USA World Bank Case Study Thesis

Length: 11 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Business Type: Thesis Paper: #72332397 Related Topics: United States Presidential Election, United States History, History Of The United States, Us
Excerpt from Thesis :

22 (United States Census Bureau). Finally, Best Market Research surveyed a disproportionate amount of those with incomes under $20,000 per year (United States Census Bureau), sample issues that most likely arose from the media of the survey, a survey. In addition to these severe sample discrepancies, the fact that the data was collected significantly earlier than the implementation date of the project is a serious time fallacy. Additionally, the statistical data only collected survey data from customers who logged onto the U.S.A. World Bank's web site. This limits the types of persons questioned to either customers of USA World Bank, those who are interested in USA World Bank, and those who accidentally stumbled onto the bank's web site. Thus, the population will not be random because it includes mostly those who already have a preference toward banking with USA World Bank, making the question regarding changing banks nearly meaningless.

Best Market Research's Question Statement Problems

In addition to the sample data errors, another issue with the sample survey was the wording of is questions. For instance, the questions make assumptions, such as assuming that spouses would know about separate bank accounts, that those in non-marital living arrangements do not have shared accounts, and that ranking information that may be arbitrary. Also, asking demographic information such as race and financial information is likely to produce false results, as people are likely to lie about such features of their lives.

Jim's Data Collection Methodology

Although Jim's attempt to find an accurate representation of the population through focus groups is admirable, his data collection strategies fell short on a few crucial points. Like Best Market Research's survey, Jim's focus groups only dealt with those customers who were already members of USA World Bank. Once again, this makes the question about switching banks nearly irrelevant if the small businesses represented in the survey were already members of the bank in question. Furthermore, this group is obviously already biased toward the bank because they have their accounts, as well as potentially other services and products through this bank. Whether it is because they enjoy banking with the institution, or because the convenience of keeping all of their accounts in the same place is great, current customers of USA World Bank are more likely than others to say that they would appreciate the new products offered by the institution. Though the fact that the surveys were conducted both by e-mail and by postal mail, as Best Market Research's were not, they still subjected themselves to bias through certain aspects of the focus group. For instance, money was offered as an incentive for the CEOs to complete the survey. While this can be construed as simply remuneration for time and honesty, people who needed the money were probably more likely to respond, suggesting that their business' income was lower. Furthermore, the instrument for gathering Jim's data requested that the CEOs and founders make themselves available for a telephone conversation in which to answer the bank's questions. While this method is better than the Internet survey conducted by Best Market Research because it allows for the elimination of customers who are not sure about their answers, it is still subject to sample error because certain CEOs, those whose businesses are doing extraordinarily well, are usually unable to find the time to sit down for a chat with a bank for only $250.

Solution

Although Jim's focus group methodology was significantly less prone to error than Best Market Research's data collection methods, both faced errors. In order to have the best chances of determining which product should be implemented, both Mary and Jim must obtain new statistical data using better methodology. Although focus groups and surveys are two accepted methods of conducting
Once USA World Bank executives know what type of sample they're looking for, it is time to begin polling the sample population. Although focus groups are a perfectly legitimate way to conduct research, in this case, surveys will be much more efficient. In order to eliminate the biases associated with computerized surveys, these surveys should be printed and mailed at random to both individuals and small business owners across the United States and the
world. Paper surveys should come with an attached, postage-paid pre-stamped envelope. To avoid a bias toward those who are older and more likely to answer postal mail, the surveys will be supplemented with a series of telephone surveys, as well as personal surveys of those who are "tagged" while shopping in malls across the United States.

Although this way of conducting surveys suggests an improvement over both Jim and Best Market Research's biased survey information, the questions asked during the survey must be similarly clear and well worded. Along with demographic information, survey questions will address the likelihood of customers and potential customers becoming involved in the Instant Rewards program, along with questions that will ask consumers if they would switch banks in order to be able to take advantage of the program. Instead of asking customers to rank their top benefits, a question that would be useless given that it would simply give ordinal data, customers will simply be asked which of the incentives is their favorite, which they would use and which they would not, and if they would still use the program if only three of the services they would use are offered as rewards. By using this type of questioning, the researchers will be able to gain more insight into what card incentives the potential customers find rewarding.

After giving these new, more accurate survey questions to the truly random sample population, USA World Bank will have more representative data regarding the implementation of the two programs. Data should be studied carefully by more than one expert and analyzed for error. Before the implementation of either program, researchers and executives at USA World Bank must determine whether or not the probability of errors is great enough to result in the retraction of one or both of the programs. Furthermore, this new data may suggest that both Mary and Jim were right: there is a demand for both products in two very different business sectors.

Conclusion

From psychology to business, the use of statistics has greatly influenced institutions in a number of fields to make accurate or semi-accurate predictions about new cures, methods, and products. While statistics have been an invaluable contributor to many fields, the situation at USA World Bank suggests that firms must be cautious when using statistics to make decisions, as statistics can be easily manipulated to represent what certain firms want to hear. Although the CEOs at USA World Bank were confident that their methodology used when collecting the research data for statistical analysis was sound, it took only an experienced statistician to tell them otherwise. When a board meeting could have quickly flown by and a new proposal approved, both time and money had to be spent on collecting new data. Although this is a frustrating situation, Brian commented that he did not care about the money. Implementing the wrong product based on faulty statistics would be more costly in the long run. What the situation at USA World Bank can teach all of those who use statistics in their daily work is that statistics should be used to supplement other data, like the customer comments that Jim and Mary received, and that they should be used with caution, employing careful methodology…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Arsham, Hossein. (2008). Statistical Thinking for Managerial Decisions. Retrieved October 5, 2008, from the University of Baltimore.

Web Site: http://home.ubalt.edu/ntsbarsh/Business-stat/opre504.htm#rrstatthink

News You Watch Says a Lot About How You'll Vote." (2008). Retrieved October 5, 2008 at http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/election_20082/2008_presidential_election/news_you_watch_says_a_lot_about_how_you_ll_vote

United States Census Bureau. (2008). Retrieved October 5, 2008, from the United States


Cite this Document:

"USA World Bank Case Study" (2008, October 06) Retrieved September 19, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/usa-world-bank-case-study-27814

"USA World Bank Case Study" 06 October 2008. Web.19 September. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/usa-world-bank-case-study-27814>

"USA World Bank Case Study", 06 October 2008, Accessed.19 September. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/usa-world-bank-case-study-27814

Purpose of Paperdue.com

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
World Bank Also Sometimes Known
Words: 2431 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 6017945

One way to reform the Bank would be to make it more accountable to an outside body of independent examiners, so that information it generates is not so self-serving and internally generated. In addition, since there have been so many charges of corruption and mismanagement, it is clear divisions such as the "anti-corruption" division are not working, and these areas need to undergo major reform. Perhaps a total reorganization

Case Study on Homeland Security Event
Words: 1951 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Terrorism Paper #: 70589519

Homeland Security Event Over the last ten years, Homeland Security has been focused on dealing with a wide variety of terrorist attacks. In most cases, these incidents usually involve some kind of intelligence indicating that a terrorist related incident was about to occur. One recent example of this happened in October 2011, with a failed assassination attempt on the Saudi Arabian Ambassador. When the news was first announced, this seemed

United States Is the Diversity
Words: 5913 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 62722507

Because of the newer mobility of a significant amount of suburban America, driving to national parks was even more an option. The more people visited the Parks, it seemed, the more of a synergistic effect upon their funding and use (Jensen and Guthrie, 2006). By the Johnson Administration in the 1960s, coupled with more media attention, there was increased public awareness of America's natural treasures. This was now that "Parks

Case Study on Implementing Company Sponsored Childcare
Words: 5099 Length: 19 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 15523232

President, Harper Supply Company The possibility of providing child care assistance to employees Since we last spoke I have been conducting extensive research into the matter of providing some form of child care assistance to the employees of Harper Industries. Needless to say, I have read much, studied much, and learned much. The final form of this reading, studying, and learning is attached to this memorandum. As you know, we had a very

United States Trade Policy With
Words: 3707 Length: 13 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 76454115

Farmers are stated to have become "risk takers, created new markets, developed rural industries and migrated to urban areas. Farmers were no longer slaves to the state..." (1996) Dorn notes the statement of Jianying Zha (1994:202) in the book "China Pop" that: The economic reforms has created new opportunities, new dreams, and to some extent, a new atmosphere and mindsets. The old control system has weakened in many areas, especially the

Israel Internal Security Case Study
Words: 3974 Length: 15 Pages Topic: History - Israel Paper #: 68159475

What are the recognized threats Recognized threats on a national and international level include, expansion of international terrorism, as a result of universal fundamentalist Arab calls for violence against those who oppress Arabs. Israel is at the center of this conflict as the most regionally active, non-Arab state and as a result of historical actions taken by it to maintain itself and its territories, both recognized and occupied. Short contemporary history of