ipfw.edu/strayerj/Ethics/Handouts/death-penalty-handout.PDF

11) Shepherd, Joanna, (June 2004), 'Murders of Passion: Execution Delays, and the Deterrence of Capital Punishment. Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 33, No. 2,

pp. 283-321

12) Dudley Sharp, "Death Penalty as a Deterrent," Accessed Feb 20th 2010,

Available at, http://homicidesurvivors.com/2006/03/20/the-death-penalty-as-a-deterrent--confirmed -- seven-recent-studies-updated-61204.aspx

13) Jeffery Fagan (2006), 'Death and Deterrence Redux: Science Law and Casual Reasoning' OHIO State Journal of Criminal Law, Vol 4.

14) Jean Christophe Merle, (May, 2000), 'A Kantian Critique of Kant's Theory of Punishment', Law and Philosophy, Vol 19, No 3.

15) Laurence, "Capital Punishment: Can Deontologists Justify the Death Sentence?," Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Available at, http://members.optusnet.com.au/[?Y]??????^?????][??[??M?HY^H??  ?X][?[H[???X][??X????Y?X? ? ? L ]?Z[X?H] ??????[?????K?X]?[?[W???W?]??[? ?B??M?H??[?][???K…

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

1) Amnesty International (2009)' More Executions in Japan as other countries Reject the Death penalty', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Available at, http://www.amnesty.org/en/news-and-updates/news/more-executions-japan-other-countries-reject-death-penalty-20090731

2) Amnesty International, 'The Death Penalty in Canada: Twenty Years of Abolition', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, available at, http://www.amnesty.ca/deathpenalty/canada.php

3) Bureau of Justice Statistics (2009), 'Executions: Key Facts at a Glance', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Available at, http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/glance/tables/exetab.htm

4) B.A Robinson (1995), ' Capital Punishment: Death Penalty Data', Accessed Feb 20th 2010, Updated Dec 07, 2009, Available at, http://www.religioustolerance.org/execut3.htm


Cite this Document:

"Death Penalty Ethics And Effectiveness" (2010, February 21) Retrieved August 1, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/death-penalty-ethics-and-effectiveness-14850

"Death Penalty Ethics And Effectiveness" 21 February 2010. Web.1 August. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/death-penalty-ethics-and-effectiveness-14850>

"Death Penalty Ethics And Effectiveness", 21 February 2010, Accessed.1 August. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/death-penalty-ethics-and-effectiveness-14850

Related Documents
Death Penalty Is A Fair Punishment For Murder
Words: 1917 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 9328655

Death Penalty All indications are that capital offenses are on the rise and the response to this phenomenon has been a cry to impose capital punishment as retribution. Certainly the issue is one of the most hotly debated in the world today; both for consideration of its humaneness as well as efficacy as a deterrent. For the purposes of this assignment we will examine the issue from both sides with the

Death Penalty Capital Punishment
Words: 4190 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 97755499

Death Penalty: Social Attitudes and Modern Alternatives The issue of the death penalty raises deep emotions on all sides of the debate. Many feel that the death penalty no longer holds value as a tool for society to prevent heinous crimes. In the past, the prevalence of the death penalty created a measure of deterrence on social behaviors. However, in modern life, there is no longer is a measurable deterrence felt

Capital Punishment the Pros and
Words: 2096 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 28952904

life imprisonment, we must follow common sense and assume that if one punishment is more fearful than another, it will deter some potential criminals not deterred by the less fearful punishment" (p. 282). In an effort to deconstruct the tenability of van den Haag's assertions, Reiman takes the deterrent analogy to an extreme and suggests that the death penalty is insufficient and that death by torture would serve as

Death Penalty As a Deterrent for Murder
Words: 6058 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Capital Punishment Paper #: 25585782

Abstract This paper examines the death penalty as a deterrent and argues that states have not only the right but the duty to apply the death penalty to criminal cases because it is incumbent upon states to back the law with force. The death penalty acts as a forceful and compelling consequence for those who should choose to violate the law and commit murder. For that reason it can be said

Pros and Cons of Death Penalty
Words: 1028 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 78019362

Death Penalty An issue as divisive as the death penalty has many arguments in its favor and many against it. Sorting through these different arguments to find a reasonable conclusion to either support the death penalty or not can be challenging. In terms of favoring the death penalty, there are two main themes, the deterrence theme and the retribution theme (Gill, 2013). Some pros are: Death penalties act as a deterrent for some Death

Kantian Ethics And Utilitarian Ethics Regarding Death Penalty
Words: 4657 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 81397208

Powell points to the fact that "in Georgia, for example, the time between the date of the murder and the murderer's execution (if it occurs) averages close to I0 years 25 Although the average lapsed time in Georgia may be the highest, the same situation generally prevails in a number of other states. No one would suggest that this is satisfactory." (Powell, 1038) Indeed, according to Calvert (1993) it demonstrates