Classical Criminology Was An Idea Formed Because Essay

Length: 6 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Criminal Justice Type: Essay Paper: #20542206 Related Topics: Criminological Theory, Crime Prevention, Torture, Death Penalty
Excerpt from Essay :

Classical criminology was an idea formed because there was no formal understanding of what caused criminal behavior. In an attempt to make sense of what was deemed socially irresponsible behavior, Cesare Beccaria was determined to formulate a theory that not only helped explain criminal behavior, but also helped to streamline punishment. Before this theory was developed, crime was not studied and the enforcement of crime was very arbitrary. Many times crime was considered a class issue. People in the lower classes were thought to be prone to crime whereas those in the upper classes were generally upstanding citizens. Of course, this could have been because the gentry were making and enforcing the laws. Therefore, the primary context around which Beccaria based his premises was that of justice which was not a primary concern previously. His theory was based on the fact that people are in control of their own fate.


Classical criminology was founded more as a complete approach to dealing with crime, the courts and punishment than just a theory. The idea was that there was no consistent manner in which crime was dealt with, and it was just as likely that a person would admit to a crime under torture, that they did not commit, than the actual perpetrator of a crime would be found. The theory offers a comprehensive look at how crime should be dealt with by the governing system.

The actual theory was about the choices people have, and the poor ones that are made due to selfish interests. "Crime occurs when the benefits outweigh the costs -- when people pursue self-interest in the absence of effective punishments" (Cullen & Agnew, 2002). The theory was not meant to provide the punishments (that was up to the courts) or to elucidate what a crime is or was (that is the job of the law-making body), but the theory did try to explain why people will act in a lawless manner.

One case in literature that follows the classical precepts closely is Jean Valjean in Hugo's "Les Miserables." His initial crime was that he stole a loaf of bread because his sister and her family were starving. The classical theory would look at the crime and see that Valjean looked at the punishment he would receive vs. The benefit of the crime. The benefit was that his family would survive for another day vs. starving to death. The other side of the coin, the punishment, could have been as harsh as death, but he did receive five years in prison for the theft. His was a classical case of weighing the crime and the outcomes, and making a decision to commit a crime based on the fact that the desire for personal gain (even though it was a selfless rather than a selfish act) was greater than the threat of punishment.


The neo-classical school of criminology follows along the same principles of rights, justice and explanation of the causes of criminal behavior that the classical theory does, but it updates the precepts and puts them in a modern context. In classical criminology the concept of imprisonment for a crime was predominant. Punishments were also harsher because the belief in capital punishment for many crimes now deemed lesser offenses...


The primary thrust of the neo-classical school is the use of other methods of deterrence that may have a greater record of success for lesser crimes. Through the use of alternative punishments such as half way houses and home confinement, theorists hoped that petty criminals could be guided to a licit lifestyle. This school also looked into the rights of the prisoner rather than just the rights of the victim of the crime.


This theory was mainly attractive to the legal authority because it had strict objectives that allowed them to construct a framework for punishment based on the crime. Since crime was previously thought of as the interference in a person's life from some supernatural force, this theory put the onus back in the criminal and took the much of the harshness out of the punishment. People realized that the criminal had to be rehabilitated rather than eradicated because of the evil force which caused them to commit the crime.

The four primary of objectives of the theory were: "1) to prevent all criminal offenses through punishment; 2) when it cannot prevent crime, at least to convince offenders to commit a lesser crime; 3) to insure that a criminal uses no more force than is necessary; 4) to prevent crime as cheaply as possible" (Cullen & Agnew, 2002). These are why the theory is so attractive. The primary goal of any police department and court system is to keep the citizens under their watch safe. By letting anyone who wishes to engage in criminal activity the punishment they will receive for a particular act, it is more possible to achieve the two final goals. Punishment is meant to completely deter crime, but another attractive feature is that it should reduce the cost of the crime on two fronts. First, the individual cost, meaning how crime affects people, is greatly reduced if there is a comprehensive and focused theory of crime. Also, the actual monetary expense should be reduced (at least according to the theory).


Europe as a whole was dominated by the thought that criminal activity could only be controlled through extreme means. Torture to exact confessions was the primary way that people were convicted of a crime. However, England stopped exacting confessions via torture long before other European countries did, but England also went to a more republican governmental system (for the people instead of for the monarch) before any of the other European states. The main problem with England prior to the reformation of their penal and justice systems was the way they treated the families of the convicted. First, most felonies carried a death penalty. This also meant that not only the life but the property of the convicted criminal was also forfeited. This left the family of the felon destitute, and did much more to continue the criminal activity than to punish the felon. It was also difficult for the parents of a convicted felon to give an inheritance to their grandchildren.

The impact of the classical criminology theory was to change the way that people thought about crime. It was seen less as a failing of blood (heredity) than a personal failing. Therefore, there was more of a move to rehabilitation and civil penalties were separated from criminal.


It had become, through the positivist school of criminology, the practice to believe that people actions were somewhat beyond their control. People do act with freewill as the classical school says, but there are other factors that are not accounted for in the classical model. The reason that the classical model made a reemergence is that people started believing that choice was a larger factor in why a person committed a criminal act than outside forces (stressors) that may act on them.


Situational crime prevention is basically using modern methods of data gathering to prevent crime. It is not a method that attacks the criminal or makes any statement about the individual in any way. Instead using this method people try to determine the places that crimes occur the most, and they use policing and community response to diminish its occurrence in those areas. A great example of this is when Rudoph Giuliani changed the way…

Sources Used in Documents:


Cullen, F.T., & Agnew, R. (2002). Criminological theory: Past to present (Essential readings). Los Angeles: Roxbury.

Jones, S. (2005). Criminology (3rd Ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tierney, J. (2005). Criminology: Theory and context (2nd Ed.). London: Prentice Hall.

White, R., & Haines, F. (2005). Crime and criminology: An introduction (3rd Ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Cite this Document:

"Classical Criminology Was An Idea Formed Because" (2011, March 20) Retrieved June 14, 2021, from

"Classical Criminology Was An Idea Formed Because" 20 March 2011. Web.14 June. 2021. <>

"Classical Criminology Was An Idea Formed Because", 20 March 2011, Accessed.14 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Criminology: Definitional Sentences Technique of
Words: 2111 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 13763283

All students would be responsible for monitoring the halls at all times and for telling their fellow students when they were violating one of the rules. To give them an incentive to engage in such monitoring, students would be responsible for certain duties, such as picking up litter, removing graffiti, and straightening the lunchroom when students violated school rules. A violation of the rules of the school would be

Classical School Vs. Positivist School
Words: 951 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 74289807

Classical vs. Positivist School of Criminology: Two Clashing Views of the Human, Criminal Animal Although 18th century classical views of criminology should not be conflated with later, modern notions of classical psychological conditioning like Pavlov's dog being trained to salivate at the sound of a bell, there are certain similarities between the two schools of thought and even some of the methods used in classical criminology to reorient criminals back into society.

Classical Causes of Criminal Behavior
Words: 1461 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 88141669

43) Foundation and Focus The foundation for the Classical Theory to crime focused less on the criminal and targeted more on securing a rational, fair system for controlling and putting punishments in order. Little concern was given to causes of criminal behaviors. Significant words/definitions related to this theory include: Classicism - The Enlightenment view of crime that stresses free will and rationality and the corresponding rationality of the justice system.... Free will

Features of Positivist Criminology Positivist Criminology Uses
Words: 1925 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 73017725

Features of Positivist Criminology Positivist criminology uses scientific research (primarily quantitative, laboratory, empirical experiment) to investigate the causes of crime and deviant behavior. Positivist criminology posits that the roots of deviancy are located in the physical, genetic, psychological or biological makeup of the individual and the individual, consequently, is not held accountable (or is faintly held accountable) for his deeds. Use of instruments, statistics, classification, and similar scientific instruments are

Macro Theory of Sociology Regarding the Classical
Words: 580 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Sociology Paper #: 61676320

Macro Theory of Sociology Regarding The Classical tradition and Social Imagination: Overall, what kinds of messages do we inherit from the "classical tradition"? How does the "sociological imagination" inspire and direct our activities as students and practitioners of the social sciences? How might an understanding of the key ideas of long-dead theorists inform how you live your personal life today? How might a reading of the classics benefit your everyday

Task Force Creation
Words: 1045 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 97132609

Terrorist Profiling Task force case study: Creating a new parole policy to reduce crime and expenditures on crime Other than her immediate advisors or cabinet members, who should the governor seek for advice on the plan? The two major areas of controversy that are likely to arise regarding the Utopian governor's plan are how the plan deals with community safety and the need to balance the rights of currently and formerly incarcerated prisoners