Business - Case Studies -- Term Paper

Length: 15 pages Sources: 15 Subject: Business Type: Term Paper Paper: #72563922 Related Topics: Disruptive Innovation, Business Theory, Case Formulation, Business Decision Making
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Market Analysis

The third principle, that markets that don't exist can't be analyzed, reminds managers that assessing the effects of disruptive technologies is often counter-intuitive to good management practice. Many companies require the development of a business case and a business plan for new products. This approach is generally very successful when applied to sustaining technological innovations, because the market is well-known; however, when companies apply this strategy to new, emerging markets resulting from disruptive technologies, they become paralyzed. They are seeking data on markets that do not yet exist. Christensen concludes that businesses can counteract this principle by planning for failure and taking a discovery-based planning approach to disruptive technologies. Managers should not plan on being right all the time and should view their initial strategy as a learning opportunity. As they gather data, managers must be prepared to make revisions to their business plans.

Capabilities and Disabilities

The fourth principle, that an organization's capabilities define its disabilities, is perhaps the most obvious statement of the difference of the disruptive technology environment. An organization's capabilities lie in its processes and its values, neither of which are as flexible, for example, as the skill sets of an organization. These organizational processes and values develop over time because they help make the company successful in a certain environment. Because these processes and values become ingrained and inflexible, they can impede success in the disruptive technology environment.

Technology Supply and Market Demand

The fifth principle, that technology supply may not equal market demand, illustrates that disruptive technologies do not meet the needs of mainstream markets at the outset (although they do eventually become competitive). Since the pace of technological change is so rapid, and because companies are always focused on developing a more superior product, companies quickly exceed their customer's product requirements. While aiming at the competitors in higher-performance, higher-margin markets, these companies create a vacuum at lower price points in the market into which companies with disruptive technology can enter.

Source: Lewis, 2001, p. 61.

This is an interesting approach to looking at how Exxon is doing business today and how it tends to respond to new forces in its market and potential market - which is to say the entire world. In this regard, Exxon's operations in some parts of the world have been "paralyzed" by terrorism (Dale, 2005) and coping with corruption in developing nations (Naresh, Spieler & Strassfeld, 2006), and remains "paralyzed" on the issue of global warming today (Livesey, 2002). In this aspect at least, Exxon has clearly been also been adversely affected by the capabilities and disabilities component of the disruptive innovation spectrum as it applies to its exploration throughout Asia (Hunter, 2004). For example, in response to increasingly vocal criticisms from many environmentalists, ExxonMobil has been backed into a desperate corporate corner on the issue of global warming, much like its experiences following the Exxon Valdez spill (Boyles, 2005). In that fiasco, Exxon "refused to take the critics seriously, and it suffered long-term for its mishandling of the Alaska oil spill in 1989.... Jurors said one reason for the high penalties was that the Alaska situation showed them that Exxon was a company that could not be trusted and deserved to be punished" (Smith, 2005, p. 22). Likewise, as a result of the environmental issues facing the company today, Exxon has been forced to adamantly maintain that there is no provable link between its exploration and production activities and ecological harms, either "presently manifested or anticipated" (Livesey, 2002, p. 1).

According to this author, "This [approach] uses a strategy by now made familiar in other cases where corporate products or production processes have been alleged to cause toxic effects (e.g., asbestos and tobacco). From the commercial perspective, therefore, any proposed change in business practices, which would impose costs, is unwarranted and said to threaten to 'harm' the 'health' of the economy (Livesey, 2002, p. 2). Because the company's entire existence relates to the very activities which are being cited as the cause of global warming, the company does not have any room to equivocate in its response but must continue to pursue its existing corporate strategy in the face of such criticisms: "ExxonMobil's argument here produces the conclusion that the problem is not global warming, but the wrong-headed, if not arrogant, views of climate scientists (and the misguided government representatives and public who trust them), 'who believe they can predict changes in climate decades from now'" (emphasis added) (Livesey, 2002, p. 117). The company has a number of influential scientists and politicians lined up on its side on this issue as well, but the final principle of disruptive...


According to this author, "The development of the resource-based view of the firm has led numerous scholars to prescribe that firms should focus on developing 'core competences' from which business- and product-level competitive advantage will naturally flow" (Silverman, 2002, p. 2). The nature of these core competences, though, as well as the methods by which organizations are able to exploit them remain unclear, and core competencies do not become readily discernible except through historic analyses; therefore, an improved understanding of how important attributes of technological resources fuel a company's decision to diversify (or to pursue an alternative mechanism of exploitation) would provide some valuable insights into the nature of resource-based rents and their differences across firms and industries (Silverman, 2002). According to Intagliata, Smallwood and Ulrich (2000), core competencies represent a critical aspect of leadership within any type of organization for at least five reasons, including the following:

They guide direction;

They are measurable;

Competencies can be learned;

They can distinguish and differentiate the organization; and,

They can help integrate management practices.

This aspect of Exxon can be viewed in terms of how it has helped the company use its resources to their maximum advantage, a process that as noted above is not as straightforward or concrete as many observers might think. In sum, Intagliata and his colleagues emphasize that like the vision provided by corporate leaders, this feature of strategy is reciprocal and requires constant fine-tuning to avoid complacency and missed opportunities for growth: "Competencies provide organizations with a way to define in behavioral terms what their leaders need to do to produce the results the organization desires and do so in a way that is consistent with and builds its culture. They should provide the 'North Star' by which leaders at all levels navigate in order to create synergy and produce more significant and consistent results" (2000, p. 12). Because core competencies must be quantifiable by definition, then, applying this analysis to Exxon suggests that the company's core competencies should be linked to positive outcomes that can be measured. For this purpose, Intagliata and his colleagues provide some useful metrics as show in Table 2 below.

Table 2.

Relationship between core competencies and key result areas.

Key Result Area

Result Metrics



Changes in employees' knowledge and skill levels;

The extent to which the company's vision is shared among all employees;

Retention/turnover rates (voluntary and involuntary; low vs. high performers);

Employee satisfaction or commitment index;

Employee productivity

Supporting Competencies

Upgrades talent

Coaches and develops

Vision communication

Empowers others


Performance with target customers and market niches;

Customer retention and loyalty;

Differentiated value propositions and disciplined execution of market share vs. profitability trade-offs; and,

Strategically customizes the value proposition.

Marketplace understanding

Builds customer commitment and intimacy;

Strategically customizes the value proposition;

Capital invested across business processes consistent with value proposition

Organization Capability

Extent to which innovative management practices in one unit are shared across boundaries;

Time to introduce new products/service or take them global;

Integration of customers, suppliers, and vendors into business;

Performance management/compensation systems in line with delivery expectations

Builds a learning organization;

Builds speed and agility;

Supports collaboration and teamwork.


Measurement of growth overall and by product, geography, channel, customer, or leverage;

Distinction between work that creates advantage and transactional work that can be outsourced; and,

Analyst's understanding of company and its vision.

Holds self and others accountable;

Focuses on growth;

Resource management;

Financial understanding; and,

Stakeholder relationship building

Source: Intagliata et al., 2000, p. 12.

The effectiveness - and profitability -- of the company's existing strategies in applying its core competencies can be readily seen in one quantifiable aspect of their performance as reflected by its P/E ratio (this is the stock's market capitalization divided by its after-tax earnings over a 12-month period) as shown in…

Sources Used in Documents:


Boyles, D.R. (2005). Schools or markets? Commercialism, privatization and school-business partnerships. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Culpan, R. (2002). Global business alliances: Theory and practice. Westport, CT: Quorum Books.

Dale, J.G. (2005). In dire straits: Why big oil needs transnational regulation. Journal of International Affairs, 59(1), 288.

Exxon. (2007). Yahoo! Finance: Market Guide. [Online]. Available:

Cite this Document:

"Business - Case Studies --" (2007, May 09) Retrieved October 17, 2021, from

"Business - Case Studies --" 09 May 2007. Web.17 October. 2021. <>

"Business - Case Studies --", 09 May 2007, Accessed.17 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Business Case Analysis
Words: 736 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 96685971

Business Case Analysis The Celtel Corporation has operated under strictly plain rules of doing 'clean business'; however, the choice of operating in African states was bound to pose a problem in their business dealings sooner or later when the widespread corruption in the region would catch up in a way that the co-founders, Terry Rhodes and Mo Ibrahim, would not be able to weave around and overcome. Initiating a mobile network

Business Case Kalinsky Was Correct
Words: 931 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 21932724

Thus, Bruce's desire to leave the company was a surprise. Lastly, there was a failure to adequately communicate David's firing quickly. By waiting, Kalinsky opened the situation up to Bruce's interference, which in turn only made the situation worse. Each of these four communication problems contributed to the situation that Kalinsky faced, with two investors seeking to leave the company, including one he did not envision leaving. Many of the

Business Case -- Nordstrom the
Words: 876 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 27270929

This means that the staff at Nordstrom's marketing department needs to implement a continuous process of learning in order to be able to integrate the new technologies within their endeavors. Considering that Nordstrom has decided to enter the Mexican market, they need a strong promotional campaign. A first element of this campaign would be that of advertising the company in itself. This would have the benefit of creating a favorable

Business Case Studies Krispy Kreme
Words: 1716 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 49291182

P&G's free cash flow growth rate is also superior to Gillette's, but the productivity of the free cash flow is inferior. The addition of Gillette is expected to increase P&G's bottom line. 4. The price paid by Procter and Gamble to purchase Gillette seems rather high, but the investment is expected to return in the form of increased sales and cost reductions. The 20% premium is appropriate as it is

Business Case for Single Responder
Words: 1814 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Death and Dying  (general) Paper #: 10780721

Other data has reported that if a person begins to administer CPR alone, then the best chance the collapsed patient has for survival is if EMS arrives with a defibrillator before 8-12 minutes (American Heart Association, 2006). REFERENCES: Cagle AJ, Diehr P, Meischke H, Rea T, Olsen J, Rodrigues D, Yakovlevitch M, Amidon T, Eisenberg M. Psychological and social impacts of automated external defibrillators (AEDs) in the home. Resuscitation. 2008; 76(2):226-32. Cummins,

Business Case for Investment Business and Technology
Words: 2534 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Education - Computers Paper #: 54685742

Business Case for Investment Business and technology investment Kudler Fine Foods is one of the food stores which have always worked towards satisfaction of its customers in every level. With the coming technology it has not been left out and has considered technology investment strategy that will see its customer feel a sense of satisfaction. The paper will analyze the business case for investment of Frequent Shopper Program in Kudler Fine Food. Scope Describing