Business Ethics How Important Is an Individual's Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Business Ethics

How important is an individual's privacy in the workplace? Is an individual's privacy in the workplace the most important consideration to be taken into account? What constitutes privacy in a workplace environment? Do the goals and the mission of the organization supersede an individual's desire to protect his or her privacy? Is it ethical for an employer to collect and disperse personal information from employees without their knowledge? How does the philosophy of utilitarianism play into this issue? This paper delves into those questions and provides supporting information for the resolution of this issue.

After careful review of the textbook for this course, after reviewing additional scholarly resources and taking into consideration a utilitarian approach to this issue -- and after researching the Australian laws regarding workplace privacy -- this paper takes the position that an individual's privacy is indeed vitally important (and must by law be protected) but not as important as the quality of effort put forward by the employee in terms of teamwork, production, and competency vis-a-vis the goals and purposes of the organization.

Additional backup justification for the thesis

Companies and small businesses are the engines that drive the Australian economy, and government should pass legislation -- and government has passed laws -- to protect individual privacy. But looking at the theory of utilitarianism -- "Actions are right to the degree they tend to promote the greatest good for the greatest number" -- the greatest number in this context is the company itself and all the workers. If a company struggles in the marketplace because a substantial number of employees are giving only 60 to 70% of their best efforts (and the other 30 to 40% of the time they are engaged in personal conversations online or other distractions), that company is failing and this could mean layoffs for workers who depend on their income to support families. Happiness is of course a relative and vague concept; to a company happiness is a healthy bottom line and to middle managers happiness is having your boss be pleased with the production on their units. Because of the diversity of employees in any given work environment, happiness comes in myriad shades and colors.

What is meant by privacy in the workplace?

According to the Australian Government's "Best Practice Guide" (Fair Work Ombudsman), matters of privacy in the workplace relate to what information management has a right to collect and retain. Also, privacy in the workplace entails the question of what information is appropriate for an employer to share with other entities. Privacy entails more than just matters of personal information such as where one was born or a person's financial status. Privacy has to do with "…being able to do things without interference by others," the Fair Work Ombudsman explains.

But basically "personal information" is private information unless an individual worker is willing to disclose that information. Clearly some personal information is legitimately provided to employers (a person's address, age, work experience, and more). But there are matters that are personal and private and should be respected by employers as such. That includes an employee's: sexual preference; political views and associations; religious affiliations; ethnicity; health and genetic information (Fair Work Ombudsman).

The Fair Work Ombudsman explains that federal privacy laws (National Privacy Principles -- NPPs) relate to standards in Australia that employees are obliged to adhere to. When an employer gathers information about a particular employee, that employer should notify the worker that certain information is being gathered -- and moreover, the employer should let the employee know what the purpose is for the gathering of personal information. That said, the employer should also make any information gathered about an employee available for review by that employee.

As to sharing personal information from employees to third parties, the Fair Work Inspector from the government has the right to request information about workers when that information relates to legal obligations the employer must meet. The Fair Work Ombudsman best practice policy permits an employer to disclose personal information when another employer is requesting reference data -- but in most cases, it is considered best practice to notify the employee that his or her performance at work is the subject of an inquiry from a potential employer.

When it comes to the use of email and the Internet while at work, just because an employer gives a new hire a password and login code doesn't mean that the employee's private conversations online are not monitored. Here is an instance in which the employer is using best practice policies by notifying the worker that his or her emails can be (and likely will be) monitored. In addition, it is best practice for the company to be fully open with transparency vis-a-vis notifying the employee as to what is expected, what is prohibited, who has access to personal information and what the consequences are for improper use of the Internet / email.

The Fair Work Act 2009 allows for the collection of personal information on an employee when a complaint is lodged by the employee or: "…when you email or telephone the Fair Work Ombudsman"; when an investigation is ongoing by the Fair Work Ombudsman; or when a Fair Work Ombudsman is auditing a company or a campaign (Fair Work Ombudsman). Regarding the rights of the employee, he or she has the right to be told why personal information is being gathered; and employees have the right to be protected against "unauthorized access" to his or her personal information. In addition, personal information cannot be shared with another person or organization unless the employee gives permission or if the information is "required by law" or "necessary to prevent "…or lessen a serious threat to the life or health of another individual" (Fair Work Ombudsman).

Why is workplace privacy an important issue in Australia?

The fact is that some employers "…unhesitatingly rummage through the files of their workers" even though those files may have "Private" written in big bold letters gives workers pause regarding whether their private information is being shared without their knowledge or permission, according to the textbook. The textbook asserts (p. 446) that employers peek into emails and even "eavesdrop on their employees' phone calls" -- and recent research found that 65% of Australian companies monitor employee emails without notifying employees that this policy is ongoing (446). And there are other apparent violations of employee privacy but the more salient point is found on page 447 of the textbook: "Even when a genuine privacy right is identified, the strength of that right depends on circumstances."

Moreover, it is certainly true in Australia as in other countries that corporations and smaller businesses (and other organizations) do have "legitimate interests that may conflict with the privacy concerns of employees" (447). But the larger question (after taking the previous sentence into consideration) is this: when is it morally justifiable to infringe on employee's privacy?

Rebuttals to points made in previous two paragraphs

While it is wrong for any company to eavesdrop on an employee's emails if the employee has not been notified that this policy is in place, any alert, technology-competent worker knows that his or her emails in a company environment could easily be accessed by supervisors. Employees are working with technology that does not belong to them; therefore, when the company owns the computer and the software and an employee is asked to perform specific tasks on that equipment, it is fair for the company to assume the worker will confine use of those technologies to tasks assigned by the company, and not for personal usage.

Again, this doesn't justify intrusion into personal letters and messages, but unless the worker is sending emails on his or her own smartphone -- or computer -- if a company computer is being used for private, personal communication, all bets are off as far as assuming those communications will remain private.

Certainly companies have the right to expect their workers to dress appropriately and conduct themselves with good behavior. The textbook notes that in some cases an employee might be asked to wear clothing that is provocative. There is a logical rebuttal to that problem: when applying for the position the employee certainly should know what is expected out in front. There may be cases where this is not plainly spelled out, but in most cases the expectations of the company or organization is clearly obvious. If a young woman is applying to Hooters for a job as a server, surely that applicant knows what to expect as far as apparel on the job.

Informed consent on the job

There is a fine line between asking an employee to voluntarily take a personality test and demanding that the employee take the test. If asked to take a test that is said to be "voluntary," then the employee is being offered free choice and should not be docked or in any penalized for refusing to take it. However, once the test is taken, then…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"Business Ethics How Important Is An Individual's" (2012, September 26) Retrieved October 22, 2016, from

"Business Ethics How Important Is An Individual's" 26 September 2012. Web.22 October. 2016. <>

"Business Ethics How Important Is An Individual's", 26 September 2012, Accessed.22 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According

    Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According to Laura Hartman and her co-writer, Joe Desjardins in the work entitled "Business Ethics: Decision Making for Personal Integrity & Social Responsibility" philosophical ethics may be clearly differentiated from theological ethics because theological ethics attempted to disseminate the well-being of an individual on a religious basis while the ethics of an individual's philosophy is such that provisions of justifications that can be applied to

  • Business Ethics in the Fire

    2). These are important issues because fire chiefs are routinely confronted with actual ethical dilemmas that involve conflicting or competing public and private values as well as corresponding conflicting professional responsibilities (Haraway & Kunselman, 2009). This point is also made by Pammer and Killian (2003) who cite the expanded responsibilities of both fire chiefs and line personnel in recent years. According to these authorities, "A successful fire chief today

  • Business Ethics Company Overview Ethics and Code

    Business Ethics Company Overview Ethics and Code of Conduct Guiding Principles Our Ideology; Our Objectives; Our Core Values that shape us; As a part of my Business Ethics lesson I have a task to criticize and improve my company's code of ethics, before doing that I want to briefly explain about my company; MLS Holding and what we do? The most effective statements in regard to business ethics are rooted in the strategic vision of an organization

  • Business Ethics Is a Very Significant Issue

    Business Ethics Ethics is a very significant issue in all businesses because it illustrates the moral values of any given business, according to an article in the peer-reviewed International Journal of Business Administration. This paper reviews and critiques the article. Authors Aytac Gokmen and A. Turan Ozturk present a study of business ethics issues in both domestic and international businesses. Review / Critique of Article The authors posit that ethical behaviors in an

  • Business Ethics Palmeri C& rupp L 2013 May

    Business Ethics Palmeri, C&Rupp, L 2013, May 3, Disney Bangladesh Exit Pressure on Clothes makers Who Stay, Retrieved from The work of Palmeri and Rupp (2013) is focused on highlighting the issues faced by the multinational organizations while operating in developing markets. It is highly likely for large organizations to develop their overseas presence. However the economically developing markets a number of issues including environmental, infrastructural, and compliance with health and

  • Business Ethics Phl 323 Ethics Management Current Ethical

    Business Ethics PHL/323 Ethics Management Current Ethical Issue Business Paper (select a recent article -- back 1 year) • Research information issue deals business ethics a newspaper, magazine, journal, TV, Internet. Current ethical issue in business: Ethics of marketing junk food There are many products which are marketed to the American public which are not 'healthy' such as cigarettes and spirits. However, the issue of food marketing is a more nebulous one, ethically

  • Business Ethics and Morality Many in the

    Business Ethics and Morality Many in the business and sociology fields have attempted to separate the ideas of ethics and morality from religious beliefs. Researchers have worked hard at identifying the principles which hold our societies together from the viewpoint which identifies the common good, or the well-being of the individual or organization as the foundation of moral or ethical behavior. However, this humanistic approach to morality voids the central thesis

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved